• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Palin's reckless views on obesity

More intrusion, more regulations, more federal funding we can't afford.
Here's just a small taste of her huge agenda.
Mrs. Obama has already been talking about some of the 70 recommendations, such as having pediatricians measure children's Body Mass Index in order to track healthy weight. Others include:

- "Asking the federal government to revisit rules on television advertising aimed at kids "if voluntary efforts to limit the marketing of less healthy foods and beverages to children do not yield substantial results."

I believe Reagon, using the former Surgeon General, C. Everett Koop, did the same thing concerning cigerettes.

- "Federally funded and private insurance plans should cover services necessary to prevent, assess, and provide care to overweight and obese children." Entertainment and technology companies should continue to develop new approaches for using technology to engage children in physical activity."
And you find fault with this? Recognizing that children of this digital/technology age are using computers, video game systems and handheld devices, i.e., cell phones with streaming video/audio, more and more. Therefore, wouldn't it make sense to convence video game and cell phone companies to develop software that will aid our youth in becoming more aware of their health? Wii Fit anyone?

But the proposals, issued by a task force led by White House Domestic Policy Adviser Melody Barnes, stays away from any firm recommendations on controversial matters pending in Congress, state legislatures and city councils, such as taxes on junk foods and sodas. Instead, there is a recommendation to "analyze the effect of state and local sales taxes on less healthy, energy-dense foods."

There have been efforts by several states to impose taxes on sugarly foods and beverages. Since the states have begun to take these such initiatives on their own - something those who share your political views claim they encourage states to do...take more control for themselves - the way I see it is the "government staying OUT of the state's business. Don't be such a hypocrit, hon.

Just as breastfeeding can reduce a child's chances of obesity later, reducing sugar in children's diets can also make a difference, the report notes. "Children today consume a substantial amount of added sugars through a whole range of products. . . . Targets for reducing added sugar will then need to be established that track the overall goal of driving obesity rates down to 5% by 2030."
Michelle Obama Unveils Anti-Childhood Obesity Action Plan

I don't see a problem with this whatsoever. Healthier children today means a healthier society tomorrow which means fewer elderly people on Medicare which is taking up atleast 1/4 of the nation's budget. Makes perfect sense to me; enact preventative health measures now, see the benefits later. What's wrong with that?
 
Rather than getting in to the tit-for-tat, and pointing out once again the irony of M'obama talking about weight and her ginormous ass, I'll juts point out that we have LOTS of problems that are contributing to obesity, and just as the "Just say "no to drugs campaign didnt address the fact that normal happy healthy well adjusted people dont typically turn to drugs so those that do prolly need more than just a slogan, just saying "Move it" doesnt address the obesity problems. For the poor, the food they can typically afford (or are given) is high in carb and starch and low in protein and nutrition. Movin it aint gonna change that. For the majority of kids, obesity is a bi-product of a sedentary lifestyle...the curse of affluence...the readily availability of entertainment on the couch, etc. Some families live an outdoor, exercise filled lifestyle. But some? Most? Most kids sit on their ass playing video games, watching TV, throwing down Code Red and chips, hanging out at the mall...and most parents are footing the bill without any expectation of their kids to work. We have for several generations now spoon fed children and lowered expectations. Those children have had children...hell...they have had grandchildren. Hard work (not just labor intensive jobs but yard work for crying out loud) has become obsolete. We pay yard service companies to do the job our 12 year old should be doing. Its not an exercise problem...its a multigenerational overall lifestyle problem.
 
More intrusion, more regulations, more federal funding we can't afford.
Here's just a small taste of her huge agenda.
Mrs. Obama has already been talking about some of the 70 recommendations, such as having pediatricians measure children's Body Mass Index in order to track healthy weight.
Umm... having doctors monitor health. That smacks of Orwellian Big Brotehr. I'll give you that one. No one needs to be monitoring my kids' health but me and their doctor..uh wat?

- "Asking the federal government to revisit rules on television advertising aimed at kids "if voluntary efforts to limit the marketing of less healthy foods and beverages to children do not yield substantial results."
This is somehow unrelated to the government making decisions for me.

- "Federally funded and private insurance plans should cover services necessary to prevent, assess, and provide care to overweight and obese children."
And this is also somehow unrelated to the government making decisions for me.

Entertainment and technology companies should continue to develop new approaches for using technology to engage children in physical activity."
This is an opinion that someone has expressed. And this is also somehow unrelated to the government making decisions for me.

When do we get to the part about the govt taking away my ability to make choices about what my children eat? When do we get to the part of it being forced upon me?

But the proposals, issued by a task force led by White House Domestic Policy Adviser Melody Barnes, stays away from any firm recommendations on controversial matters pending in Congress, state legislatures and city councils, such as taxes on junk foods and sodas. Instead, there is a recommendation to "analyze the effect of state and local sales taxes on less healthy, energy-dense foods."
And this is also somehow unrelated to the government making decisions for me.

Just as breastfeeding can reduce a child's chances of obesity later, reducing sugar in children's diets can also make a difference, the report notes. "Children today consume a substantial amount of added sugars through a whole range of products. . . .
These are statements of fact that are also somehow unrelated to the government making decisions for me.


"...Targets for reducing added sugar will then need to be established that track the overall goal of driving obesity rates down to 5% by 2030."
Michelle Obama Unveils Anti-Childhood Obesity Action Plan
Establishing these targets will somehow be the government making decisions for me?



So it doesn't have anything at all to do with the govt trying to "take over and make decisions for us". Okay. that's pretty much as I thought.

So she isn't actually going to take people's children away. She isn't going to take food out of children's hands. There will be no criminal nor civil penalties. It's not even clear if I will get the stink-eye.

Yawn
 
here's the down low of how the govt is going to force this down our thraots and make decisions for us:

from http://www.letsmove.gov/pdf/TaskForce_on_Childhood_Obesity_May2010_FullReport.pdf


Summary of Recommendations

Recommendation 1.1: Pregnant women and women planning a
pregnancy should be informed of the importance of conceiving at a
healthy weight and having a healthy weight gain during pregnancy,
based on the relevant recommendations of the Institute of Medicine.

Recommendation 1.2: Education and outreach efforts about prenatal
care should be enhanced through creative approaches that take into
account the latest in technology and communications. Partners in
this effort could include companies that develop technology-based
communications tools, as well as companies that market products and
services to pregnant women or prospective parents.

Recommendation 1.3: Hospitals and health care providers should use
maternity care practices that empower new mothers to breastfeed,
such as the Baby-Friendly hospital standards.

Recommendation 1.4: Health care providers and insurance companies
should provide information to pregnant women and new mothers on
breastfeeding, including the availability of educational classes, and
connect pregnant women and new mothers to breastfeeding support
programs to help them make an informed infant feeding decision

Recommendation 1.5: Local health departments and communitybased
organizations, working with health care providers, insurance
companies, and others should develop peer support programs that
empower pregnant women and mothers to get the help and support
they need from other mothers who have breastfed

Recommendation 1.6: Early childhood settings should support
breastfeeding

Recommendation 1.7: Federal and State agencies conducting health
research should prioritize research into the effects of possibly obesogenic
chemicals.

Recommendation 1.8: The AAP guidelines on screen time should be made more available to parents, and young children should be encouraged to spend less time using digital media and more time being physically active.

Recommendation 1.9: The AAP guidelines on screen time should be made more available in early childhood settings.

Recommendation 1.10: The Federal government, incorporating input from health care providers and other stakeholders, should provide clear, actionable guidance to states, providers, and families on how to increase physical activity, improve nutrition, and reduce screen time in early child care settings.

Recommendation 1.11: States should be encouraged to strengthen licensing standards and Quality Rating and Improvement Systems to support good program practices regarding nutrition, physical activity, and screen time in early education and child care settings

Recommendation 1.12: The Federal government should look for opportunities in all early childhood programs it funds (such as the Child and Adult Care Food Program at USDA, the Child Care and Development Block Grant, Head Start, military child care, and Federal employee child care) to base policies and practices on current scientific evidence related to child nutrition and physical activity, and seek to improve access to these programs

Recommendation 2.1: The Federal government, working with local communities, should disseminate information about the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans through simple, easily actionable messages for consumers and a next generation Food Pyramid.

Recommendation 2.2: The FDA and USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service should collaborate with the food and beverage industry to develop and implement a standard system of nutrition labeling for the front of packages

Recommendation 2.3: Restaurants and vending machine operators subject to the new requirement in the Affordable Care Act should be encouraged to begin displaying calorie counts as soon as possible

Recommendation 2.4: Restaurants should consider their portion sizes, improve children’s menus, and make healthy options the default choice whenever possible.

Recommendation 2.5: The food and beverage industry should extend its self-regulatory program to cover all forms of marketing to children, and food retailers should avoid in-store marketing that promotes unhealthy products to children.

Recommendation 2.6: All media and entertainment companies should limit the licensing of their popular characters to food and beverage products that are healthy and consistent with science-based nutrition standards

Recommendation 2.7: The food and beverage industry and the media and entertainment industry should jointly adopt meaningful, uniform nutrition standards for marketing food and beverages to children, as well as a uniform standard for what constitutes marketing to children.

Recommendation 2.8: Industry should provide technology to help consumers distinguish between advertisements for healthy and unhealthy foods and to limit their children’s exposure to unhealthy food advertisements.

Recommendation 2.9: If voluntary efforts to limit the marketing of less healthy foods and beverages to children do not yield substantial results, the FCC could consider revisiting and modernizing rules on commercial time during children’s programming

Recommendation 2.10: Pediatricians should be encouraged to routinely calculate children’s BMI and provide information to parents about how to help their children achieve a healthy weight.

Recommendation 2.11: Federally-funded and private insurance plans should cover services necessary to prevent, assess, and provide care to overweight and obese children.

Recommendation 2.12: Dentists and other oral health care providers should be encouraged to promote healthy habits and counsel families on childhood obesity prevention as part of routine preventive dental care

Recommendation 2.13: Medical and other health professional schools, health professional associations, and health care systems should ensure that health care providers have the necessary training and education to effectively prevent, diagnose, and treat obese and overweight children

Recommendation 3.1: Update Federal nutritional standards for school meals and improve the nutritional quality of USDA commodities provided to schools.

Recommendation 3.2: Increase resources for school meals.

Recommendation 3.3: USDA should continue its outreach and technical assistance to help provide training for school food service professionals.

Recommendation 3.4: Schools should consider upgrading their cafeteria equipment to support the provision of healthier foods, for example, by swapping out deep fryers for salad bars.

Recommendation 3.5: USDA should work with all stakeholders to develop innovative ways to encourage students to make healthier choices.

Recommendation 3.6: USDA should work to connect school meals programs to local growers, and use farm-to-school programs, where possible, to incorporate more fresh, appealing food in school meals

Recommendation 3.7: Schools should be encouraged to make improvements in their school meal programs through the HealthierUS Schools Challenge in advance of updated Federal standards.

Recommendation 3.8: Increase the alignment of foods sold at school, including in the a la carte lines and vending machines, with the Dietary Guidelines.

Recommendation 3.9: Food companies should be encouraged to develop new products and reformulate existing products so they meet nutritional standards based on the Dietary Guidelines and appeal to children.

Recommendation 3.10: USDA and the U.S. Department of Education should collaborate with states to increase the availability and consistency of nutrition education in schools.

Recommendation 3.11: Where possible, use school gardens to educate students about healthy eating.

Recommendation 3.12: Technical assistance should be provided to schools about how to a cafeteria and lunch room environment can support and encourage a healthful meal

Recommendation 3.13: Schools should be encouraged to ensure that choosing a healthy school meal does not have a social cost for a child

Recommendation 3.14: Schools should be encouraged to consider the impact of food marketing on education.

Recommendation 3.15: School districts should be encouraged to create, post, and implement a strong local school wellness policy.

Recommendation 3.16: Promote good nutrition through afterschool programs.

Recommendation 3.17: Promote healthy behaviors in juvenile correctional and related facilities.

Recommendation 4.1: Launch a multi-year, multi-agency Healthy Food Financing Initiative to leverage private funds to increase the availability of affordable, healthy foods in underserved urban and rural communities across the country.

Recommendation 4.2: Local governments should be encouraged to create incentives to attract supermarkets and grocery stores to underserved neighborhoods and improve transportation routes to healthy food retailers.

Recommendation 4.3: Food distributors should be encouraged to explore ways to use their existing distribution chains and systems to bring fresh and healthy foods into underserved communities.

Recommendation 4.4: Encourage communities to promote efforts to provide fruits and vegetables in a variety of settings and encourage the establishment and use of direct–to-consumer marketing outlets such as farmers’ markets and community supported agriculture subscriptions.

Recommendation 4.5: Encourage the establishment of regional, city, or county food policy councils to enhance comprehensive food system policy that improve health

Recommendation 4.6: Encourage publicly and privately-managed facilities that serve children, such as hospitals, afterschool programs, recreation centers, and parks (including national parks) to implement policies and practices, consistent with the Dietary Guidelines, to promote healthy foods and beverages and reduce or eliminate the availability of calorie-dense, nutrient-poor foods

Recommendation 4.7: Provide economic incentives to increase production of healthy foods such as fruits, vegetables, and whole grains, as well as create greater access to local and healthy food for consumers.

Recommendation 4.8: Demonstrate and evaluate the effect of targeted subsidies on purchases of healthy food through nutrition assistance programs.

Recommendation 4.9: Analyze the effect of state and local sales taxes on less healthy, energy-dense foods

Recommendation 4.10: The food, beverage, and restaurant industries should be encouraged to use their creativity and resources to develop or reformulate more healthful foods for children and young people

Recommendation 4.11: Increase participation rates in USDA nutrition assistance programs through creative outreach and improved customer service, state adoption of improved policy options and technology systems, and effective practices to ensure ready access to nutrition assistance program benefits, especially for children.
 
here's the down low of how the govt is going to force this down our thraots and make decisions for us:

from http://www.letsmove.gov/pdf/TaskForce_on_Childhood_Obesity_May2010_FullReport.pdf


Summary of Recommendations cont

Recommendation 5.1: Developers of local school wellness policies should be encouraged to include strong physical activity components, on par with nutrition components.

Recommendation 5.2: The President’s Challenge should be updated to ensure consistency with the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans and to ensure ease of use and implementation by schools. Private sector partners with an interest in physical activity should help enroll children in the Presidential Active Lifestyle Award program

Recommendation 5.3: State and local educational agencies should be encouraged to increase the quality and frequency of sequential, age- and developmentally- appropriate physical education for all students, taught by certified PE teachers

Recommendation 5.4: State and local educational agencies should be encouraged to promote recess for elementary students and physical activity breaks for older students, and provide support to schools to implement recess in a healthy way that promotes physical activity and social skill development.

Recommendation 5.5: State and local educational agencies should be encouraged to provide opportunities in and outside of school for students at increased risk for physical inactivity, including children with disabilities, children with asthma and other chronic diseases, and girls

Recommendation 5.6: Federal, state, and local educational agencies, in partnership with communities and businesses, should work to support programs to extend the school day, including afterschool programs, which offer and enhance physical activity opportunities in their programs

Recommendation 5.7: State and local educational agencies should be encouraged to support interscholastic sports and help decrease prohibitive costs of sports by curbing practices such as “pay-to-play,” working with other public and private sector partners.

Recommendation 5.8: Reauthorize a Surface Transportation Act that enhances livability and physical activity.

Recommendation 5.9: The Environmental Protection Agency should assist school districts that may be interested in siting guidelines for new schools that consider the promotion of physical activity, including whether students will be able to walk or bike to school

Recommendation 5.10: Communities should be encouraged to consider the impacts of built environment policies and regulations on human health.

Recommendation 5.11: The Federal Safe Routes to School Program (SRTS) should be continued and enhanced to accommodate the growing interest in implementing Safe Routes to Schools plans in communities.

Recommendation 5.12: “Active transport” should be encouraged between homes, schools, and community destinations for afterschool activities, including to and from parks, libraries, transit, bus stops, and recreation centers.

Recommendation 5.13: Increase the number of safe and accessible parks and playgrounds, particularly in underserved and low-income communities

Recommendation 5.14: The Federal government should continue to support investments in a wide range of outdoor recreation venues, such as National Parks, Forests, Refuges and other public lands, and expand opportunities for children to enjoy these venues.

Recommendation 5.15: Local governments should be encouraged to enter into joint use agreements to increase children’s access to community sites for indoor and outdoor recreation

Recommendation 5.16: The business sector should be encouraged to consider which resources and physical assets like fields and gyms can be used to increase students’ access to outdoor and indoor recreational venues

Recommendation 5.17: Entertainment and technology companies should continue to develop new approaches for using technology to engage children in physical activity​
 
Fresh off from their appearance on the restore socialism stage - where they collected crucial data regarding controlling masses of people - Jamie and Adam get recruited by Michelle Obama to test new technologies to implement her devious plan

candybaby.jpg


It seems that images of phase II where they shove a funnel into the baby's mouth and veggie-boarded the test baby with Brussel sprout puree is not available.
 
Last edited:
In addition, the plan features Fat Panels who will decide if Granny is thin enough to live.
Obesity Rating for Every American Must Be Included in Stimulus-Mandated Electronic Health Records, Says HHS | CNSnews.com
Under this mandate in the stimulus law, Secretary Sebelius issued a regulation--developed by Dr. Blumenthal--that requires that all EHRs keep track of a person’s Body Mass Index (BMI) score. Body Mass Index is a ratio between a person’s weight and height, and is used to determine whether or not someone is overweight or obese. It is the preferred method of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) for measuring obesity.

Michelle Obama has made dealing with the problem of childhood obesity the main theme of her term as First Lady.


Nothing would surprise me with this administration.
 

Palin again proves she is a moron, and a hypocrite. She is jumping on Michelle Obama for trying to fight obesity, meanwhile Palin was abstinence only education and had a knocked up teen daughter.

She is going to sit on her a** and say the government doesn't have a right to tell us to exercise, but she says government does have the authority to teach OUR kids ignorance about birth control and protection and preach virginity.. utterly sicking.

Many conservatives like her try to have it both ways with this limited government stuff.. and it's BS. If you believe in limited government, then prove it by stop being a hypocrite..

And the fact is, people are stupid and ignorant.. People don't raise their kids right about eating and exercising, or even proper morals or manners. I know plenty of people personally like my sister.. Feeds her son fast food and pizza, and all he does is play xbox but he isn't fat. He has high metabolism, but his diet is still unhealthy, but I think she does it out of convenience more than anything.

I had a boss and she was the same way.. her daughter even had a health problem and she always hauled her into work everyday after kindergarten with a happy meal. She was already chubby little girl too.

The government doesn't have to babysit people, even those people. That is not a solution, but pretending all parents know how to feed their kids, like Palin does, just offends my common sense. They say it's better to teach a man to fish, than give him one.. so it's better to teach parents and kids through public outreach or through evil community organizing..
 
Don't you think there are larger drains on our welfare system and government assistance than obesity? You know, things that could actually be solved by government intervention that didn't involve taking away freedom and liberty from American citizens?
This crusade on obesity has nothing to do with the cost to society.
It's about control.
It also will not make people thin unless you plan to lock them up and monitor everything they eat.
Education is fine, but regulation and more spending? No way.

And raising children into a world of obesity, a lifetime of health problems and an early grave *isn't* robbing those children of liberty?

It's not liek they're forming some sort of gestapo and punishing parents for poor diet-habits. They're just encouraging and being supportive of healthier choices.
 
What I'm talking about is when problems don't need action to be fixed. For example, if I break my toe, it will heal in time. The problem is solved, no matter how well it is done, and I didn't need to take action on it. Could I have fixed it better if I took action on it? Sure, but that isn't my point. Obesity is exactly that kind of thing. Society is what caused the problem, and society is what will fix it. It might take time, it might not work the way you wish, but it will fix itself. There is no action that needs to be taken. The problem with people like yourself is you think you can craft society, or that you have the right to do so. Neither is so.

Society hasn't fixed a lot of problems it's created.. Social organization and agency is what creates a lot of our problems..
 
Then what do you propose we do about the fact that it's predicted that the majority of Americans will have diabetes by 2020? What do we do about the fact that the majority of us are not in fit enough shape to fight? "Nothing" is not a good enough answer.

