• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

School's Nation of Islam handout paints Founding Fathers as racists [W:293]

Yes, but the faults, like gossip, can be exaggerated to the point where they become more important than the greatness which was achieved, as though they should have shared billing.

I am a history major and through my many years of history classes K-12 + five years of college I never had a teacher who emphasized the bad over the good when it came to the Founders. After all, what make the biggest impact in history: Jefferson's Louisiana Purchase or his philandering with slave women?
 
I am a history major and through my many years of history classes K-12 + five years of college I never had a teacher who emphasized the bad over the good when it came to the Founders. After all, what make the biggest impact in history: Jefferson's Louisiana Purchase or his philandering with slave women?
They don't have to 'emphasize" it.
 
Yeah, and it was ridiculous. You honestly think Washington's Birthday was changed to President's Day to diminish the historical relevance of the Founding Fathers. That is beyond stupid.
You claim it's called "President's Day" to honor Abraham Lincoln. That speaks for itself.
 
Well, you know, if the shoe fits.

By today's standards - yes - they were racist. They just didn't care back then which is why slavery and other practices were permitted to continue for so long.

But to try to claim they were NOT is absurd.

Let's at least give credit to half of those on the mount: Washington and Jefferson. What other country besides America on the planet was more free back in 1776?

Anyone else??? Huh????

I don't belive Washington and Jefferson were any more racist that our current installment, Barak Obama---who continually reminds the world of his Blackness---even though it is semi-Blackness.

Now Islamic people are the very last people on the earth that should be complaining about slavery (this just cracks me up).

You see, the very first place to outlaw slavery was Iceland back in 1117. The Nordic countries were at the forefront on human rights. Islamic nations are the among the worst, knowing that Saudia Arabia was the last nation to outlaw slavery.

Abolition of slavery timeline - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

If Liberals want to cry about slavery, let them go the the nations where slaves can still be purchased: Togo, the Ivory Coast, Senegal, and many others. You sure won't see the Nation of Islam going into these areas and protesting about it.

Slavery still haunts Africa, where millions remain captive - Los Angeles Times
 
If Liberals want to cry about slavery, let them go the the nations where slaves can still be purchased: Togo, the Ivory Coast, Senegal, and many others. You sure won't see the Nation of Islam going into these areas and protesting about it.
They won't do that. They'll complain about American history regarding slavery, women's right's, voting rights, and so on but will ignore modern slavery, the sale of women into slavery, FMG, and so on. In fact they will even bar women who suffered from Islamic atrocities first hand from speaking.

America is their target for their complaints and has been for the past generation. They haven't a clue outside that.
 
They don't have to 'emphasize" it.

The vast majority dont. The teaching of history should be about no agenda except the teaching of facts from the past. Anything other than that is just propaganda.
 
The vast majority dont. The teaching of history should be about no agenda except the teaching of facts from the past. Anything other than that is just propaganda.
I cannot help but notice that patriotism in America has been on the skids for the last generation or more, and the number of heroes for succeeding generations to look up to has declined.

Every nation needs heroes to inspire successive generations as to what a successful and productive life means. Now the heroes in the United States are not George Washington, or Abraham Lincoln but celebrities, and the more debauched they are the more celebrated they often become. We search for the flaws in our heroes rather than celebrating their achievements.

Maybe teaching that Washington held slaves is all to the good, or that MLK was a womanizer, or that Jackie Robinson had a bad temper, the warts and all theory, but I'm not sure I see the advantage, unless it applies to biographers and students who have a deeper interest in these people and are of an age where they've developed some perspective.

The American culture has become more shabby, and it might be that their heroes have become more shabby also.
 
I cannot help but notice that patriotism in America has been on the skids for the last generation or more, and the number of heroes for succeeding generations to look up to has declined.

Every nation needs heroes to inspire successive generations as to what a successful and productive life means. Now the heroes in the United States are not George Washington, or Abraham Lincoln but celebrities, and the more debauched they are the more celebrated they often become. We search for the flaws in our heroes rather than celebrating their achievements.

Maybe teaching that Washington held slaves is all to the good, or that MLK was a womanizer, or that Jackie Robinson had a bad temper, the warts and all theory, but I'm not sure I see the advantage, unless it applies to biographers and students who have a deeper interest in these people and are of an age where they've developed some perspective.

The American culture has become more shabby, and it might be that their heroes have become more shabby also.

I do agree the people we tend to "look up to" nowadays are poor role models. However, I am not convinced this is the result of a more critical look at historical figures. When did you first realize your father was not a perfect person? Was he no longer your role model afterwards?
 
I do agree the people we tend to "look up to" nowadays are poor role models. However, I am not convinced this is the result of a more critical look at historical figures. When did you first realize your father was not a perfect person? Was he no longer your role model afterwards?
In fact my father left when I was a child so my heroes were in sports, the men who tried their best and showed no fear.

When I became a father I mimicked those who were good fathers in the movies or on TV. I was then able to draw from them and became, according to my sons, a good father myself. I needed role models though, just as most children do, but who do we have now? The sports heroes? Politicians? Cowboys? Celebrities? Even TV fathers tend to be wimps, ridiculed by their wives and children.

But I may be making too much of this. If I can be a hero to my own children, and they don't mimic the celebrities of today then, on a personal level, I can be well satisfied.
 
In fact my father left when I was a child

I am sorry to hear that.

so my heroes were in sports, the men who tried their best and showed no fear.

Fair enough. But should we bury our heads in the sand when one of our sports heroes throws his teammates under the bus? Cheats on his wife? Gambles his money away? Or even murders someone? I'm sure there were many young Pats fans who looked up to Aaron Hernandez at one point. If anything, we should hold these leaders to a higher standard and be very critical when they screw up. After all, what they do can impact the young mind of a child.


If I can be a hero to my own children, and they don't mimic the celebrities of today then, on a personal level, I can be well satisfied.

I agree, a father's presence is more critical than ever in today's society for the exact reasons you speak of. As a teacher, I see the effect every day on fatherless children. And even when a father screws up (which he inevitably will) the children will continue to respect him if he owns up to his mistakes. I have no doubt that if our Founders were alive today they would concur slavery was a horrific institution that went against the principles they were espousing. Students can admire their courage and strength while acknowledging their mistakes. As I said before, I have yet to meet a professor or teacher who focused more on the faults of America's figures than their accomplishments.
 
I am sorry to hear that.
Thanks, though we know people have gone through much worse.

Fair enough. But should we bury our heads in the sand when one of our sports heroes throws his teammates under the bus? Cheats on his wife? Gambles his money away? Or even murders someone? I'm sure there were many young Pats fans who looked up to Aaron Hernandez at one point. If anything, we should hold these leaders to a higher standard and be very critical when they screw up. After all, what they do can impact the young mind of a child.
If one of my sports heroes cheated on his wife I certainly wouldn't have known about it. Same with gambling or any other vice. The press just kept it to themselves, and I'm grateful they did because, as a child, I needed someone to look up to. Of course murder is something else entirely.


I agree, a father's presence is more critical than ever in today's society for the exact reasons you speak of. As a teacher, I see the effect every day on fatherless children. And even when a father screws up (which he inevitably will) the children will continue to respect him if he owns up to his mistakes. I have no doubt that if our Founders were alive today they would concur slavery was a horrific institution that went against the principles they were espousing. Students can admire their courage and strength while acknowledging their mistakes. As I said before, I have yet to meet a professor or teacher who focused more on the faults of America's figures than their accomplishments.
Well, I hope you are right. I appreciate your sincerity.
 
Back
Top Bottom