• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

American Bacon Versus British Bacon

Who makes the best bacon?


  • Total voters
    46

PoS

Minister of Love
DP Veteran
Joined
Feb 24, 2014
Messages
33,902
Reaction score
26,619
Location
Oceania
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian
OK because Andalublue dared to question the supremacy of American bacon, this is a poll to see which is the better one!

First off this is a lovely pic of the greatest of foodstuff known to man: American bacon. It makes everything taste better!

bufJqv6.jpg


This on the other hand, is a pathetically cut piece of pork, notice the limp fat dangling on its sides and the utter lack of color and bland flesh that is British Bacon!

xxXl7Re.jpg


To quote MMC, "what say ye?"
 
Americans have perfected things like this.

My family is British, two things to note about British cuisine...

#1 The meats are ****

#2 the baked goods (breads/cakes/etc.) are ****ing delicious as hell

Sidenote - bacon falls under meat, not baked goods :)
 
I've never had british bacon. And canadian bacon is ham.


I vote sausage.
 
The post worked.. I'm going to my refrig and getting the bacon and frying a pound to make 3 sandwiches. Thick sliced, apple smoked, and I'm going to eat it on that worthless bleached white flour bread. Somebody call the cholesterol police. Save me from myself.
 
To quote MMC, "what say ye?"
British bacon is pork loin; American bacon is solely pork belly.

I like British bacon at a sit-down, fancy brunch. But I'd prefer American bacon if I were to cook it at home.
 
It depends on regional taste I think. It's the difference between good country ham and regular breakfast ham. US bacon has an addictive quality to it, as does country ham, that other versions just don't get to in my view. As for the British style, I can tell you that the Highland Scottish breakfast is really good and quite filling. The bacon has a hamish quality to it, but who cares.

ScotlandBreakfastWithBacon.JPG
 
The miracle of pig: turn garbage into delicious pork products we can eat.
 
Who cares? It's all torturerd and murdered pig flesh.
 
American bacon for the win.

That British crap looks just damn awful....:shoot
 
I'm partial, but Canadian Peameal or back bacon is far superior to other forms of bacon. It is the leanest form of pork product, effectively pork tenderloin trimmed of fat and cured. You have to be careful of the salt content, as with all cured meats, but it is delicious and a great treat - but not to be eaten daily.
 
Canadian bacon isn't bacon.

If British bacon is pork loin it isn't bacon either. It's got to come from the belly or it ain't bacon.

btw - skip the crap in the supermarket. Go to a decent butcher and buy a pork belly. Night and day difference.
 
OK because Andalublue dared to question the supremacy of American bacon, this is a poll to see which is the better one!

First off this is a lovely pic of the greatest of foodstuff known to man: American bacon. It makes everything taste better!

bufJqv6.jpg


This on the other hand, is a pathetically cut piece of pork, notice the limp fat dangling on its sides and the utter lack of color and bland flesh that is British Bacon!

xxXl7Re.jpg


To quote MMC, "what say ye?"



I like both forms actually, however back bacon, taken from the upper back/neck area is leaner and better for you. I have roasted peameal back bacon which should be eaten as a delicacy; unlike traditional bacon it does not always improve the flavor of other foods.
 
kevin bacon of course
 
Bacon is not meant to be lean, which is why it is cut from the belly instead of the loin. Pork loin is a wonder all it's own and should be allowed to maintain that identity. As for getting the fresh cut over the mass packaged stuff, I couldn't agreed more. Just make sure if what you want is bacon that it has been cured, because it can be pork belly that is sliced like bacon and just be fatty pork. Much like a ham is just pork unless it has been cured.

For those of us who like wild hog, it is important to note that the bacon will be far too lean to resemble what we are used to. It can be cured and will be awesome, but it will be lean. A wild hog ham, properly brined (my recipe is a wet brine that takes 3 weeks) is indiscernible from a domestic ham. If you want something like traditional bacon from a wild hog, you cure the hog jowls and slice them. I'm talking actual wild hog descendant from european hogs, not domestics that have gone wild. Those will be a little leaner and not as gamey as a true wild hog, but it only takes about 3 or 4 months off the farm for a domestic to become wild.

As an interesting (to me anyway) side note, pot belly pigs are different from both domestics and wild varieties, even as far as key anatomical differences. For instance a pot bellied pig has it's nuts inside the body cavity (makes sense, they are pretty low to the ground) and a retracted penis that is located further forward than it is on other pigs. You see, when you butcher a pig you want to tie off the penis and around the anus (after you cut around it) to prevent contamination of the meat. The overgrown pot belly we were given a couple of months ago was supposed to be female according to the owner. It was not. Another interesting thing about pigs is that it is quite difficult to convince them that they are dead, even when it is quite clear that they are. When we trap them we prefer to kill them with a pistol shot straight down thru the frontal cortex. The pig is dead for all intents and purposes. There is no breathing, no pain response and no eye movement or pupil response, but the heart will continue to beat. This is particularly handy, because you can "kill" one, then cut it's throat and the heart will pump the majority of the blood out before you start skinning.
 
Bacon is not meant to be lean, which is why it is cut from the belly instead of the loin. Pork loin is a wonder all it's own and should be allowed to maintain that identity. As for getting the fresh cut over the mass packaged stuff, I couldn't agreed more. Just make sure if what you want is bacon that it has been cured, because it can be pork belly that is sliced like bacon and just be fatty pork. Much like a ham is just pork unless it has been cured.

For those of us who like wild hog, it is important to note that the bacon will be far too lean to resemble what we are used to. It can be cured and will be awesome, but it will be lean. A wild hog ham, properly brined (my recipe is a wet brine that takes 3 weeks) is indiscernible from a domestic ham. If you want something like traditional bacon from a wild hog, you cure the hog jowls and slice them. I'm talking actual wild hog descendant from european hogs, not domestics that have gone wild. Those will be a little leaner and not as gamey as a true wild hog, but it only takes about 3 or 4 months off the farm for a domestic to become wild.

As an interesting (to me anyway) side note, pot belly pigs are different from both domestics and wild varieties, even as far as key anatomical differences. For instance a pot bellied pig has it's nuts inside the body cavity (makes sense, they are pretty low to the ground) and a retracted penis that is located further forward than it is on other pigs. You see, when you butcher a pig you want to tie off the penis and around the anus (after you cut around it) to prevent contamination of the meat. The overgrown pot belly we were given a couple of months ago was supposed to be female according to the owner. It was not. Another interesting thing about pigs is that it is quite difficult to convince them that they are dead, even when it is quite clear that they are. When we trap them we prefer to kill them with a pistol shot straight down thru the frontal cortex. The pig is dead for all intents and purposes. There is no breathing, no pain response and no eye movement or pupil response, but the heart will continue to beat. This is particularly handy, because you can "kill" one, then cut it's throat and the heart will pump the majority of the blood out before you start skinning.

There is a restaurant here is the Bay Area that often serves wild boar. I haven't tried it yet, but I'd like to.
 
Vegan atheist.

That's funny. I'm a Christian conservative hunting omnivore in the north Georgia mountains. My sister, only a year older, is an honest to God socialist buddhist vegan living in Ecuador. She teaches English at a university in Quito and has been on college campuses (campii?) for 30 years.
 
There is a restaurant here is the Bay Area that often serves wild boar. I haven't tried it yet, but I'd like to.

I'm quite fond of it.
 
I'm quite fond of it.

So can articulate? I once marinated some elk medallions: olive oil, red wine, garlic and seared 'em. They were quite good and gamie taste was wiped out. The friend who hunted them said, 'if you want to taste them as they are, just pick a fist full of sage and put it in your mouth'.

bleh
 
I like a BLT sandwich with a fried egg added to it....but minus the lettuce. The bacon and tomato flavors blend well with the egg and buttered toast.

And my favorite pizza is canadian bacon on 4 cheese, with uncooked tomato slices put on afterward.

Never had British bacon. It looks like cheap ham.
 
I like a BLT sandwich with a fried egg added to it....but minus the lettuce. The bacon and tomato flavors blend well with the egg and buttered toast.

And my favorite pizza is canadian bacon on 4 cheese, with uncooked tomato slices put on afterward.

Never had British bacon. It looks like cheap ham.

Hate to break it to you, but that's what "Canadian bacon" is, cheap ham. :mrgreen:
 
Isn't most American bacon now being made by the Chinese? Can you really call any Smithfield product "American" any more?
 
Back
Top Bottom