• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Syriana Movie

Gladiator

Verifier
DP Veteran
Joined
Jun 21, 2007
Messages
4,685
Reaction score
660
Location
Suburbia
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Promo Info

Syriana

Are we allowed to discuss Movies under Books?

..
 
I see Movies are under Entertainment.
 
Syriana Movie

Syriana

Some Themes,

If you work hard and you are sincere, things may stillnot work out ideally.

Sometimes your subordinates can sell you out.

Sometimes you try to do good for your kids, but it does not work out.

Top Secret Clearances create problems in marriages.





..
 
Moderator's Warning:
Two Syriana Movie threads merged together.

Thank you for deleting the thread from under Books. I put a second message to indicate I was starting the thered under Music and Entertainment.


..
 
Syriana Characters

Syriana: Characters

Transcript of Screenplay

http://wbads-01.vo.llnwd.net/e1/wbmovies/syriana/site/med/Syriana-Screenplay.pdf

Why was Arash Amiri and his brother killed?

What did Bob do with the money for selling two missles?



Should Wassim's father know about the future for his son?

Did Prince Nassir know about Bob's Mission, when Bob stopped Prince Nassir's convoy? Was Bob trying to warn Prince Nassir? Or getting a still target?



Should Bob have tested Mussawi before revealing the nature of Bob's mission? How should Bob have tested Mussawi?

Did Terry expect Bob to verify that Mussawi was ready to help with Bob's mission? Before or after the mission ran into trouble?






..
 
Last edited:
Did Bob go Rogue after the Amir investigation started?

Why did Bob ask Whiting for his passports back? Did Whiting get Bob's passports back for him? How?

Was it important for the CLI to believe that the US Embargo would create a climate to weaken the Islamic control of Iran, so that another Government could be installed in Iran by the West?



..
 
Last edited:
Margaret, Bob's wife, only appears in the Deleted Scenes, I believe. I watched the Deleted Scenes last night, and they did not shed much light on the mysteries of the movie.

I looked for Bob to give a signal to to a roof-top after Bob delivered the missles, as described in the Screenplay. I didn't see Bob's actor give much of a signal.



..
 
The Division Chief, , for the CIA, in the Screen play is a maybe 45 Year old strawberry blond lady, called Jane, in the Movie. Jane Atkinson was the actress, according to the Character List.

Syriana: Characters


Jane backed down when Terry made a decision adverse to Bob. Should Jane have made more of a challenge to Terry?

At what level was Mr Whiting contacting the CIA?

I have tried to avoid giving away the turns in the Plot of Syriana, to avoid "ruining" the movie for people reading my posts. I have just tried to delineate and raise questions that are still lingering in my mind.

Does the movie Syriana give any dynamics that would tend to disprove any reasons why Iran may be distrustful of the Western intentions and tactics?

Was a Shape Charge used in the real life sinking of the USS Cole? How does the missing Stinger Missle tie into any real life Terrorist bombing?

What are the lessons about Family Relations to be drawn from the movie Syriana?





..
 
Correction of the post above, I should have said the ATTEMPTED sinking of the USS Cole.

USS Cole: the bomb


US Kills USS Cole Mastermind.

Al-Qaida: Its USS Cole explosives expert killed World News | Breaking International & Foreign News - cleveland.com


"The name of the 2005 film Syriana was apparently inspired by Pax Syriana. According to the film's publicity materials, "Syriana" was "a very real term used by Washington think-tanks to describe a hypothetical reshaping of the Middle East."[5] In an online discussion with The Washington Post in November 2005, Syriana director Stephen Gaghan said he saw Syriana as "a great word that could stand for man's perpetual hope of remaking any geographic region to suit his own needs."[6]

Pax Syriana - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The overall discussion of the movie, without giving away specific plots, could be Man's attempt to reshape the world.

Islamists attempt to reshape the world through terrorist acts. The West attempts to reshape the world by taking actions to prevent a climate that fosters Terrorist Acts. The Oil Companies attempt to reshape the world so they can get oil more cheaply, and control factors that might interrupt oil, or raise retail or wholesale oil prices.

Were Bob's Memos more about the atmosphere suporting terrorist acts, or more about preventing a specific terrorist act with a specific unaccounted weapon?


Does the Stinger Missle use C-4 Explosives in the warhead?

"The warhead is a 3 kg penetrating hit-to-kill warhead type with an impact fuze and a self-destruct timer"

A Stinger Missle weights about 23 Pounds. That includes the rocket motor, fuels and guidance system, along with the explosive charge. The Stinger warhead must be something like C-4, if not C-4.

Could the C-4 used for the USS Cole been from a stolen Stinger Missle?

FIM-92 Stinger - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Is the West really interested in preventing All terrorist acts, or rather in limiting, rather than eliminating terrorist acts? Do a few, occasional Terrorist acts allow a sufficient budget so that some clandestine actions can be undertaken, so the West can attempt to shape other cultures?

Were Bob's annoying memos about a missing Stinger Missle? Are a few missing missles a central part of the real mission of the CIA?



..
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom