• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Ukraine bans all Russian movies released since 2014

PakPuk

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Messages
1,847
Reaction score
449
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Very Conservative
The Ukrainian parliament has banned all Russian films released after January 1, 2014, saying the move is aimed at improving “national security.”
The ban is an amendment to the Law on Cinematography that was adopted by the Ukrainian parliament in 2015.

Some 237 Rada (Ukrainian parliament) deputies voted in favor of the new measure.

The original version of the law banned Russian films that fall within the military genre made from 1991, which were dubbed as “propaganda” by the Ukrainian authorities. Now, the fresh amendment bans all films produced or showcased after 2014 in all genres.

More than 430 Russian films and TV series fall under the new measures.

http://rada.gov.ua/ru/news/Novosty/Soobshchenyya/127213.html
https://www.rt.com/news/337728-ukraine-bans-russian-movies/
 
More antagonistic nonsense. What possible "national security" is lost because of a movie?
 
What happened? Slow Muslim day?
 
Simpleχity;1065718053 said:
What happened? Slow Muslim day?

Not talking about the OP? Changing the subject? Off topic post.
 
The Ukrainian parliament has banned all Russian films released after January 1, 2014, saying the move is aimed at improving “national security.”
The ban is an amendment to the Law on Cinematography that was adopted by the Ukrainian parliament in 2015.

Some 237 Rada (Ukrainian parliament) deputies voted in favor of the new measure.

The original version of the law banned Russian films that fall within the military genre made from 1991, which were dubbed as “propaganda” by the Ukrainian authorities. Now, the fresh amendment bans all films produced or showcased after 2014 in all genres.

More than 430 Russian films and TV series fall under the new measures.

http://rada.gov.ua/ru/news/Novosty/Soobshchenyya/127213.html
https://www.rt.com/news/337728-ukraine-bans-russian-movies/

I have seen only few good Russian movies.
 
I have seen only few good Russian movies.

Who gives a ****?

The point is this was passed on "national security" concerns. I am asking what those could possibly be.
 
Who gives a ****?

The point is this was passed on "national security" concerns. I am asking what those could possibly be.

Poroshenko tends to delve into the bizarre regularly. Whether it's stuff like this or making outrageous and unsupported accusations, the guy seems to believe that people will accept his version of reality just because he says it is so.

He is unfit to lead but that seems to be the norm for Ukraine. Just another in a long line of corrupt buffoons.
 
Who gives a ****?

The point is this was passed on "national security" concerns. I am asking what those could possibly be.

Oh, propaganda and finance.
 
Who gives a ****? The point is this was passed on "national security" concerns. I am asking what those could possibly be.
Anyone who has lived in Ukraine is well aware of the ingredients. It is a bit complex. However, I will attempt to briefly explain what has occurred.

During its many decades as a part of the Soviet empire (Ukrainian SSR), Moscow did everything in its power to minimize the Ukrainian language and culture. All official documents and publications were in the Russian language. With the dissolution of the Soviet Union and Ukrainian national independence in 1991, Ukraine endeavored to rescue the Ukrainian language and culture. It proved difficult however, to move away from Soviet/Russian modalities that had ruled for 70 years.

Ukraine has had laws governing cinema, copyright, licensing, and broadcasting since 1996. These laws were further updated in 2006. The intent of the 2006 amendments was to create an environment in which Ukrainian cinema, television (and language) could better flourish. The state wanted to increase the share of Ukrainian-language film and television broadcasts from 3% to 25%. There the matter rested quietly until 2014.

After Russia invaded Crimea and Donbas (eastern Ukraine) in the spring of 2014, a social movement in Ukraine - Vidsich (Rebuff) - initiated a "Do not buy Russian goods!" campaign. This boycott even extended to sex, with Ukrainian females wearing t-shirts saying "I will not sleep with a Russian". One glaring humiliation at this time was that roughly 40-80% of Ukrainian cinema and television material was of Russian origin. Ukrainians in the invaded Donbas region (Donetsk/Luhansk) were receiving only broadcasts from nearby Russia. It was precisely at this time that the Russian propaganda facet of their "hybrid warfare" doctrine being used against Ukraine was ratcheted up into high-gear.

This was all too much for Vidsich which began a campaign to limit Russia's penetration of Ukraine's movie houses and television broadcasts. In sympathy, on 11 April 2014 movie theaters in Kyiv, Lviv, and Odessa announced that they will no longer show Russian films. The largest Russian-content broadcasting TV channel "Ukrayina" — contained 87% Russian content. The TV channel "NTN" (71%), "Inter" (67%), "ICTV" (43%), "2+2" (42%). Activists began to hold protests at television stations. The Verkhovna Rada (Ukraine parliament) also took issue with much of the content arriving from Russia... such as the glorification of Putin, the glorification of Russia's security services and military personnel, Moscow chest-thumping over stealing Crimea, and outright propaganda to stir-up rebellion in eastern Ukraine. To make matters worse, Putin cinema/media moguls were receiving broadcasting fees and royalties to distribute and broadcast material slanderous of Ukraine. Vidsich (the people) and the Rada (parliamentarians) were on the same page.

The recently passed (29 March 2016) third reading on amendments (#1317) to the Law on Cinematography says that Russian film/television content which contains popularization, agitation, propaganda, and any action of occupation enforcement agencies, armed forces and other armed military or security forces of an occupier is strictly prohibited. The material of ~8 Russian directors is also prohibited because the bulk of their blatantly anti-Ukraine material is intended for the domestic Russian audience.

And there we are. It is not a blanket ban on Russian content, but a ban on Russian propaganda content. As long as Moscow has troops (currently 9,000) in eastern Ukraine and is an occupier (Crimea/Donbas) of Ukrainian territory, Russian propaganda is prohibited in Ukraine. I personally cannot imagine any nation in a state of active war and partially occupied allowing a similar situation to persist.
 
Simpleχity;1065720252 said:
Anyone who has lived in Ukraine is well aware of the ingredients. It is a bit complex. However, I will attempt to briefly explain what has occurred.

During its many decades as a part of the Soviet empire (Ukrainian SSR), Moscow did everything in its power to minimize the Ukrainian language and culture. All official documents and publications were in the Russian language. With the dissolution of the Soviet Union and Ukrainian national independence in 1991, Ukraine endeavored to rescue the Ukrainian language and culture. It proved difficult however, to move away from Soviet/Russian modalities that had ruled for 70 years.

Ukraine has had laws governing cinema, copyright, licensing, and broadcasting since 1996. These laws were further updated in 2006. The intent of the 2006 amendments was to create an environment in which Ukrainian cinema, television (and language) could better flourish. The state wanted to increase the share of Ukrainian-language film and television broadcasts from 3% to 25%. There the matter rested quietly until 2014.

After Russia invaded Crimea and Donbas (eastern Ukraine) in the spring of 2014, a social movement in Ukraine - Vidsich (Rebuff) - initiated a "Do not buy Russian goods!" campaign. This boycott even extended to sex, with Ukrainian females wearing t-shirts saying "I will not sleep with a Russian". One glaring humiliation at this time was that roughly 40-80% of Ukrainian cinema and television material was of Russian origin. Ukrainians in the invaded Donbas region (Donetsk/Luhansk) were receiving only broadcasts from nearby Russia. It was precisely at this time that the Russian propaganda facet of their "hybrid warfare" doctrine being used against Ukraine was ratcheted up into high-gear.

This was all too much for Vidsich which began a campaign to limit Russia's penetration of Ukraine's movie houses and television broadcasts. In sympathy, on 11 April 2014 movie theaters in Kyiv, Lviv, and Odessa announced that they will no longer show Russian films. The largest Russian-content broadcasting TV channel "Ukrayina" — contained 87% Russian content. The TV channel "NTN" (71%), "Inter" (67%), "ICTV" (43%), "2+2" (42%). Activists began to hold protests at television stations. The Verkhovna Rada (Ukraine parliament) also took issue with much of the content arriving from Russia... such as the glorification of Putin, the glorification of Russia's security services and military personnel, Moscow chest-thumping over stealing Crimea, and outright propaganda to stir-up rebellion in eastern Ukraine. To make matters worse, Putin cinema/media moguls were receiving broadcasting fees and royalties to distribute and broadcast material slanderous of Ukraine. Vidsich (the people) and the Rada (parliamentarians) were on the same page.

The recently passed (29 March 2016) third reading on amendments (#1317) to the Law on Cinematography says that Russian film/television content which contains popularization, agitation, propaganda, and any action of occupation enforcement agencies, armed forces and other armed military or security forces of an occupier is strictly prohibited. The material of ~8 Russian directors is also prohibited because the bulk of their blatantly anti-Ukraine material is intended for the domestic Russian audience.

And there we are. It is not a blanket ban on Russian content, but a ban on Russian propaganda content. As long as Moscow has troops (currently 9,000) in eastern Ukraine and is an occupier (Crimea/Donbas) of Ukrainian territory, Russian propaganda is prohibited in Ukraine. I personally cannot imagine any nation in a state of active war and partially occupied allowing a similar situation to persist.


"Stealing" Crimea?

The only reason Ukraine had the Crimea in the first place was that Khrushchev, who was a Ukrainian, gave it to them.

Not to mention that dwelling on it isn't going to help anyone, seeing as Russia's not giving it back.
 
"Stealing" Crimea?

The only reason Ukraine had the Crimea in the first place was that Khrushchev, who was a Ukrainian, gave it to them.
Yes, stealing.

300px-The_transfer_of_Crimea.jpg

Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet transferring Crimea to Ukraine in 1954

Crimea has been sovereign Ukrainian territory for the past 60+ years.

That is why Crimea's water, electric, gas, highway, and rail all originate in Ukraine.

■ The Partition Treaty on the Status and Conditions of the Black Sea Fleet (1997)
■ Agreement between Ukraine and Russia on the Black Sea Fleet in Ukraine (Kharkiv Pact - 2010)

It is why Moscow paid Ukraine $98 million annually since 1997 to lease a naval base in Crimea for Russia's Black Sea Fleet.

You don't pay someone rent for something you already own.
 
The Ukrainian parliament has banned all Russian films released after January 1, 2014, saying the move is aimed at improving “national security.”
The ban is an amendment to the Law on Cinematography that was adopted by the Ukrainian parliament in 2015.

Some 237 Rada (Ukrainian parliament) deputies voted in favor of the new measure.

The original version of the law banned Russian films that fall within the military genre made from 1991, which were dubbed as “propaganda” by the Ukrainian authorities. Now, the fresh amendment bans all films produced or showcased after 2014 in all genres.

More than 430 Russian films and TV series fall under the new measures.

????????? ???? ???????
https://www.rt.com/news/337728-ukraine-bans-russian-movies/

They make movies in Russia? I didn't think they'd done that since Tarkovsky left for Italy. Who knew?
 
Back
Top Bottom