Daktoria
Banned
- Joined
- Oct 27, 2011
- Messages
- 3,245
- Reaction score
- 397
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- Political Leaning
- Private
Daktoria-
I figure your sense of history begins with your birth backed up by some talk radio version of what has built the Middle Class.
You have ignored everyone's postings on what per-union factories, coal mines, mills and foundries were like prior to the advent of unions. Farmers formed granges and more urban workers formed Unions.
I suggest you look into pre-Union America, it's workforce with who and how many formed the Middle Class. Then look into the early 20th century expansion of the Middle Class through the post WWII boom.
MILLIONS of Americans rose into the Middle Class simply because now industry had to do more than hire the healthy and fire the crippled. There wouldn't be the enormous Middle Class of today without strong Union action across large sectors of our industrial complex.
Union numbers today barely make it to the double digit area, so while Talk Radio vilifies Unions, they are a minor part of the equation these days and oddly enough comes during a period where worker pay and benefits are eroding.
Rather than dwell on a very self centered workplace incident, you might take a wider world view.
And study history past 1980.
My familiarity with Jacksonian Democracy is that it thrived in pursuit of Manifest Destiny with landowners pioneering their own domain.
The industrial revolution catalyzed during the Gilded Age brought tremendous innovation, but the struggle which took place as primarily in cities. When you look beyond Chicago, Boston, New York, and Philadelphia, life really wasn't that bad. The worst of it was during the dust bowl, but that only happened once and was in response to increased food demand from urban living.
If you have stats to back up your claim, I'd be willing to read them, but my familiarity with unions is they were an excuse for the social gospel. Progressive Protestants wanted to mold the Protestant Work Ethic onto Catholic immigrants, and unions were encouraged to accommodate Catholic solidarity rather than really assimilate Catholic immigrants into Americana.
The implication was a tossed salad rather than an authentic melting pot where immigrants were taught to take pride in struggling ethnic enclaves.
As far as talk radio's concerned, I don't think you've ever heard the narrative spouted above by Rush Limbaugh or Sean Hannity. If anything, they reinforce immigrant pride in absorbing rugged individualism by perpetuating the melting pot myth.
Last edited: