• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

How Did You Know?

Tigger

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Jul 25, 2011
Messages
12,879
Reaction score
2,707
Location
New England
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Very Conservative
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?
 
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?

I didn't. I didn't have to know for certain. There's nothing certain in life...except death. If one waits until one is certain? They're never going to get married or engaged.
 
.

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?

Her expanding tummy told me it was about time to get hitched.
 
I'm not certain that you really can know, and there is no certainty that someone who is "the one" now, will still be the one in 10, 20, or 30 years. Ya pays your nickel, ya takes your chances. ;)
 
If you can talk to someone 10 minutes at a time without feeling the need to strangle them, that's the one.
 
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?


You don't. They may be THE ONE for the next 10 years, or 50 years. When two people were committed to each other and worked out their differences, problems, dislikes and likes - marriage meant something. We're human, we screw up... today it's more of a financial arrangement. Precious few are committed the way my mother and father were and they had no perfect marriage by any means. It's also too easy to get a divorce, walk away, just say "oops, I don't love you any more" and move on. Culturally divorce is considered a "norm"; legally it's very common; financially it's even beneficial in some cases; socially it's fully accepted; religiously it's accepted.

To me, it's more of a commitment to stay together when there is no financial gain for either one, than it is getting married. The piece of paper, the signature, the ring no longer symbolizes what we thought they did in the past. That doesn't mean two people cannot MAKE those symbols mean that, it just means that when looking at our society as a whole, it's doesn't have the same meanings.
 
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?

i knew the first night i met my husband, at 16. of course, we were kinda sorta exceptionally wild back in the day, so i was at an after party at his house, with another guy. the other guy passed out, and my future husband and i just TALKED, all night long. he partied hard, but worked two jobs and was just, well, a nice guy. we married 3 years later, and are still married today, 34 years later. he's still a nice guy.
 
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?
I knew 2 weeks after I met her. I kept picturing marrying her, and kept scolding myself for letting me think about that that early. The biggest thing was that it was the easiest decision in the world to marry her, if she's not the one for me, I'm totally screwed.

People said we were too young to get married (19) and we only knew each other for 7 months, but when it's right, it's right. We're still together years later and trucking along just fine.
 
Last edited:
I didn't. I didn't have to know for certain. There's nothing certain in life...except death. If one waits until one is certain? They're never going to get married or engaged.

I'm not certain that you really can know, and there is no certainty that someone who is "the one" now, will still be the one in 10, 20, or 30 years. Ya pays your nickel, ya takes your chances. ;)

You don't. They may be THE ONE for the next 10 years, or 50 years....

Okay. Assuming that one cannot ever be Certain that He/She is "The One"; then how does one go about deciding whether or not that person is worth taking that chance on?

Or is this sort of like choosing which number you place all your chips on at the Roulette table?... with dumb luck, chance, and guesses being as good as any other set of factors one can come up with.
 
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?

no marriage is perfect but is the product of work and love.

however do you feel like you want to spend your life with this persom in your gut? if yes think on what the problems might be and if you can live with them or solve them without changing the nature of the relationship.

that will be your answer.

Sent from my YP-G1 using Tapatalk. My YP-G1 is a very nice device that hardly ever explodes or shoots jets of burning acid at my face. Samsung has done a good job in that respect in building it. However one has to consider hamsters in regard to android as cyborg hamsters are very cool. Imagine how fast an Android hamster could run in their exercise wheel for example.
 
She had never been married before. I had. Neither of us wanted to get married. Life was too much fun to want to ruin in with commitment. By the second date my brain screamed, "run away, run away". The same was happening to hear. A month later she moved in and we lived together for a year to make certain we weren't crazy. It'll be 20 years in May.

She is independent, stubborn, very intelligent, successful and she loves to travel. She loves dogs. She put's up with me. We appreciate each other and we don't have to work at it. We have always had a lot of trust in each other. We got lucky. Occasionally someone will ask us what the secret is. We tell them that we don't know and don't want to analyze is.
 
Okay. Assuming that one cannot ever be Certain that He/She is "The One"; then how does one go about deciding whether or not that person is worth taking that chance on?

Or is this sort of like choosing which number you place all your chips on at the Roulette table?... with dumb luck, chance, and guesses being as good as any other set of factors one can come up with.


If you're willing to, after contemplation, give up everything you own, all your other relationships and your very life for her... and you've felt that way for a while (more years than months)... then I'd say you've got marriage material. Even then though, you or she may not feel that way 2 years, 5 years or 10 years down the road. A buddy of mine currently going through a divorce says kids changed it for him and his wife. As soon as the kids showed up, she got cold, only cared about the kids, and then started cheating on him because he didn't become what she expected him to become. He didn't change at all... The biggest issue is that some women tend to think that marriage and kids will change a man and that rarely happens. Either accept them for who they are now and accept them to be that way going forward, or don't. Yes men change, but not many change a lot, and not many change to what she wants them to be. It goes the other way around too... the marriages I see lasting are the one's where there are no hidden expectations and there's acceptance: Each accepts each other and they love each other for who they really are.
 
Okay. Assuming that one cannot ever be Certain that He/She is "The One"; then how does one go about deciding whether or not that person is worth taking that chance on?

Or is this sort of like choosing which number you place all your chips on at the Roulette table?... with dumb luck, chance, and guesses being as good as any other set of factors one can come up with.

It's like a lock, certain tumblers keep falling into place to where you say, "this could work out for awhile." But after the commitment you have to be willing to do all that's realistically possible to compliment and accommodate each other.
 
Okay. Assuming that one cannot ever be Certain that He/She is "The One"; then how does one go about deciding whether or not that person is worth taking that chance on?

Or is this sort of like choosing which number you place all your chips on at the Roulette table?... with dumb luck, chance, and guesses being as good as any other set of factors one can come up with.

Well, quite frankly, she is taking a chance as well. just because you think you have found *the one*, doesn't mean that she will still believe you are *the one* down the road. There are no certainties in life, whether you're talking relationships or even life itself. You will both change as you grow older. The best hope is that you still like each other enough to stick it out. Love is one of those things that is very misunderstood. Most people think that it's a feeling, but it's really an action and a test of your will.
 
no marriage is perfect but is the product of work and love.

however do you feel like you want to spend your life with this persom in your gut? if yes think on what the problems might be and if you can live with them or solve them without changing the nature of the relationship.

that will be your answer.

Thanks mega. Very well thought out answer and exactly the sort of thing I was looking for. It is greatly appreciated.
 
If you're willing to, after contemplation, give up everything you own, all your other relationships and your very life for her... and you've felt that way for a while (more years than months)... then I'd say you've got marriage material. Even then though, you or she may not feel that way 2 years, 5 years or 10 years down the road....

I think we're headed in that direction. Obviously it's only been about two and a half months (almost 3) but it defintely feels like we might be headed that way. We're both truly hoping that's how things work out, but we also don't want to rush things either. Here's hoping that six to eight months from now we still feel the same way.


It's like a lock, certain tumblers keep falling into place to where you say, "this could work out for awhile." But after the commitment you have to be willing to do all that's realistically possible to compliment and accommodate each other.

We seem to naturally compliment and accomodate each other (at least so far). It's been a great ride for both of us over the last eleven weeks. We're going to have to see what evolves and how things continue from here, but we're both definitely off the market for the short-term and hopefully permanently.


Well, quite frankly, she is taking a chance as well. just because you think you have found *the one*, doesn't mean that she will still believe you are *the one* down the road. There are no certainties in life, whether you're talking relationships or even life itself. You will both change as you grow older. The best hope is that you still like each other enough to stick it out. Love is one of those things that is very misunderstood. Most people think that it's a feeling, but it's really an action and a test of your will.

Very interesting and insightful commentary, lizzie. We've talked about it enough for me to know that she's feeling and thinking things very similar to what I am. Her family absolutely adores me. She met my mom for the first time last Friday and they hit it off quite nicely. I can honestly say I've never felt like this about a woman at any other time in my life. If it were feasible I'd probably have asked her to move in with me already, and I'm quite sure she would have agreed. Here's hoping things continue to progress and this turns into a permanent arrangement.
 
I knew 2 weeks after I met her. I kept picturing marrying her, and kept scolding myself for letting me think about that that early. The biggest thing was that it was the easiest decision in the world to marry her, if she's not the one for me, I'm totally screwed.

People said we were too young to get married (19) and we only knew each other for 7 months, but when it's right, it's right. We're still together years later and trucking along just fine.

thats how my marriage is too. it was compketely natural and i knew before i even spoke to her.

13 years later, we have had tough times and we make sure to not take each other for granted and we are fine.

Sent from my YP-G1 using Tapatalk. My YP-G1 is a very nice device that hardly ever explodes or shoots jets of burning acid at my face. Samsung has done a good job in that respect in building it. However one has to consider hamsters in regard to android as cyborg hamsters are very cool. Imagine how fast an Android hamster could run in their exercise wheel for example.
 
other things to keep in mind. if she has had a bad day, offer to make dinner, bring flowers, listen, do something.

if the trash needs taking out or something else, do it without hesitation.

if she needs to be held, hold her. if she isnt confident, then take the lead.

basically, listen to her and honor her. wothout this, it will never work.

Sent from my YP-G1 using Tapatalk. My YP-G1 is a very nice device that hardly ever explodes or shoots jets of burning acid at my face. Samsung has done a good job in that respect in building it. However one has to consider hamsters in regard to android as cyborg hamsters are very cool. Imagine how fast an Android hamster could run in their exercise wheel for example.
 
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?

just as there is no certainty, there is no ONE
there are some and hopefully you found ONE of them

from your posts, you strike me as being a hard person to please (in some ways; in other ways your very direct behavior would allow someone to know exactly where you stand)
if i can sense that on the internet, then she certainly knows it from these weeks you have been together
that she has not fled, is a positive sign [i am NOT being sarcastic or intentionally mean in saying that]
glad you may have found your soulmate and equally glad you are intending to wait a while and see if the magic remains intact. just be absolutely candid in your expectations and desires and hope she will be equally honest in telling you how she feels rather than responding with what she believes you want to hear

my wife was a young widow. i had a starter marriage years before. so, we both had an understanding about the complexities and realities of a marriage. i had vowed never to get married again, and thought i could not father children. so, the prospect of marriage when i met her was beyond remote

there were many, many women in my life; sexual partners, adventure partners, intellectual partners. some of them were also good friends (and thankfully, remain good friends). but none of them were the whole package. none were the women i would want to be my childrens' mother, or they were not the kind of women who would not bore me to tears, or the gals i could not wait for them to leave after spending time together. one i was very close to, and contemplated marriage with - probably the most beautiful and sexual woman i have ever seen, much less known - would be absolutely catty to waitresses, for no reason whatsoever. that was a sign telling me to stay away. her subsequent history of relationships proved my inner instinct correct. another was a very high income earner, but insisted on spending more than she made. she was gorgeous and sensual and bright. and a few years after i married someone else she was also bankrupt
that inner voice. listen to it. i got married the first time despite that inner voice screaming "don't do it". after dating for two years i naively believed i needed to marry the woman i was with who wanted to be married. i tuned out that inner voice and made a huge mistake
i guess i am trying - struggling - to say listen to your heart but also listen to your head. is this woman compatible, in bed, in values, in expectations, in life. is this woman someone you want to be there. someone you want to be with when she is not around; is this woman your FRIEND. if you BOTH want children, would this woman make a good mother to your kids
if you really believe the answer to those questions is yes, then chances are good you have stumbled into a relationship with one of the ones
and do not let her get away

thus june will mark 28 years of being glad i found someone who could put up with me
 
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?

i couldnt know and this is why i ended my engagement last month ,if i were able to know this ,i would propably be married now
 
This question is for all of the DP Members who are Engaged or Married......

How did you KNOW, for CERTAIN that your Husband or Wife was THE ONE?

When she explained it to me. Slow and clearly.
 
i couldnt know and this is why i ended my engagement last month ,if i were able to know this ,i would propably be married now

I'm very sorry to hear that Medusa. Hopefully things work out.
 
Back
Top Bottom