Re: Israel’s Nuclear Advisory Panel Endorses Iran Deal
Replace "Israel" with the US.. "The Attorney General of Israel for example is not the government. "
You've just proven that you're trying to base your claim for what is the Israeli government on the US one.
"On the US one"? What?
Breaking news: the nations of the world have different forms of governments.
Breaking news, the fundamental structure of government is still the same.. Its not about "ideology" or pandering an administrations line. Its pretty simple, a commission created by the government and serves the government becomes part of the government bureaucracy. Same as if you are appointed to a position within the government such as an agency, a department, etc its the GOVERNMENT.
All you have presented is total illogical arguments such as:
"well they advice the government"...
---Ok, well guess what you can be an advisory agency/board/department within the government...
"Their actions are independent of the government's actions."
---Ok, you can still advice the government and the ruling party/coalition/powers that actually within the government can still make decisions that are against the agencies advice... Happens a lot actually.
This is my personal favorite so far: "They are a committee formed by the government with members assigned by the government "
---Ok, they are a committee FORMED BY THE GOVERNMENT and MEMBERS ASSIGNED BY THE GOVERNMENT, but somehow they aren't the government!?
Totally illogical.
"Being under the government is not equal to being part of it."
---Being in the government does not make you apart of the government?
Again, totally illogical
"A committee assigned by the government can have independent views."
---One views or committee or agencies views has nothing to do with if you are a part of the beucarcy/government... EPA might recommend certain policies that both Republicans and Democrats disagree with and dont want to move forward with, this does not make them not part of the government because the legislative or executive branch does not want to move forward with or take their advice...
So illogical.