How about going back to to manditory PE in school and not make it some wimpy program. Heck I remember PE in high school where we had a session on wrestling, track, etc. It was not a recreational PE. How about parents getting their offsprings off their butts (parents also) and get out and play.
My generation did not need the Govt telling us what we ccanand can't eat. If think the govt. should, it says a lot about what road this country may be heading down.
 
Obesity Rating for Every American Must Be Included in Stimulus-Mandated Electronic Health Records, Says HHS | CNSnews.com
Under this mandate in the stimulus law, Secretary Sebelius issued a regulation--developed by Dr. Blumenthal--that requires that all EHRs keep track of a person’s Body Mass Index (BMI) score. Body Mass Index is a ratio between a person’s weight and height, and is used to determine whether or not someone is overweight or obese. It is the preferred method of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) for measuring obesity.

Michelle Obama has made dealing with the problem of childhood obesity the main theme of her term as First Lady.


Nothing would surprise me with this administration.
And this item you're posting here--which has very little to do with Michelle Obama and even less with the govt trying to "take over and make decisions for us"--scares you because...you don't want your doctor to know how tall you are nor how much you weigh?
 
We have had food readily available far before this ever became a problem. I highly doubt that is a cause. As for getting more exercise, ofcourse, but that is just a habit that has plenty of chances to change on its own.

A lot of preprocessed food is widely known as being unhealthy and fattening.. even baby formula is well known to be less beneficial to a baby, but it's a million dollar industry. We live in society of consumption and convenience, so when a female doesn't learn how to breast feed quickly, she just goes to formula.... even if she is poor, she'll move to formula and get it via WIC. That has become acceptable today.

It's easier to be unhealthy and convenient than it is to LEARN how to be independent.. how to make your own food, grow your own vegetables, be an economic independent entity and feeding yourself while you are rich or poor

I am not saying this is deserving of government punishment, but I believe self sufficiency and independence are a major part of our founding principle values. If people learned how to grow their own food and feed themselves independently again, I think the poor would be less likely to starve without assistance and WIC would be less of an occurrence.

It really seems like common sense to me..
 
How about going back to to manditory PE in school and not make it some wimpy program. Heck I remember PE in high school where we had a session on wrestling, track, etc. It was not a recreational PE. How about parents getting their offsprings off their butts (parents also) and get out and play.
My generation did not need the Govt telling us what we ccanand can't eat. If think the govt. should, it says a lot about what road this country may be heading down.

Exactly - intervention and guidance wouldn't BE necessary if people didn't choose - on their own and iwth their freedom - to become fat lazy slobs.
People had freedom - and are just ruinging their health and the health of their children with their freedom.

What happens to freedom when you abuse it? You lose it.

If people don't want the government to get involvedi n your personal life you shouldn't give them a reason - you know, if I don't want my car serached I shouldn't give the cops a reason to think I'm stoking some toke.
 
I don't know who is contributing to the hype on Palin more, conservatives or liberals. Seems to be a dead heat these days.

Just stop already.

Couldn't agree with you more here. The Left fears her because they view her as a threat to their power base. The GOP establishment fears her because they view her as a threat to their power base.

This is all about the Ruling Class protecting it's own and it's own power. Nothing more, nothing less.
 
It's about time someone attacked Michelle Obama for this. I said the same thing when Laura bush wanted my future kids to learn how to read. Big gubment needs to stay away from my fat obese stupid illiterate children. Lol.

But, where would we get future conservatives if we allow our kids to grow up stoopid? Oh wait, I answered my own question......:2razz:
 
Last edited:
LOL He's not going anywhere. I thought everyone loved him there. Well maybe not teachers and other unions.
I know other governors are taking notice and may follow his lead.

No, lots of folks can't stand him. The good thing about him not leaving is that we get to vote him out of office in 2013.
 
It's funny how all these vague accusations never hold up to scrutiny.

Actually, it's beyond funny. It's typical of the extreme right. NOTHING they say holds up to scrutiny.
 
Actually, it's beyond funny. It's typical of the extreme right. NOTHING they say holds up to scrutiny.

Meanwhile, they support government babysitting it's citizens, but they won't own up to it.. Yep.. it's deserving of lulz
 
Back
Top Bottom