• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Mafia #3.3.2 - Pasch's PacMan Mayhem v2

ecofarm said:
It's 9 players, thus 1 remains the same, or 3. So, Solaris being the same exludes there being 2 (leaving an odd number of roles to shuffle). Also, he could not take the risk of Helix remembering (or having been withholding) his knowledge of the other scum's role.
Click to expand...

I'd have to think about it but I think there is a flaw in your logic. 1 would not necessarily have to remain the same--none could be the same. Think of it like a basketball drill, the last in line passes the ball to the first in line and they keep cycling. DDD was Ms. Pacman last game and everybody knew that due to the tilt. I am not Ms. Pacman I know and Helix was quick to jump on that role and nobody has disputed it unless they are a pac and not falling for the bait. Beyond that IDK. I am not going through 550 posts to figure it out though.
 
ecofarm said:
That kills Fisher's newest theory.
Click to expand...

Still doesn't mean there is one this game. Perhaps you forgot that whole tweak the powers thing Pasch mentioned as part of the role reassignments.
 
Fisher said:
I'd have to think about it but I think there is a flaw in your logic. 1 would not necessarily have to remain the same--none could be the same. Think of it like a basketball drill, the last in line passes the ball to the first in line and they keep cycling. DDD was Ms. Pacman last game and everybody knew that due to the tilt. I am not Ms. Pacman I know and Helix was quick to jump on that role and nobody has disputed it unless they are a pac and not falling for the bait. Beyond that IDK. I am not going through 550 posts to figure it out though.
Click to expand...

I suppose your math is correct on the even/odd requirement. At least you're probably correct about 1 thing.
 
So a role cop and a godfather. Godfaters turn up innocent when investigated. That's very scary and cuts the town cop's usefullness.

Does the cop get to investigate night 0? Cop should investigate chaddelapeep, pEEPSLOCK, or The Peep.
 
Well, here's the deal with X Factor. He claimed a minor role, ~"not so bad". Without a counter-claim, I can only presume he is the minor role that I received at the false-start (perhaps tweaked).
 
Makes no sense to me. Regardless, I say I find someone suspicious and suddenly I am a goblin. Interesting someone has demanded votes for a week but tries to derail any meaningful discussion. That person will go on my ignore list. Beyond that, I am open to what anybody else might have to say but I see no reason to change my vote at this point.
 
Fisher said:
I see no reason to change my vote at this point.
Click to expand...

How about: it's hopeless, I'm not getting lynched, and even if I were scum there would be at least 1 other (or 2 according to you) to find and perhaps be able to lynch.
 
You've claimed yourself, Fisher, on more than one occasion that it's hopeless to try to get me lynched. Yet, you refuse to sniff out the other TWO scum that exist (according to you).

Why?
 
How about everyone post their top three suspects and we see if we can't find a common player we all agree on? Here's mine:

Fisher - Not sure if he actuallys believes the scenario he has suggested.

X Factor - Not too much in the way of posts and the ones he did were not helpful. Did claim to have a minor role, but such a vague claim is hard to refute.

cAPSLOCK - way too smart of a player to have disappeared for this long.
 
mine, in no particular order :

solaris
fisher
x factor

i will be casting my vote tomorrow, and if someone can make a compelling argument for someone else, i will consider it.
 
Fisher said:
He would have if he were making it up as scum to create confusion and not telling what the real role was because he has a power he doesn't want us to know about but was outed and winged it. Not exactly sure what a Godfather does for certain, but given the small size of the game and what I read about it on wiki, it seems like a stretch of a role for Pasch to create if they are the King Maker. Goblins obviously know who they are since they had a night 0. Town, not so much. You forget that one person here does not have the benefit of insight from the tilted game so must distrust everybody.
Click to expand...

Here is a simple rebuttal:

Why on Earth would I lie about a scum power role from the last game?

That said, It is annoying to spend too much time on the broken game's mechanics.
 
ecofarm said:
He would have to have been scum both times. Only scum would lie about such a role perhaps being in game. If Helix could remember, we'd know if he is lying.
Click to expand...

I think I told Helix my role last time in the QT thread, but what does that matter now? This is another game... seems a very grey area talking about this...
 
Chaddelamancha said:
How about everyone post their top three suspects and we see if we can't find a common player we all agree on? Here's mine:

Fisher - Not sure if he actuallys believes the scenario he has suggested.

X Factor - Not too much in the way of posts and the ones he did were not helpful. Did claim to have a minor role, but such a vague claim is hard to refute.

cAPSLOCK - way too smart of a player to have disappeared for this long.
Click to expand...

Yes... I apologize. And it looks scummy I know... but I've been particularly busy. Air conditioner at my business went out (I own the business) being the main reason I am busy... ugh... I sure hope it's repairable.

That said X Factor HAS been EXTREMELY strange and very very absent.
 
##Vote: X Factor

He's been too quiet.
 
Sorry, I had every intention of carefully going through all the posts from where I left off last time and I haven't had the chance. I've read through them but quicker than I wanted to. I know we're running out of time so I will cast a vote.

##vote Solaris

My suspicion of her hasn't ever changed and I can't believe she's now trying to get someone (TheMark?) to post a role pm. She's just a little too eager to know who's got what and what it does.

That said, if someone has the information readily available, who in this game has NOT role claimed? In addition to myself, I believe Fisher, Thor, Chad and Caps have also not role-claimed. Is that right? This is looking a lot like a game we had that Tucker broke open by assuming all the role-claims were true, then putting everyone who hadn't role-claimed up on the chopping block to get them talking. The truth is that fake claims by scum are actually pretty rare because scum knows it's a good way to reveal themselves to someone.

Whatever happens with this vote, I think there's a decent chance that scum is among those who have not role-claimed.
 
I don't think I've ever been the very first lynch before. Let me just say this before you all start ravaging my lifeless corpse (you know you want to, you sick bastards), watch Chad carefully. If I'm suspicious for my lack of activity, I actually have more posts than him (ok, by one).
 
X Factor said:
Sorry, I had every intention of carefully going through all the posts from where I left off last time and I haven't had the chance. I've read through them but quicker than I wanted to. I know we're running out of time so I will cast a vote.

##vote Solaris

My suspicion of her hasn't ever changed and I can't believe she's now trying to get someone (TheMark?) to post a role pm. She's just a little too eager to know who's got what and what it does.

That said, if someone has the information readily available, who in this game has NOT role claimed? In addition to myself, I believe Fisher, Thor, Chad and Caps have also not role-claimed. Is that right? This is looking a lot like a game we had that Tucker broke open by assuming all the role-claims were true, then putting everyone who hadn't role-claimed up on the chopping block to get them talking. The truth is that fake claims by scum are actually pretty rare because scum knows it's a good way to reveal themselves to someone.

Whatever happens with this vote, I think there's a decent chance that scum is among those who have not role-claimed.
Click to expand...

I role claimed. I am the Strawberry. Coo coo, cachoo.
 
X Factor said:
Sorry, I had every intention of carefully going through all the posts from where I left off last time and I haven't had the chance. I've read through them but quicker than I wanted to. I know we're running out of time so I will cast a vote.

##vote Solaris

My suspicion of her hasn't ever changed and I can't believe she's now trying to get someone (TheMark?) to post a role pm. She's just a little too eager to know who's got what and what it does.

That said, if someone has the information readily available, who in this game has NOT role claimed? In addition to myself, I believe Fisher, Thor, Chad and Caps have also not role-claimed. Is that right? This is looking a lot like a game we had that Tucker broke open by assuming all the role-claims were true, then putting everyone who hadn't role-claimed up on the chopping block to get them talking. The truth is that fake claims by scum are actually pretty rare because scum knows it's a good way to reveal themselves to someone.

Whatever happens with this vote, I think there's a decent chance that scum is among those who have not role-claimed.
Click to expand...

BTW, I should say, I hated Tucker's plan at first because I was the cop in that game and I was annoyed at the thought of being forced to role-claim.
 
X Factor said:
BTW, I should say, I hated Tucker's plan at first because I was the cop in that game and I was annoyed at the thought of being forced to role-claim.
Click to expand...

Remove your claim to be quoting me from your signature line.
 
When did Joko join the game? :lol:
 
I'd rather hang Fisher, Solaris or maybe Thor than X Factor. I dunno if I can change my vote to him; probably not, so I think it's up to you guys if were gonna go that way.

He has been shady, but he's the only minor role claim. I think it would be strange for scum to claim a minor role instead of vt and there has been no counterclaim (or, other claim of minor role).
 
X Factor said:
When did Joko join the game? :lol:

Originally Posted by joko104
The underlying logic of "pro-life" is pro-rape
Click to expand...

You have made this - and ever other thread you post on - abortion topic threads. So I'll find my messages on the topic you raised and post it on those threads you are changing to abortion topic threads.
 
joko104 said:
Remove your claim to be quoting me from your signature line.
Click to expand...

Hah. If someone put me in their sig, I'd never know. I have sigs off.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom