• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Virginia prisoners go on hunger strike

TheDemSocialist

Gradualist
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 13, 2011
Messages
34,951
Reaction score
16,311
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Socialist
On May 22, close to 50 prisoners at Red Onion State Prison, in Wise County, Va., in at least two segregation pods, began a hunger strike protesting inhumane conditions and ongoing abuses by prison staff. For the men participating in the strike, this is their only recourse to get Red Onion warden, Randy Mathena, to officially recognize their grievances and make immediate changes to food, sanitation and basic living conditions at the prison. ROSP, built on a mountain 400 miles from Richmond, is considered the most isolated prison within the Virginia Department of Corrections.

1. We demand fully cooked food, and access to a better quality of fresh fruit and vegetables. In addition, we demand increased portions on our trays, which allow us to meet our basic nutritional needs as defined by VDOC regulations.2. We demand that every prisoner at ROSP have unrestricted access to complaint and grievance forms and other paperwork we may request.3. We demand better communication between prisoners and higher?ranking guards. Presently, higher?ranking guards invariably take the lower?ranking guards’ side in disputes between guards and prisoners, forcing the prisoner to act out in order to be heard. We demand that higher?ranking guards take prisoner complaints and grievances into consideration without prejudice.4. We demand an end to torture in the form of indefinite segregation through the implementation of a fair and transparent process whereby prisoners can earn the right to be released from segregation. We demand that prison officials completely adhere to the security point system, ensuring that prisoners are transferred to institutions that correspond with their particular security level.5. We demand the right to an adequate standard of living, including access to quality materials that we may use to clean our own cells. Presently, we are forced to clean our entire cell, including the inside of our toilets, with a single sponge and our bare hands. This is unsanitary and promotes the spread of disease?carrying bacteria.6. We demand the right to have third party neutral observers visit and document the condition of the prisons to ensure an end to the corruption amongst prison officials and widespread human rights abuses of prisoners. Internal Affairs and Prison Administrator's monitoring of prison conditions have not alleviated the dangerous circumstances we are living under while in custody of the state, which include, but are not limited to: the threat of undue physical aggression by guards, sexual abuse and retaliatory measures, which violate prison policies and our human rights.7. We demand to be informed of any and all changes to VDOC/IOP [Internal Operating Procedure] policies as soon as these changes are made.8. We demand the right to adequate medical care. Our right to medical care is guaranteed under the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution, and thus the deliberate indifference of prison officials to our medical needs constitutes a violation of our constitutional rights. In particular, the toothpaste we are forced to purchase in the prison is a danger to our dental health and causes widespread gum disease and associated illnesses.9. We demand our right as enumerated through VDOC policy, to a monthly haircut. Presently, we have been denied haircuts for nearly three months. We also demand to have our razors changed out on a weekly basis. The current practice of changing out the razors every three weeks leaves prisoners exposed to the risk of dangerous infections and injury.[FONT=ff-tisa-web-pro-1, ff-tisa-web-pro-2, Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif]10. We demand that there be no reprisals for any of the participants in the Hunger Strike. We are simply organizing in the interest of more humane living conditions.[/FONT]
[FONT=ff-tisa-web-pro-1, ff-tisa-web-pro-2, Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif]​
[/FONT]

[FONT=ff-tisa-web-pro-1, ff-tisa-web-pro-2, Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Read more @: [/FONT]Virginia prisoners go on hunger strike

[FONT=ff-tisa-web-pro-1, ff-tisa-web-pro-2, Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Intesting set of demands. I can get behind on this. If all of these things are true they defiantly deserve to be treated like human beings not some animals locked up in a cage. I certainly hope the whole prison industrial complex is not this low in quality and humanitarian standards. [/FONT]

[FONT=ff-tisa-web-pro-1, ff-tisa-web-pro-2, Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Thoughts?[/FONT]
[FONT=ff-tisa-web-pro-1, ff-tisa-web-pro-2, Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Comments?[/FONT]
[FONT=ff-tisa-web-pro-1, ff-tisa-web-pro-2, Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Response?e[/FONT]

 
sounds like they are doing their part to keep public sector costs down
Good for them
 
If all that is true, then yeah they're overdue for some reform at the Onion.
 
even prisoners have human rights.
True, but had those criminals recognized the rights of their victims they wouldnt be in prison in the first place.
 
True, but had those criminals recognized the rights of their victims they wouldnt be in prison in the first place.

Since they ****ed up and did a inhuman act we should take their human rights? Do 2 wrongs make a right in this instance?
 
True, but had those criminals recognized the rights of their victims they wouldnt be in prison in the first place.




Yeah, but think about it a minute...


There are tens of thousands of laws on the books... nobody knows them all, not even Scalia.

It can be a federal felony to bring certain plants and animals into the country, even if you had no idea they were proscrbed and meant no harm you could do 10 years in the pen for it.

You've probably committed a felony or two and didn't even know it. You can't depend on common sense anymore... IIRC taking and keeping Hawk feathers that you find on the ground is a felony, due to some Endangered Species legislation.

Seriously, there are things that could get you hard time that you wouldn't even believe are crimes.

Or, you could shoot some dude who was trying to kill you, and a bad eyewitness (or NO eyewitness, or an ill-considered word on your part) could see you doing time. It happens.

It's easy to dismiss things like this when you beleive your ox will never be gored, but don't be so sure everyone in prison deserves to be there.
 
Since they ****ed up and did a inhuman act we should take their human rights? Do 2 wrongs make a right in this instance?
If you notice the first word in my response was the word True. That was in response to the statement "that even prisoners have human rights." So I am not suggesting that prisoners have none. However, a prisoner, by his own actions, does surrender certain rights that you and I take for granted; the most obvious of which is individual liberty. They are in cages, after all. Imprisoning a man for actions that harm another is not an example of 2 wrongs somehow making a right. They are incarcerated as punishment for their behavior and to protect the rights of other members of society from their violent and criminal behavior. While they are there, they should not be subject to mistreatment or subhuman conditions--even if some of them have it coming.
 
If you notice the first word in my response was the word True. That was in response to the statement "that even prisoners have human rights." So I am not suggesting that prisoners have none. However, a prisoner, by his own actions, does surrender certain rights that you and I take for granted; the most obvious of which is individual liberty. They are in cages, after all. Imprisoning a man for actions that harm another is not an example of 2 wrongs somehow making a right. They are incarcerated as punishment for their behavior and to protect the rights of other members of society from their violent and criminal behavior. While they are there, they should not be subject to mistreatment or subhuman conditions--even if some of them have it coming.

Ok thanks for the clarification:)
 
The problem I have with prisons is that they have somehow become the one size fits all method of punishment. They are acceptable for people who significantly harm other people. They make little sense (to me) as a way to punish non-violent crimes.

Prisons are a growth industry, now large enough to lobby for more types of crimes and longer confinement. They take people who could certainly be rehabilitated productively and convert them to career criminals instead, thereby assuring repeat business.

There are some criminals I would enjoy being deprived of "human rights". Since that can't be done selectively, there should be higher standards for these Corporations that grow through societal misfortune.
 
Yeah, but think about it a minute...

There are tens of thousands of laws on the books... nobody knows them all, not even Scalia.

It can be a federal felony to bring certain plants and animals into the country, even if you had no idea they were proscrbed and meant no harm you could do 10 years in the pen for it.

You've probably committed a felony or two and didn't even know it. You can't depend on common sense anymore... IIRC taking and keeping Hawk feathers that you find on the ground is a felony, due to some Endangered Species legislation.

Seriously, there are things that could get you hard time that you wouldn't even believe are crimes.

Or, you could shoot some dude who was trying to kill you, and a bad eyewitness (or NO eyewitness, or an ill-considered word on your part) could see you doing time. It happens.

It's easy to dismiss things like this when you beleive your ox will never be gored, but don't be so sure everyone in prison deserves to be there.
Seriously, this. Anymore, just because someone is in prison does not automatically mean that they are an incorrigible threat to society.
 
So did their victims. Don't want the time? Don't do the crime.

Nobody is debating that part.

They were sentenced to time, they were not sentenced to malnourishment, maltreatment, etc. People don't seem to realize that. People are sentenced to time in prison, not being beaten up for their crime daily for the amount of time set by the judge.

If we treat our inmates like animals, then we can't be shocked when they act like them.
 
even prisoners have human rights.

True but when the fed spends more on death row inmates than the average American somethings wrong there wouldn't u say?
 
To put the Onion in perspective, it is the highest maximum security prison in Va. To qualify for membership, you have been determined unfit for imprisonment in any other Va prison. They are considered extremely dangerous.

No paper passers or multiple DUI's here.
 
The California equivalent of Pelican Bay? Yeah, not nice people but deliberate mistreatment doesn't seem very clever either.



To put the Onion in perspective, it is the highest maximum security prison in Va. To qualify for membership, you have been determined unfit for imprisonment in any other Va prison. They are considered extremely dangerous.

No paper passers or multiple DUI's here.
 
The California equivalent of Pelican Bay? Yeah, not nice people but deliberate mistreatment doesn't seem very clever either.

The prisoners say they were mistreated. I have not seen any report of evidence of such. The prisoners are not exactly people whose word I would take at face value
 
The prisoners say they were mistreated. I have not seen any report of evidence of such. The prisoners are not exactly people whose word I would take at face value

As if this means anything at all. Did you see any report about maltreatment of prisoners in Attica? What about prisoners striking in Georgia? NC? What makes your lack of information on the subject somehow worthy while 50 people deciding to peacefully assemble and demand SPECIFIC changes to their living conditions, unworthy? It's not like they're demanding some abstract change to their lives. They've got marked out issues and complaints which point out where they'd like to see a change.
 
Prison is supposed to be a deterring factor AGAINST crime. So I would expect the conditions to be harsh. Granted the stripping of human rights is a tad on the ****ed up side, but these prisoners are complaining because the guards are too mean? That their grievences aren't being heard? Well no ****, it's prison. It's supposed to suck ass. It's supposed to make you never commit crimes again.
 
Back
Top Bottom