- Joined
- Oct 13, 2011
- Messages
- 1,145
- Reaction score
- 445
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Libertarian - Right
I have always believed that some crimes are so heinous, the only appropriate penalty is death.
I still believe that... I just no longer believe the government has a right to carry out that sentence.
In fact, I am persuaded that Government should have no power to kill its own citizens at all. The only exception to this I would make is that individual government agents should have the exact same power as the citizenry in such matters... namely, the right to kill in defense of one's self or of innocents under threat where the threat is severe and imminent. Government agents (police, mainly) who do so should be subject to EXACTLY the same scrutiny and judgement as citizens who do so.
My reasoning is that government is already far too powerful, and abuses its power far too often. While I have doubts and caveats regarding some of the studies using DNA evidence to "prove innocence" of death row inmates (mainly due to old samples poorly stored), my doubts are a matter of degree... there is little question that "the system" has, at times, executed innocent citizens.
This is not acceptable. Since we cannot be certain those government executes are guilty and worthy of death, we must not allow government to execute its own citizens.
A man imprisoned can always be set free if found to be innocent later. A person executed cannot be restored to life if later found innocent.
Understand I am not speaking of the military or of war against foreign enemies, just of the government and its own citizens.
This is too great of a power and too easily misused or willfully abused, and we already know it has been in some cases.
It pains me to come to this conclusion for there are surely crimes that cry out for execution as simple justice, so heinous are they... but the government and the legal system are too fallible to entrust with such a thing.
If a criminal is killed in the act by a citizen or an officer of the law as a matter of defense, so be it. Once arrested and subjected to the judicial system, though, the government should not be allowed to kill its own citizens via cold and premeditated execution.
This is too much power to invest in the hands of an already-too-powerful, often corrupt, often wrong institution.
I agree. I have changed my mind on this issue as well. IMO, while some people are certainly deserving of death, our society stoops to too low a level by allowing our government to punish people in this way.