• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

China vs India, who will win?

Joined
Nov 16, 2009
Messages
40
Reaction score
0
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
I was annoyed by China's Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Con


As an Indian guy, I was really annoyed by the behavior of Chinese netizens.
Yesterday, i was annoyed by a post from a China media, which is so-called Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest, where they make comparisons between China and India.
They think they easily beat India in 1962 and will do that in the future. Acoording to the netizens of China, India can be no match for China.
I don't know why they said that! 'badboy'! I know that China is developing , but India also is. There are lots of poor people there. Lots of our Indian netizens has gone to there to beat back Chinese netizens already. I also did that. Even I am angry now!

The following are some evidence i selected for us:

[ame="http://forum.globaltimes.cn/forum/showthread.php?t=8671"][Sino-Indo] "Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest" recruits debaters - Global Times Forum--Discuss China,Discuss the world--The Most Open and Objective Forum in China[/ame]

China and India, two Eastern giants with thousand-year of civilization, are playing increasingly important roles in international affairs. However, in recent years, the upgrading trade conflicts and tensions generated by border disputes have make this piece of Asian land a hotspot in world.


Quote:
In order to reinforce the civil communication and information sharing between Chinese and Indian netizens, Sino-Indo Special Column of Huanqiu.com initiates "Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest". The contest will start on December 1, 2009 on Global Times Forum. Debaters from China and Indian will have a hot discussion on key issues of mutual concern.

We are looking for netizens from China and India who are interested in Sino-Indo issues to take part in the contest. We're looking forward to your participation!

Please send your basic information (Name, E-mail, MSN, QQ, Location) to zhuliangliang@huanqiu.com We would like to read your comments on following topics first. If you would like to writte something please attach it in your E-MA


Quote:
Chinese, Indian Internet users to have lively debate
Globaltimes_china news_chinese_news

Related News:
India's unwise military moves
Is Dalai Lama's visit to Tawang not political?


Should China resort to force to fight back India at this point?


美智库:中国的“印度洋战略”
Which country is most likely to launch a war against China?
India is thirsty for American's advanced weapons to counter China
Does peacefully rising China need to be checked and ballanced in East Asia Community?
Should Google Earth Remove Map Notes in Chinese Language in Arunachal Pradesh
 
Last edited:
A debate contest and an honest clearing of the air between citizens sounds like it might be a good start to deflating tensions between the two governments, provided that the debate progresses in a courteous fashion.

Unfortunately, my knowledge of Chinese and Indian history is extremely limited and it falls almost entirely in the early 20th century and earlier.

A thread about historical Sino-Hindi relations would be a useful addition to our History sub-forum if you would like to start one.
 
Related News:
India's unwise military moves
Is Dalai Lama's visit to Tawang not political?


Should China resort to force to fight back India at this point?


美智库:中国的“印度洋战略”
Which country is most likely to launch a war against China?
India is thirsty for American's advanced weapons to counter China
Does peacefully rising China need to be checked and ballanced in East Asia Community?
Should Google Earth Remove Map Notes in Chinese Language in Arunachal Pradesh


This all looks strangely China centric. I think the best move would be for India to beat the crap out of China in soccer! Seriously though an internet discussion could be good or could be bad. Worth a shot.

I have done lots of reading of the Hindu religion. I used to follow Sri Ramakrishna. My preference in Indian philosophy is Advaita Vedanta. One with Brahman. I work with both Indian and Chinese engineers and much prefer the Indian language over the Chinese language, which drives me bonkers.

I'm rooting for you Ganesh!
 
Last edited:
The true battlefield of national pride.

I'm glad to see the US getting better, but we still have a ways to go before breaking into the elite level. The thing that burns me is the reception our national team gets in places like Mexico. I have heard reports of them throwing bottles and batteries and other objects at our team.

To keep this on thread topic, how well does India do at soccer? Not cricket, soccer... I know China has been improving.
 
I'm glad to see the US getting better, but we still have a ways to go before breaking into the elite level.

That's okay. We'll always have baseball. I'd prefer to see the US take a more prominent position in world soccer, but it's just not going to happen until it loses the stigma of being a "woman's sport" here.
 
That's okay. We'll always have baseball. I'd prefer to see the US take a more prominent position in world soccer, but it's just not going to happen until it loses the stigma of being a "woman's sport" here.

Ahh, yes. That's the price for having an elite level women's team!
 
I'm glad to see the US getting better, but we still have a ways to go before breaking into the elite level. The thing that burns me is the reception our national team gets in places like Mexico. I have heard reports of them throwing bottles and batteries and other objects at our team.

To keep this on thread topic, how well does India do at soccer? Not cricket, soccer... I know China has been improving.

they cant be worse at soccer than they are at cricket, but to be on topic, maybe they should sort it out by a soccer match, a cricket match and a martial arts contest, and whoever wins is better....and maybe the loser will resort to nuclear warfare
 
I think India will eventually win because more people there speak english and the issue of Taiwan will never go away. I mean the Brits gave them back hong kong and now they want Taiwan, too?

Also I abhor the way china has treated Tibet.
 
I was annoyed by China's Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Con


As an Indian guy, I was really annoyed by the behavior of Chinese netizens.
Yesterday, i was annoyed by a post from a China media, which is so-called Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest, where they make comparisons between China and India.
They think they easily beat India in 1962 and will do that in the future. Acoording to the netizens of China, India can be no match for China.
I don't know why they said that! 'badboy'! I know that China is developing , but India also is. There are lots of poor people there. Lots of our Indian netizens has gone to there to beat back Chinese netizens already. I also did that. Even I am angry now!

The following are some evidence i selected for us:

[Sino-Indo] "Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest" recruits debaters - Global Times Forum--Discuss China,Discuss the world--The Most Open and Objective Forum in China

China and India, two Eastern giants with thousand-year of civilization, are playing increasingly important roles in international affairs. However, in recent years, the upgrading trade conflicts and tensions generated by border disputes have make this piece of Asian land a hotspot in world.


Quote:
In order to reinforce the civil communication and information sharing between Chinese and Indian netizens, Sino-Indo Special Column of Huanqiu.com initiates "Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest". The contest will start on December 1, 2009 on Global Times Forum. Debaters from China and Indian will have a hot discussion on key issues of mutual concern.

We are looking for netizens from China and India who are interested in Sino-Indo issues to take part in the contest. We're looking forward to your participation!

Please send your basic information (Name, E-mail, MSN, QQ, Location) to zhuliangliang@huanqiu.com We would like to read your comments on following topics first. If you would like to writte something please attach it in your E-MA


Quote:
Chinese, Indian Internet users to have lively debate
Globaltimes_china news_chinese_news

Related News:
India's unwise military moves
Is Dalai Lama's visit to Tawang not political?


Should China resort to force to fight back India at this point?


美智库:中国的“印度洋战略”
Which country is most likely to launch a war against China?
India is thirsty for American's advanced weapons to counter China
Does peacefully rising China need to be checked and ballanced in East Asia Community?
Should Google Earth Remove Map Notes in Chinese Language in Arunachal Pradesh

im sure the west would love to see you wipe each other out so they can maintain hegemony. in fact, this may be why the usa is selling weapons to pakistan.
 
I was annoyed by China's Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Con


As an Indian guy, I was really annoyed by the behavior of Chinese netizens.
Yesterday, i was annoyed by a post from a China media, which is so-called Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest, where they make comparisons between China and India.
They think they easily beat India in 1962 and will do that in the future. Acoording to the netizens of China, India can be no match for China.
I don't know why they said that! 'badboy'! I know that China is developing , but India also is. There are lots of poor people there. Lots of our Indian netizens has gone to there to beat back Chinese netizens already. I also did that. Even I am angry now!

The following are some evidence i selected for us:

[Sino-Indo] "Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest" recruits debaters - Global Times Forum--Discuss China,Discuss the world--The Most Open and Objective Forum in China

China and India, two Eastern giants with thousand-year of civilization, are playing increasingly important roles in international affairs. However, in recent years, the upgrading trade conflicts and tensions generated by border disputes have make this piece of Asian land a hotspot in world.


Quote:
In order to reinforce the civil communication and information sharing between Chinese and Indian netizens, Sino-Indo Special Column of Huanqiu.com initiates "Sino-Indo Internet Users Debate Contest". The contest will start on December 1, 2009 on Global Times Forum. Debaters from China and Indian will have a hot discussion on key issues of mutual concern.

We are looking for netizens from China and India who are interested in Sino-Indo issues to take part in the contest. We're looking forward to your participation!

Please send your basic information (Name, E-mail, MSN, QQ, Location) to zhuliangliang@huanqiu.com We would like to read your comments on following topics first. If you would like to writte something please attach it in your E-MA


Quote:
Chinese, Indian Internet users to have lively debate
Globaltimes_china news_chinese_news

Related News:
India's unwise military moves
Is Dalai Lama's visit to Tawang not political?


Should China resort to force to fight back India at this point?


美智库:中国的“印度洋战略”
Which country is most likely to launch a war against China?
India is thirsty for American's advanced weapons to counter China
Does peacefully rising China need to be checked and ballanced in East Asia Community?
Should Google Earth Remove Map Notes in Chinese Language in Arunachal Pradesh

That was an interesting site. It is one of the most hateful forums I have ever visited, also. Looks like china and india will get into it. I am rooting for india.
 
That's okay. We'll always have baseball. I'd prefer to see the US take a more prominent position in world soccer, but it's just not going to happen until it loses the stigma of being a "woman's sport" here.
Well, America's standard in international baseball is falling too, while national standards are rising. Queer thing is that national teams are better than the international one.
 
Well, realistically, China has a better chance of winning the economic and political war, but India will win the morale war. I find Indian people always optimistic with a twinge of unfailingness. However, China like every former top country before it, will eventually fall. Then, I think India will pick up the pieces and take over China as Asian hegemony.

However, I can't leave without saying anything about my country as my overwhelming national pride is getting hold of me. Under the current administration, our country will never get hold of the world stage. However, I do hope that my country's turn to be regional hegemon will come, preferably during my lifetime
 
I know that China is developing , but India also is.
India is more poor than Africa, I don't know how much that will affect the outcome?
Eight Indian states account for more poor people than in the 26 poorest African countries combined, a new measure of global poverty has found.

The Indian states, including Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal, have 421 million "poor" people, the study found.

This is more than the 410 million poor in the poorest African countries, it said.
BBC News - 'More poor' in India than Africa
 
No military conflict is likely to have any decisive results. The border region is arguably the worst in the entire world from a logistical standpoint. Neither has any significant power projection capabilities with their respective navies, so large scale warfare isn't really viable. That doesn't even get into the fact that both sides have nuclear weapons. I see it as much more likely to play out on a political and economic fashion. China has the economic advantage at the moment, but India's functioning democracy is likely to be more politically stable than China's repression, especially as they both get wealthier.
 
No military conflict is likely to have any decisive results. The border region is arguably the worst in the entire world from a logistical standpoint. Neither has any significant power projection capabilities with their respective navies, so large scale warfare isn't really viable. That doesn't even get into the fact that both sides have nuclear weapons. I see it as much more likely to play out on a political and economic fashion. China has the economic advantage at the moment, but India's functioning democracy is likely to be more politically stable than China's repression, especially as they both get wealthier.

India is actually far more unstable then is China

India has a Naxalite insurgency in the eastern parts of India, which is growing
It has a potential for another Sihk moverment to separate, the last one fizzled out in the 80's
It has a strong separatist movement in Kashmir requiring.

Those are the ones I can recall.


Other political issues would include the BJP a Hindu nationalist party that is fairly powerfull, and not exactly one that will support minority rights (including that of low caste Hindu's_
It has states that are run by the Indian communist party
 
The caste system is the polar opposite of Western democracy. If this system continues to flourish in India, it will eventually lead to failure or India.

Modern communication may help to put an end to this barbaric cultural system, I hope.

One of the best things that India has as an advantage is that many people there speak English.
:peace
 
-- Also I abhor the way china has treated Tibet.

It's a shame we lost the one pro-China poster in jfuh a while ago, I enjoyed discussing Tibet with him: always polite even if he was generally hated by other posters in other areas of the forum.
 
That was an interesting site. It is one of the most hateful forums I have ever visited, also. Looks like china and india will get into it. I am rooting for india.

If you mean, who will win the forum political debate, I dont give a toss, but the more dirty they make the battle the more entertainement for us. ;)

Off the forum, in the real world, I just hope negotiations for peace will soon bring peace, in a way that will benefit all parties involved, especially the ordinary citizens of these countries.
 
If you mean, who will win the forum political debate, I dont give a toss, but the more dirty they make the battle the more entertainement for us. ;)

Off the forum, in the real world, I just hope negotiations for peace will soon bring peace, in a way that will benefit all parties involved, especially the ordinary citizens of these countries.

I wonder when people wonder are going to realize the fact that politicians are puppet masters in this brainwashed world?
 
Well, temporarily, China is going to beat India. With its Maoists and all kinds of trouble from Pakistan, it has to be. Yet nobody predicted that after the Korean War, South Korea which was poorer even than African countries could become the 13th largest economy in the world after 5 decades. It's something called a miracle, and the rapid economic growth of South Korea is actually called the Miracle of the Han River, which is the main river of both Seoul and South Korea
 
Well, temporarily, China is going to beat India. With its Maoists and all kinds of trouble from Pakistan, it has to be. Yet nobody predicted that after the Korean War, South Korea which was poorer even than African countries could become the 13th largest economy in the world after 5 decades. It's something called a miracle, and the rapid economic growth of South Korea is actually called the Miracle of the Han River, which is the main river of both Seoul and South Korea

It just goes to prove that if you want your country to improve just start a war with the United States. Works every time. If Detroit was smart they would start an insurrection to improve their economy.
 
Back
Top Bottom