• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Most influential profession?

JC Callender

DP Veteran
Joined
Jan 26, 2013
Messages
6,477
Reaction score
3,270
Location
Metro Detroit
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
What would you say is the most influential (not the oldest) profession and why? Examples: Philosopher, scientist, writer, politician, etc...
We'll focus on the top echelon of these jobs, for instance philosophy: Plato, Socrates, etc...
 
I'm gonna go with elementary teacher....... :)
 
i see a good argument for teaching. pretty much all trees grow from those roots. the only profession with a more fundamental role is parenting.
 
That is a really good, and really tough, question. I think I am going to go with scientist/engineer. I think their discoveries, inventions and creations affect our lives more than the work products of other professions.
 
i see a good argument for teaching. pretty much all trees grow from those roots. the only profession with a more fundamental role is parenting.

Two great professions, but I can't think of a teacher or parent (known mainly for their parenting) who's as influential as Newton, Aristotle, Lincoln, etc...can you?

Although Socrates was mainly a philosopher, he also taught Plato, Plato taught Aristotle, and Aristotle taught Alexander. So teaching was important as well, but not their main professions.
 
Proctologist.

No other professional so completely has you over a barrel from the moment you are forced to bend over and accept him or her ramming their index finger up your arse to the 3rd knuckle, all the way past the moments when you are forced to wipe yourself up and clean off all the goo with a paper towel, and then slink off with all your dignity gone forever.

Oh wait;
That's pretty much the VOTING EXPERIENCE in this Presidential election in a nut-shell.

Never mind.
:(
 
software engineer

makes all of the world's tech parts move as desired
 
Proctologist.

No other professional so completely has you over a barrel from the moment you are forced to bend over and accept him or her ramming their index finger up your arse to the 3rd knuckle, all the way past the moments when you are forced to wipe yourself up and clean off all the goo with a paper towel, and then slink off with all your dignity gone forever.

Oh wait;
That's pretty much the VOTING EXPERIENCE in this Presidential election in a nut-shell.

Never mind.
:(

Have you had a woman do it?
 
Proctologist.

No other professional so completely has you over a barrel from the moment you are forced to bend over and accept him or her ramming their index finger up your arse to the 3rd knuckle, all the way past the moments when you are forced to wipe yourself up and clean off all the goo with a paper towel, and then slink off with all your dignity gone forever.

Oh wait;
That's pretty much the VOTING EXPERIENCE in this Presidential election in a nut-shell.

Never mind.
:(

also is someone who knows an asshole when (s)he sees one
 
Have you had a woman do it?

Good question.

No, I am blessed to say that I have never had to visit a proctologist.

That was just the creative writer in me coming out, and me attempting to gross everyone out.

:)
 
Sadly, in all of history, the most influential of humans have been lawyers and mad-men.

And the forecast is for more of the same.
:(
 
What would you say is the most influential (not the oldest) profession and why? Examples: Philosopher, scientist, writer, politician, etc...
We'll focus on the top echelon of these jobs, for instance philosophy: Plato, Socrates, etc...

A preacher with a lot of charisma has a pretty good grip on his flock.
 
A preacher with a lot of charisma has a pretty good grip on his flock.

That's a good guess. If I put Jesus in a worldly profession, it would probably be either preacher/minister or philosopher.
 
Definitely teachers, IMP. I had some great elementary teachers. We had an exchange teacher directly from England in the 3rd. grade. England got our old bat that year. And in 4th. grade I had a wonderful, teacher (a guy) who was a Quaker. Our class was interrupted during 4th. grade by the assassination of President Kennedy.
 
In the 21st century I think there is a strong case for them.

anyone who believes our nation's students should be more exposed to learning how to code should read this:
https://gigaom.com/2015/08/24/heres-why-american-students-dont-learn-computer-science/

some salient excerpts:
... 91 percent of parents want their children to learn computer science; less than 8 percent of principals thought demand for the courses was that high.
... That could help explain why many superintendents who responded to the survey said there isn’t enough money to train or hire a teacher (57 percent); nor a sufficient budget to purchase necessary equipment (31 percent) or software (33 percent); nor enough equipment (20 percent) or software (27 percent) already in their schools for them to introduce computer science courses. ...
you can bet that all of the kids are being taught to write software in india and china
 
Two great professions, but I can't think of a teacher or parent (known mainly for their parenting) who's as influential as Newton, Aristotle, Lincoln, etc...can you?

and i can't think of a Newton, Aristotle, or Lincoln that didn't start with a parent and teacher. can you?

Although Socrates was mainly a philosopher, he also taught Plato, Plato taught Aristotle, and Aristotle taught Alexander. So teaching was important as well, but not their main professions.

it's kind of like the arguments i've heard as a scientist. all biology is chemistry. all chemistry is physics. the mathematician chimes in : what is the language that you all speak?
 
and i can't think of a Newton, Aristotle, or Lincoln that didn't start with a parent and teacher. can you?



it's kind of like the arguments i've heard as a scientist. all biology is chemistry. all chemistry is physics. the mathematician chimes in : what is the language that you all speak?

appears Abe was largely self taught:
Abraham Lincoln was born on February 12, 1809 in a log cabin in Kentucky. He moved with his parents and an older sister, Sarah, to the backwoods of Indiana when he was seven. His mother died two years later. They were poor and Abe helped support the family by clearing land, plowing fields, husking corn, splitting logs for fences, doing carpentry work and various odd jobs. But Abe grew up with a keen desire for knowledge. When Abe's father remarried, Abe's stepmother took a special interest in him by encouraging him to read and study.

Abe always said that he went to school “by littles,” which meant a few weeks at a time when he was six, seven, eleven, thirteen, and fifteen. However, the sum total of his schoolhouse education did not even amount to one full year. Abe educated himself mainly by reading books and newspapers that he borrowed from others. He studied by firelight, working out arithmetic problems using charcoal on a wooden slate. Later when he was able to obtain paper, he practiced writing in a homemade copybook with a feather pen and blackberry ink.

Abe always had a book in his pocket to read out in the field when he had a break between chores. He commented one time that he had “read through every book that he had heard of within a circuit of fifty miles.” His favorites included the Bible, Aesop’s Fables, Robinson Crusoe, The Arabian Nights, Pilgrim’s Progress, Grimshaw’s History of the United States, a biography of George Washington, Shakespeare’s plays, and the poetry of Robert Burns.

The family moved to Illinois when Abe was 21, and after helping his father set up a new farm there, he then set out on his own. Lincoln worked as a riverboat pilot, a surveyor, a store clerk, and a postmaster, while in his spare time studying law books and teaching himself to be a lawyer. ...
Abraham Lincoln - Famous Homeschoolers - Famous Homeschool Parents
 
There are some nice answers above, but I think everyone is missing the big picture here.

There's a case to be made for rodeo clowns, mall Santas, cat behavior consultants, unicyclists, jugglers, mimes, restroom attendants, encyclopedia salesmen, WalMart greeters, reality show contestants, and that guy that shaves your ballsack before penis surgery.
 
and i can't think of a Newton, Aristotle, or Lincoln that didn't start with a parent and teacher. can you?



it's kind of like the arguments i've heard as a scientist. all biology is chemistry. all chemistry is physics. the mathematician chimes in : what is the language that you all speak?

Sure, some of them may have had great teachers, but there's are reasons they're much more well known than their teachers. Lincoln had the moral courage to usher our country through a gigantic civil war, but whoever taught him is more influential? Which btw as justabubba pointed out, Lincoln was pretty much self taught. And I think you're also assuming that these great people had excellent teachers, but they may have just come across people who passed information on to them and they had the ability to process it and build on it much better than most would.
 
What would you say is the most influential (not the oldest) profession and why? Examples: Philosopher, scientist, writer, politician, etc...
We'll focus on the top echelon of these jobs, for instance philosophy: Plato, Socrates, etc...


Excellent question and thank you.

My vote is lawyers. They are in everything and the most predominant profession in politics, from the back room, image makers, to the decision makers.

I would have at one time rated journalism second. But it has become entertainment now, the farce within a farce is exposed as a giant "real-life" day time drama ad machine, more about name calling than what's at stake. Those who are making sense are buried deep in the back pages by the lawyers in editor's chairs.
 
The answer is scientist....not even close.
 
1) Leaders
2) Philosophers
3) Scientists

There aren't many people in history who were very significant figures and weren't one (or more than one) of those.
 
Back
Top Bottom