• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Donald trump: We will have a ‘deportation force’

"We will have a deportation force, and it's gonna be great! It's gonna be the best deportation force of all the deportation forces."

Am I crazy, or would "The Deportation Force" be a sweet name for a punk band?
 
The differences between then and now is two-fold... 1) political will, and 2) scale.

Regarding the latter, it's easy to do if you keep up and do it as it happens. It's not a huge undertaking, and it's not too disruptive to the overall economy..
Illegals do not make up a large percentage of our workforce. Contrary to what pro-illegals claim there is no significant discount on goods and services as a result of illegal alien labor.
Low-paid illegal work force has little impact on prices | The Seattle Times

I think what most Rep candidates are saying is that it wouldn't be doable now because we let it get too big and it would be unwieldy and unworkable

Almost every one of those people saying that want amnesty. They act as though mass round and deportation is the only solution that the anti-illegal immigration side proposes so they can pretend that can never work even though it has been done in the past that the only possible solution is amnesty. Getting illegal aliens back into their country will require different solutions.Round ups and deportation are only part of it. The following should go along with round up and deportations.




1.Crack down on the scum who hire illegals.Treat them no different than we do drug dealers and other criminals who profit from and or use their money for illegal activities.

2. In order to get any ID or driver's license you present a birth certificate( in rare cases a non-availability birth certificate where it has been investigated that the individual was born in the US), green card, or certificate of naturalization and social security card.After that require a state issued ID or driver's license in order to the following-

-enroll yourself into school
-enroll your minor kids into school
-apply for welfare,food stamps,section 8 housing and any other tax payer assistance for yourself and or your children
-get a business license,fishing/hunting permit,building permit, license to practice law, food handlers permit, gun license(in states that require a permit to buy a gun),concealed carry permit(in states that require a license to conceal carry) or any other tax payer funded service
-open a bank account, cash a check, use a credit/debit/pre-paid card, apply for a loan,or wire money.
-rent,borrow,lease or buy property
-rent,borrow,lease or buy a motor vehicle.
-get legal documents for yourself or your children.
-get utilities

3.Mandate E-verify for every employer.

4.Repeal part of the immigration and nationality act of 1965 that allows for the chain migration of relatives other than spouse or minor children.This would virtually eliminate anchor babies.

5.Seeing how many of these people here illegally came her on a visa and let it expire we should also cut off visas to citizens of countries we have the most illegal immigration problems with until those numbers go down.
 
You mean adopting a plan involving this...



https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...portation-operation-wetback-was-anything-but/

If this what you call "humane" I doubt we inhabit the same plane of reality.

I think our policy with deporting illegal immigrants should be is 6 months in jail for the first offense like the law says we can and then deport them to the furthest point away from us.For example illegals from Mexico would be deported to the Cancun,Mexico while illegals from Canada would be deported to Alert, Nunavut Canada. This would ensure that it would be a long time before they would cross into the US illegally again and that it would be financially more costly to them.Sure it would be costly at first but when people get the message that deportation will be a bitch for them them they will think twice before coming here illegally. That will help bring down the number of people coming into the country illegally.
 
the donald crapped himself this time
the only thing more stupid would be to say he was going to place land mines along the border from brownsville to san diego ... probably because he hasn't thought of it yet

a 1,954 mile wall
it sure helped the chinese [/s]

Actually it did help the Chinese.Contrary to popular belief the great wall of China is not a Single wall. The Chinese built walls like the Egyptians and Mayans built pyramids and the Catholics built large cathedrals.
,
 

Attachments

  • 745px-Map_of_the_Great_Wall_of_China.jpg
    745px-Map_of_the_Great_Wall_of_China.jpg
    95.8 KB · Views: 18
Do you have any idea how few illegal aliens work in those agricultural jobs? I would bet that it is less than 5%. The reason that few US citizens will do those jobs is that the pay sucks and the work is generally seasonal which requires a migratory lifestyle.

Yeah, a LOT of them work in the building trades. Are those jobs Americans just won't do too? :rolleyes: I am so tired of the silly little memes libs foment to forward their retarded agendas. Also, if we quit paying able bodied people NOT to work, those crops would get picked, toot sweet. ;)
 
Trump is emigrating undocumenteds to slow down spending by the US government. I can't remember the figure undocumenteds cost the US each year. It's HUGE.

I guess I have to clarify Trump's policy to send illegals back to their country of origin for him. When there's an election every 2 years or so, everyone has to provide some sort of identity to vote. Same would be the case for those who wish to receive entitlements in the US. One wants food stamps? Provide American citizenship first. One wants a free education? Provide American citizenship first. One wants free health care insurance? Provide American citizenship first. One wants free housing? Provide American citizenship first. PROVIDE AMERICAN CITIZENSHIP FIRST.

There's no need for "Jackbooted thugs to break down the doors of illegals", as some rhetoricians (some of which are 'conservative' Republicans who think they are concerned with uncontrollable government spending..) keep proclaiming. The incentive for undocumenteds to stay in America will be taken away when freebies aren't liberally handed out to those who can't prove they are American.
 
Last edited:
Of course, the American people would need a president that would faithfully execute the laws...and uphold The Constitution.
 
What I got from what you said was "bad people back then did it so it must be bad now". So using your logic then that means vegetarians and animal lovers are as bad the nazis. Because why else ignore the Israeli/Palestinian wall as an example of a wall that worked for good purposes? Instead you brought up a wall built by a brutal communist dictator used to keep people from leaving.

Is vegetarianism or a PETA something that a government is doing?

The wall in Israel isnt a good thing in case you didnt know. WHat next are you going to espouse that we need what is between North and South Korea? A little DMZ is a good thing?

The concrete wall around certain parts of the West Bank was built to prevent terrorists and suicide bombers from entering Israeli cities and villages. It wasnt built to stop illegal immigration.

WHile I do agree that our border should be tougher to cross, I dont believe a wall is the solution. Proper military stations would do much more to defend our borders. There should be a military base every so many miles on the North, South, West and East borders. Patrols should be a 24/7. Technology should be exploited so that we know even if a snake crosses the border. Deployable forces could be on the spot in minutes. Making a wall a moot point.

A fence though should be there.



0711956dc881090827a2aacc592cea2b.jpg
 
Because of that wall Israel is no longer the terrorist target capital of the world.Suicide bombings dropped dramatically.

then the israelis no longer have a fear for their personal security
good to know
 
Nice artwork.

Like I said, I don't think Americans have the stomach for something like this.

You're probably right. Americans piss and moan about searching granny and toddlers: ignorant to the fact that anyone can be a terrorist or used by them.
 
Is vegetarianism or a PETA something that a government is doing?


Nope but vegetarians and PETA are doing something someone despicable in history did so by your logic that makes them bad too.

The wall in Israel isnt a good thing in case you didnt know.

It is not a good thing for the Palestinians who want to send suicide bombers into Israel.
The wall brought suicide bombings down a to a trickle.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Palestinian_suicide_attacks

WHat next are you going to espouse that we need what is between North and South Korea? A little DMZ is a good thing?
It would probably be cheaper than a concrete wall.Every country has right to do that. But those whose lips are on the testicles of the illegal alien lobby would scream bloody murder the first time someone steps on a land mine while coming into the US illegally or is shot down by armed guards. I would not also trust the next people in office to repair the fence/concertina wire or replace the land mines or to keep the manned patrols up.


The concrete wall around certain parts of the West Bank was built to prevent terrorists and suicide bombers from entering Israeli cities and villages. It wasnt built to stop illegal immigration.

It it brings suicide bombings down a trickle then it also does the same for illegal immigration.
WHile I do agree that our border should be tougher to cross, I dont believe a wall is the solution. Proper military stations would do much more to defend our borders. There should be a military base every so many miles on the North, South, West and East borders. Patrols should be a 24/7. Technology should be exploited so that we know even if a snake crosses the border. Deployable forces could be on the spot in minutes. Making a wall a moot point.

That would only work if we had a president and congress that loved their country.Currently there are too many politicians who are anti-American whose lips are planted on the testicles of the illegal alien lobby. If they did put the military on the border the only thing the military would be allowed to do is tell border patrol that they see people illegally crossing just like when George Bush and Rick Perry did when they put national guard on the border. A well built wall on the other hand would take awhile to remove.



How are you going to post a people claiming over a wall and then claim the wall in Israel is a bad thing.That picture seems to contradict your claim.
 
Nope but vegetarians and PETA are doing something someone despicable in history did so by your logic that makes them bad too.
Nope still doesnt work for you.



It is not a good thing for the Palestinians who want to send suicide bombers into Israel.
The wall brought suicide bombings down a to a trickle.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Palestinian_suicide_attacks
Like I said the point of the wall had to do with war not illegal immigration.


It would probably be cheaper than a concrete wall.Every country has right to do that. But those whose lips are on the testicles of the illegal alien lobby would scream bloody murder the first time someone steps on a land mine while coming into the US illegally or is shot down by armed guards. I would not also trust the next people in office to repair the fence/concertina wire or replace the land mines or to keep the manned patrols up.
Who said anything about mine fields? lmao we will never minefield our borders.

Without the proper military support along the border a wall wont do ****. People will just use ladders, or just knock the wall down. Walls are not impenetrable magic things.


It it brings suicide bombings down a trickle then it also does the same for illegal immigration.
A wall on the US-Mexico border wont do a damn thing without proper patrols. And if there isnt proper patrols that wall would be one big waste of tax payers money.


That would only work if we had a president and congress that loved their country.Currently there are too many politicians who are anti-American whose lips are planted on the testicles of the illegal alien lobby. If they did put the military on the border the only thing the military would be allowed to do is tell border patrol that they see people illegally crossing just like when George Bush and Rick Perry did when they put national guard on the border. A well built wall on the other hand would take awhile to remove.
I see this is just hyper partisan crap to you. Good for the team right?

Again a wall wont do any good just standing there by itself with no one to protect it. The illegals will just wait like they do now until it is safe to go climb over that wall.


How are you going to post a people claiming over a wall and then claim the wall in Israel is a bad thing.That picture seems to contradict your claim.
Must be why there is still suicide bombers and other operations still getting through.


Trumps push for a wall is just one of the things that make him a idiot. The next is his idiotic deportation force. Why couldnt we just use ICE. You know make them do their job? I guess no one told Trump about ICE, so he reinvented them all over again. Him and Gore should be buddies.
 
Nope still doesnt work for you.
Actually it does.If a wall is evil because the Soviets did it then so is veganism and liking animals because of Hitler.

Like I said the point of the wall had to do with war not illegal immigration.
If a wall can keep out suicide bombers then it can most certainly keep out illegal immigrants.

Who said anything about mine fields? lmao we will never minefield our borders.
You did.What do you think is on the DMZ?
Without the proper military support along the border a wall wont do ****. People will just use ladders, or just knock the wall down. Walls are not impenetrable magic things.

If a faucet is dripping you still shut the faucet as much as you can instead of letting it run at full blast.

A wall on the US-Mexico border wont do a damn thing without proper patrols. And if there isnt proper patrols that wall would be one big waste of tax payers money.

No one is saying just put the wall up and forget about it.

I see this is just hyper partisan crap to you. Good for the team right?
So people who encourage illegal immigration, let people flood into this country,put a national guard on the border to do nothing except call border patrol, and do not adequately secure our borders somehow love our country? That sounds like the opposite of someone who loves their country.

Again a wall wont do any good just standing there by itself with no one to protect it. The illegals will just wait like they do now until it is safe to go climb over that wall.
Again no one is saying just have a wall and no border security. A wall by itself is still better than nothing.It takes a lot more effort to go over a wall then simply walking across the border.

Must be why there is still suicide bombers and other operations still getting through.

It did slow it down to a trickle.

Trumps push for a wall is just one of the things that make him a idiot.

Yes pro-illegals do not want a wall on our border.Of course pro-illegals are going to call it idiotic.They will make comparisons to the Berlin wall while at the same time making fraudulent claims that it doesn't work.


The next is his idiotic deportation force. Why couldnt we just use ICE. You know make them do their job? I guess no one told Trump about ICE, so he reinvented them all over again. Him and Gore should be buddies.

Like Obama's plan for a national civilian security force?
 
Back
Top Bottom