• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this crap?

Gathomas88

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Feb 4, 2013
Messages
28,659
Reaction score
18,803
Location
Charleston, South Carolina
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Very Conservative
IFL - Koko The Gorilla Has A Message For Mankind

rsz_koko.jpg




The recent climate summit in Paris saw some of the most powerful humans on the planet deliver rousing speeches, although it’s the discourse of a famous member of another species that’s currently attracting attention, after Koko the gorilla made her feelings on climate change known using sign language.

Born in San Francisco Zoo in 1971, Koko began learning American Sign Language at the age of one, and, according to her trainers, was able to learn vocabulary at the same rate as a child with learning difficulties.

Over the past 45 years, she has become something of a global sensation, recently appearing in a video in which she adopts a pair of kittens, using sign language to identify them as cats and state that they are her babies.

Now, as part of a campaign by French organization Noe Conservation, Koko has been filmed delivering a message to the humans of the world, encouraging them to become more conscious of their responsibility to protect the planet. In the video, she appears to call mankind “stupid” for ignoring this responsibility, while also claiming that “Earth Koko love”

According to the Gorilla Foundation, Koko knows over 1,100 different signs, although many of these have been adapted in order to compensate for her inability to form the same complex hand shapes and movements as humans.

It must also be recognized that her ability to truly grasp the concepts about which she appears to "talk" in the video is questionable. For instance, her awareness of notions such as climate change and time unlikely to be strong. It has also not been verified by scientists not affiliated with the Gorilla Foundation whether or not she truly is able to grasp the syntax required to make complex statements, and how advanced her level of communication actually is.


Sooo... Long story short, some shady "institute" taught a monkey a parlor trick, and now all the New Age environut types are going gaga over it, hailing the thing as being the "voice of nature."

Nothing to see here folks, move along. :roll:

Why in the Hell does this count as being "science" news again? It seems more indicative of the old adage about a "sucker being born every minute."
 
Last edited:
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

Rofl wtf is this?!?!?!?
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

Sooo... Long story short, some shady "institute" taught a monkey a parlor trick, and now all the New Age environut types are going gaga over it, hailing the thing as being the "voice of nature."

I agree that this is a stupid marketing ploy which essentially means nothing.

I disagree that "all the new age environut types are going gaga over it".

I also disagree that it's a parlor trick. koko is pretty famous and can carry on complex conversations with people using sign language.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

I agree that this is a stupid marketing ploy which essentially means nothing.

I disagree that "all the new age environut types are going gaga over it".

I also disagree that it's a parlor trick. koko is pretty famous and can carry on complex conversations with people using sign language.

I disagree with the latter two. It's going to be exactly the sorts of whackjobs you'd see on an episode of "Penn and Teller's: Bullsh*t!" that are going to get the most mileage out of this.

I also find it highly, highly dubious that a Gorilla can even grasp advanced abstract concepts like "Man" and "Earth," let alone any sort of existential threat posed towards them.

I suspect they are being rather generous in interpreting these "signs," and that a certain amount of coaching is most likely involved.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

I disagree with the latter two. It's going to be exactly the sorts of whackjobs you'd see on an episode of "Penn and Teller's: Bullsh*t!" that are going to get the most mileage out of this.

I also find it highly, highly dubious that a Gorilla can even grasp advanced abstract concepts like "Man" and "Earth," let alone any sort of existential threat posed towards them.

I suspect they are being rather generous in interpreting these "signs," and that a certain amount of coaching is most likely involved.

the main criticisms of the claims made about koko center around the fact that there have been far more publications in popular media than academic papers published about her. if you look into the research that she's been a part of, however, it's pretty difficult to justify calling what she does a "parlor trick". she can communicate thoughts and feelings using signs.

like I said, this video was a marketing ploy and obviously would have required coaching. she's almost certainly not capable of high level, philosophical thought. however, she can probably understand and recognize differences between herself and other individuals, as well as between species and to me that is a lot more than just a parlor trick.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

IFL - Koko The Gorilla Has A Message For Mankind



Sooo... Long story short, some shady "institute" taught a monkey a parlor trick, and now all the New Age environut types are going gaga over it, hailing the thing as being the "voice of nature."

Nothing to see here folks, move along. :roll:

Why in the Hell does this count as being "science" news again? It seems more indicative of the old adage about a "sucker being born every minute."

lol...maybe liberals should nominate Koko as Hillary's running mate. :)
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

I disagree with the latter two. It's going to be exactly the sorts of whackjobs you'd see on an episode of "Penn and Teller's: Bullsh*t!" that are going to get the most mileage out of this.

I also find it highly, highly dubious that a Gorilla can even grasp advanced abstract concepts like "Man" and "Earth," let alone any sort of existential threat posed towards them.

I suspect they are being rather generous in interpreting these "signs," and that a certain amount of coaching is most likely involved.

RIP Penn and Teller's Bull****... Maybe it might come back... Maybe. But they are getting pretty old, Teller especially.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

I've heard similar stories around here.

It just happened to be that I had my shirt off and my back was to the audience at the time, though.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

The Left likes it because this is where they' come from.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

IFL - Koko The Gorilla Has A Message For Mankind



Sooo... Long story short, some shady "institute" taught a monkey a parlor trick, and now all the New Age environut types are going gaga over it, hailing the thing as being the "voice of nature."

Nothing to see here folks, move along. :roll:

Why in the Hell does this count as being "science" news again? It seems more indicative of the old adage about a "sucker being born every minute."

More impressive than Al Gore. Probably more accurate as well.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

Koko is not only better informed than most denier cultists, he's more articulate too! Not confined to repetitive Beavis grunting.

What are the odds he's better looking too?
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

Koko is not only better informed than most denier cultists, he's more articulate too! Not confined to repetitive Beavis grunting.

What are the odds he's better looking too?

It's actually a "she," incidentally...
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

I disagree that "all the new age environut types are going gaga over it".

according to the OP, if one right winger believes something, it's just the opinion of one right winger

If a left winger believes something, every left winger believes it. If an environmentalist believes something, every environmentalist believes it. If a feminist believes it, every feminist believes it

It's a very old shtick and even though no one is buying it, the OP keeps trying it
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

With all that deep understanding and well stated opinion what the hell is Koko doing locked up all these years? I don't know, maybe they are protecting her from trophy hunting dentists.

The video is edited and while Koko does sign there was not one complete thought, not one sentence that Koko signed that wasn't edited. Wait, I take that back. She did sign "Man is dumb" which was misinterpreted as "Man is stupid". I wouldn't argue either way.

From all I have read about Koko she is very bright (for a gorilla). She does have a broad vocabulary and she does express thoughts and emotions. Still in all Koko ain't ready for prime time, Fox News? Maybe.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

IFL - Koko The Gorilla Has A Message For Mankind



Sooo... Long story short, some shady "institute" taught a monkey a parlor trick, and now all the New Age environut types are going gaga over it, hailing the thing as being the "voice of nature."

Nothing to see here folks, move along. :roll:

Why in the Hell does this count as being "science" news again? It seems more indicative of the old adage about a "sucker being born every minute."
While I was playing this video on my laptop, my dog jumped-up on the couch to see what I was doing. He took a look, immediately let out a loud belch, and hopped back down on the floor.

He's a smart dog. I trust his judgement in this.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

lol...maybe liberals should nominate Koko as Hillary's running mate. :)

Or, perhaps they shoudl get her as the republican candidate for president, and have trump as her VP.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

according to the OP, if one right winger believes something, it's just the opinion of one right winger

If a left winger believes something, every left winger believes it. If an environmentalist believes something, every environmentalist believes it. If a feminist believes it, every feminist believes it

It's a very old shtick and even though no one is buying it, the OP keeps trying it

Bingo! Main reason why I never engage with him anymore. Koko was worth a look, though.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

IFL - Koko The Gorilla Has A Message For Mankind



Sooo... Long story short, some shady "institute" taught a monkey a parlor trick, and now all the New Age environut types are going gaga over it, hailing the thing as being the "voice of nature."

Nothing to see here folks, move along. :roll:

Why in the Hell does this count as being "science" news again? It seems more indicative of the old adage about a "sucker being born every minute."



Fantastic, an excellent piece of work. You can barely tell the arms have been manipulated.

You know, I have some ocean front property for sale in Saskatchewan. It's 1,100 acres. All you have to do is wait for the planet to warm up enough and you'll be surfing off your front door step.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

With all that deep understanding and well stated opinion what the hell is Koko doing locked up all these years? I don't know, maybe they are protecting her from trophy hunting dentists.

The video is edited and while Koko does sign there was not one complete thought, not one sentence that Koko signed that wasn't edited. Wait, I take that back. She did sign "Man is dumb" which was misinterpreted as "Man is stupid". I wouldn't argue either way.

From all I have read about Koko she is very bright (for a gorilla). She does have a broad vocabulary and she does express thoughts and emotions. Still in all Koko ain't ready for prime time, Fox News? Maybe.

I read about Koko years ago. At the time they were going to try to get her mated, wondering if she'd teach her young to sign. Never did hear how that worked out.
 
Last edited:
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

A trained ape preaching to the all too eager trained monkeys. Surely its not a shocker.

I love that people are shedding tears of sorrow and joy over the circus act. He is TALKING to us...he is really talking to us!
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

Or, perhaps they shoudl get her as the republican candidate for president, and have trump as her VP.

Republicans are more apt to shoot a gorilla and mount its head on a wall than believe what it signs to be gospel. For that they listen to voices from invisible men in the sky. :)
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

IFL - Koko The Gorilla Has A Message For Mankind



Sooo... Long story short, some shady "institute" taught a monkey a parlor trick, and now all the New Age environut types are going gaga over it, hailing the thing as being the "voice of nature."

Nothing to see here folks, move along. :roll:

Why in the Hell does this count as being "science" news again? It seems more indicative of the old adage about a "sucker being born every minute."

even if the ape actually knows sign language and has the intelligence of a little kid im guessing she was told global warming is bad people are doing it what do you think of them?

not to say that message is wrong in that case but it would be manipulative
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

Man, people are really butthurt over the fact that the worlds scientists aren't denying global warming. Better complain about a gorilla!
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

Wonder what Koko thinks about the stock markets just now. Krugman and Koko could have a back and forth on the subject published in the NYT.
 
Re: Talking Gorilla Condemns Global Warming - Are you freaking kidding me with this c

Republicans are more apt to shoot a gorilla and mount its head on a wall than believe what it signs to be gospel. For that they listen to voices from invisible men in the sky. :)

The democrat in the WH listens to voices from invisible Skyman.

Before applying non-sequiturs you should make sure there are plenty of grapes in you pickup truck.
 
Back
Top Bottom