Israeli planes violate Lebanon airspace - Page 17

Infinite Chaos · 08-02-08, 05:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Skin

-- I understand that you want to ignore the facts but the facts are stubborn things-- What pictures are you referring to? The helicopters were there after the attack as part of the rescue mission, were is your source for attack choppers participating in the attack? --

I enjoyed that...

You obviously have never visited the official website for the USS Liberty...

Photos taken during the Israeli attack on USS Liberty

Website Template

Website Template

And just to help with your explanation of jets flying "at altitude" - try this one for size...

Website Template

I'll give you time to think up some excuse but the above picture was taken by Captain McGonagle.

Dragon Skin · 08-02-08, 08:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Infinite Chaos

I enjoyed that...

You obviously have never visited the official website for the USS Liberty...

Photos taken during the Israeli attack on USS Liberty

Website Template

Website Template

And just to help with your explanation of jets flying "at altitude" - try this one for size...

Website Template

I'll give you time to think up some excuse but the above picture was taken by Captain McGonagle.

A) How do I know when that picture with the helicopter (which was quite high and quite far from the ship anyways) was taken?

B) That fighter was clearly not flying on deck and there's no way to know how fast it was traveling.

Infinite Chaos · 08-03-08, 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Skin

A) How do I know when that picture with the helicopter (which was quite high and quite far from the ship anyways) was taken?

I was mistaken, I thought you had actually bothered to do some homework on this affair. If you aren't even familiar with photographs taken by the Liberty crew-members during the attack or the USS Liberty website I won't waste either of our time anymore.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Skin

B) That fighter was clearly not flying on deck and there's no way to know how fast it was traveling.

As above. Please don't expect any further replies on this thread.

Dragon Skin · 08-03-08, 12:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Infinite Chaos

I was mistaken, I thought you had actually bothered to do some homework on this affair. If you aren't even familiar with photographs taken by the Liberty crew-members during the attack or the USS Liberty website I won't waste either of our time anymore.

So in other words you have no way to prove if that photo was taken before, during, or after the attack.

Quote:

As above. Please don't expect any further replies on this thread.

GySgt · 08-05-08, 09:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Infinite Chaos

I have had a huge amount of respect for your posts GySgt, that however is needless and way beneath your previous standards. However, I also have problems with the post below too -

Bit close to reaching ground where someone has fallen foul of Godwin's law?

More close to being tired of entertaining his typical complaints about all things Israel. Nobody complains this much without having a deeper issue. Review it yourself...why would someone care so deeply about accusing Israel of something that occurred thirty years ago? When someone steers away from the typical complaints about "Israeli aggression, or Israeli apartheid, or Israeli whatever," for favor of painting terrorist like guilt for the U.S.S. Liberty, doesn't this sound alarms that his complaints are deeper than just a casual critique? In other words, when rallying for hatred over "Israeli aggression" upon hapless peace loving innocent Palestinian victims doesn't get the support one is looking for, one may choose a way to paint them as aggressors against Americans...no matter the incident. Take in the fact that Germans and Japanese killed far more Americans in an intentional war and they receive far less bashing by these type of critics, and you have something to think about.

Sounds like a deeper issue to me.

Infinite Chaos · 08-06-08, 05:54 AM

GySgt - my post to you was about your response to two different posters. I know you are better than your response to Volker (post two).
The post about your response to Obvious Child - well, I dont know much about him - he may be anti-Israeli but that doesn't mean he had a valid point to make regarding the USS Liberty incident from his perspective. I would also say if you were offended by his interest in the Liberty incident then don't read further.

Just as when it became obvious "Dragon Skin" was wasting my time I chose not to respond further until he actually had done some background research - but then he went and got himself banned..

GySgt · 08-07-08, 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Infinite Chaos

GySgt - my post to you was about your response to two different posters. I know you are better than your response to Volker (post two).

Well, we're all human and Volker deserves a jab every now and then. Even I'm capable of stooping.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Infinite Chaos

The post about your response to Obvious Child - well, I dont know much about him - he may be anti-Israeli but that doesn't mean he had a valid point to make regarding the USS Liberty incident from his perspective. I would also say if you were offended by his interest in the Liberty incident then don't read further.

Just tired of him dancing around.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Infinite Chaos

Just as when it became obvious "Dragon Skin" was wasting my time I chose not to respond further until he actually had done some background research - but then he went and got himself banned..

He was a former banned member.