- Joined
- May 14, 2009
- Messages
- 10,350
- Reaction score
- 4,989
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Other
One sees this this anecdotal 'logic' so often.
"If there's Global Warming how come it's so cold this year in... Virginia/Midlantic/etc" Fallacy.
Aside from the fact there's always variation in a general over-time trend, this thinking is also myopic in not looking at the larger geographic picture and more local influences warming might cause.
High pressure pushed wacky weather over USA
Doyle Rice, USA Today
Feb 5 2011
"If there's Global Warming how come it's so cold this year in... Virginia/Midlantic/etc" Fallacy.
Aside from the fact there's always variation in a general over-time trend, this thinking is also myopic in not looking at the larger geographic picture and more local influences warming might cause.
High pressure pushed wacky weather over USA
Doyle Rice, USA Today
Feb 5 2011
Vast Swathes of the Northern Hemisphere are much warmer than normal, some warmest ever (4-11 degress) while smaller BUT populated areas of the temperate zones are colder as a direct result... of warming.Q: So what's causing our wacky winter?
A: It may not sound too dramatic, but when we've had extreme winter weather in North America and Europe, the common denominator has been unusually high pressure at upper levels of the atmosphere over the Arctic and Greenland, says Weather Channel senior meteorologist Stu Ostro.
Such high atmospheric pressure has made temperatures warmer than average over Canada, Greenland and Alaska, but has opened the door to lower pressure, cold outbreaks and ferocious storms over the USA and Europe.
[.......]
How about global warming? Does this cold winter disprove it?
A: NOT really. As global temperatures rise, higher pressure is more likely at upper levels of the atmosphere, Ostro says, which is what happened this winter. Strong ridges aloft in recent months and years have been conducive to potent troughs of low pressure that help form intense storms.
"It's important to look at the context and the big picture," he says. "While major population centers such as London, Paris, Chicago and Atlanta were shivering, which got a lot of media attention, large expanses in and near the Arctic, including northeast Canada and Greenland, have been experiencing unusually warm conditions this winter."
Q: Anything else to worry about?
The loss of Arctic sea ice, which was at its lowest December and January levels on record, according to the National Snow and Ice Data Center.
"It could be changing atmospheric patterns," Ostro says.
Last edited: