There is no reason to expect that market value or any other amount make a difference at all. Its all just opinion on what is “just” compensation.
Well yeah it is “opinion”, what is just compensation. Based on sound reasoning, mastery of the English language, legal precedent, and such. That is why we have judges and SCOTUS.
To figure out the details of “just”, and “reasonable”, and other such legal metrics and standards. Because attempting to write a Constitution that enumerated everything single detail would not only take a metric buttload (official SI unit of measure!
) of text, it would also inevitable fail to cover something, not to mention within years break because something in the world (our knowledge and understanding of the world, commerce realities, etc.) would change and it would not make sense anymore. In the same vein it would also remove room for laws (and guidelines regulations, enacted by the Executive Branch under laws) to work within it in.
It short it would weaken the Constitution to the point of being unworkable.
Constitutions work best as light frameworks, with little meddling and relatively infrequent changes. Just take a look at the mess California has gotten itself into with its relatively numerous and frequent amendments, and that is small potatoes compared to the detail you seem to be expecting.
How is that even possible? The very interpretation doesn't hold up to it.
Of course it does hold up, which is why it has has long (AKA always) been understood in that manner.
You have some serious reading comprehension issues, coupled with what appears to be wishful thinking. I understand your desire for property rights in the vein of Jefferson’s voiced opinions,
but that did not happen. They are not in the US Constitution, they have never present in the US Constitutional law, and realistically speaking it is very unlikely they ever will. Certainly not in the near future.
So what you wish for is some different country, some different government structure. Which is fine, holding such a desire is entirely valid. Maybe it would even be a better country, at the very least from some people’s POV. *shrug* But all you will earn from deluding yourself into thinking that such is the case with the US Constitution, that it is
this country, is the label of ‘loon’. So I urge you to make that adjustment. Separate your wishes from reality and understand the distinction.
I say this with some self-interest, as that sort of thing has over the years significantly splashed over the perception onto “libertarian”.