• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Detroit High School Protest: Students Suspended After Demanding 'An Education' (edite

Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

OK. Here are excerpts from the article:

The Ford Foundation also sponsored the Grey Areas program in the early 1960s, which evolved into President Johnson’s “War on Poverty,” as a program for “urban renewal,” but was, in fact, concerned with issues arising out of poor people’s (and particularly poor people of colour’s) resistance to major urban growth projects undertaken by a coalition of corporations and corporatist labour unions following World War II. As Roger Friedland wrote:

Political challenge by the poor, and especially the nonwhite poor, threatened the dominance of the corporations and labor unions and the growth policies they pursued. It was the poorest neighborhoods which were displaced by urban renewal and highway construction, whose housing stock was depleted by clearance, whose employment opportunities were often reduced both by the expansion of office employment stimulated by central business district growth and by restrictive unionization on large construction projects and municipal jobs, and whose services were constrained by the enormous fiscal costs of the growth programs.[38]

It was in this context that the Ford Foundation established programs aimed at ameliorating the antagonisms within the impoverished communities, not through structural or systemic change of the causes of poverty, but through organization, institutionalization, and legalistic reform programs, thus leading to the government’s “War on Poverty.” The same approach was taken in regards to the Civil Rights movement.

The major foundations “supported the moderate civil rights organizations in response to the ‘radical flank’ threat of the militants, while non-elites (churches, unions and small individual donors) spread their support evenly.”[40]

Elite patronage of the Civil Rights movement “diverted leaders from indigenous organizing and exacerbated inter-organizational rivalries, thereby promoting movement decay.”[41] Foundation funding for civil rights did not become significant until 1961-62, five years after the Birmingham bus boycott, and the peak of foundation support for civil rights was in 1972-73, four to five years after the assassination of King.[42] This indicated that foundation grants to civil rights were ‘reactive’, in that they were designed in response to changes in the movement itself, implying that foundation patronage was aimed at social control. [...] Many of the foundations subsequently became “centrally involved in the formulation of national social policy and responded to elite concerns about the riots.”[44]



For clarification purposes, I am mentioning slavery in a historical context for in order for us to effectively aid the black community, we must first understand why the black community is the way it is today, which would require a historical look of black people over time in terms of politics, economics, and culture.


In terms of the War on Drugs:

As reported in the journal, Punishment & Society:

The impact of these developments has fallen disproportionately on young African-Americans and Latinos. By 1994, one of every three black males between the ages of 18-34 was under some form of correctional supervision, and the number of Hispanic prisoners has more than quintupled since 1980. These developments are not primarily the consequence of rising crime rates, but rather the ‘get-tough’ policies of the wars on crime and drugs.[60]

[...]

Just as took place during the criminalization of black life following the Civil War, the criminalization of black life following the Civil Rights Movement saw not only the growth of incarceration rates for the black community, but also saw the growth of the use of the prison population as a source of cheap labour. In today’s context, with privatization of prisons, outsourcing of prison labour, and other forms of exploitation of the “punished” population, this has given rise to what is often referred to as the “prison-industrial complex.”[63]​


I'm trying to understand. I really am. I'm having a really hard time, though.

Basically, from what I read, this is the gist of it. First, the Civil Rights movement and War on Poverty were a case of corporations and elitists giving money to the moderate leaders and sects they approved of in order to ensure that those people were kept in power. Basically, what the author is saying, is that some movement leaders sold out for money. Its funny that people are always accused of selling out when they take money when without the money they would never make it to begin with. Also, why would anyone want to give money to a radical? Lets use the best example in this case. Malcolm X vs Martin Luther King. One was a radical Islamist who preached hatred and the other was a Christian minister who preached peace. Who do you think "elitists" (in other words people with money) and corporations would want to give money to? Who would you give money to? I know Malcolm X wouldn't have gotten a dime of my money because he hated me to begin with. At least MLK made it known that he just wanted equal rights, not special ones. Second, I love the way the author portrays the War on Drugs as some kind of race hunting spree that targeted blacks. Sorry bud, but you don't roll through white suburbia and see white kids on the corner dealing drugs. You see that in the black inner city. That's just facts. In addition, and this is my favorite part, is the way he portrays it as black people just minding their own business, you know, just selling some heroin and BOOM! Johnny Law comes around the corner and makes a victim of him. How dare the law enforcement officers actually ENFORCE the law instead of turning a blind eye. This guy is actually implying that its not the black drug dealers fault that he got caught BREAKING THE LAW but the cops fault for ENFORCING THE LAW. You can't make this stuff up. The fact of the matter is this. Cops don't go looking for drugs where there are no drugs. I'm not saying white people don't use drugs. They certainly do. But like I said, you don't roll through white suburbia and see drugs being dealt. You see that in black inner cities. Just like in the country. You don't see cops looking through nice, two story houses for meth labs. You see them looking through run down trailers that have tin foil over the windows. Imagine if cops came around frisking middle class families, of any color, while they were talking a walk down their nice sidewalk in Anytown, USA. We'd be up in arms. Headlines would read "Off target cops frisk mom of 3 while on walk". We would wonder what our law enforement was doing harrassing obviously innocent people. But, that's what the author insinuates should happen. We should either A) Target all citizens as possible drug dealers, pimps, and thieves or B) Just let the aforementioned criminals have at it because we don't want to seem racist. Again, you can't make this stuff up.
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

Actually, now that you've made me think about it in that way, you're right.

What IF Sharpton and Jackson tackled one American city? Detroit? Chicago? New York? And made a stand. This was last week:



Why not? No, I mean, really. Why don't they do this??

Do they not care? Does it not serve their best interests to get this black-on-black violence under control? What?

It serves their best interest to keep stirring the pot. If these two men didn't keep **** stirred up, they would slip into obscurity. Iow, they need instability among the black community to keep themselves in the limelight.
 
I'm trying to understand. I really am. I'm having a really hard time, though.

Institutional racism has lead to higher rates of imprisonment and "they can't do it without us" type of poverty directed social welfare programs (which don't help). Case in point urban renewal projects that didn't use the community to build new homes, crack having harsher punishment, welfare designed to keep people on the government's dole ect.

I'll make another post when I'm not pressed for time about the problems facing intercity education

The difference between a democrat and a republican is who owes the favor, the politican or the business
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

"Thread: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff"

Nice to see you play the race card right there in the title.

So, is it safe to assume you think blacks should stick to protesting black issues and whites should protest white ones?

Racially divide much?

Made you look though didn't it?
 
Ok so here are some brief examples of the problems faced by the education system

1) regulations, often enacted under union contracts, prevents some teachers from going the extra mile in some states while excusing others not going the extra mile. The initial reason for these rules, such as guaranteed breaks and being allowed to leave right when school is let out,.was to prevent principals and the system from over working their staff (which happened).
2) the tenure system. This does not mean a job for life! it is simply due process to prevent political firings (it doesn't for teachers who haven't meet the tenure threshold). However, it does make it harder to fire bad teachers or teachers that have given up
3) disruptive students making up the majority of a lot of classes not being kicked out. This is the main reason why teachers give up.
4) stagnant teaching methods due to improper handling of budgets and the generational gap. Most education budgets are exhausted on redundant administrative functions and many teachers are older who have not leaned how to teach in a way that keeps the techno generation engaged.


The difference between a democrat and a republican is who owes the favor, the politican or the business
 
Last edited:
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

Black-on-Black homocide doesn't give him enough facetime.
I believe the correct term is 'genocide'...
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

Give us all a break, huh?

Sometimes I think you all have been on break way too long.

MarineTPartier= spending the kids education money on useless wars, all the while slashing as many public programs at home as humanly possible.


Yep, I see a whole lot of love for these kids, its all right there in the name.
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

Sometimes I think you all have been on break way too long.

MarineTPartier= spending the kids education money on useless wars, all the while slashing as many public programs at home as humanly possible.


Yep, I see a whole lot of love for these kids, its all right there in the name.

Yeah, because I'm in charge of appropriations for the entire US Gov't including the DOD and Department of Education.:lamo Get a friggin clue bud. Write your Congressman if you don't like how the gov't spends money.
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

Sorry bud, but you don't roll through white suburbia and see white kids on the corner dealing drugs. You see that in the black inner city. That's just facts.

I've witnessed a white kid dealing drugs in white suburbia. I've encountered several other white drug dealers in my profession as well. Far be it from me to defend liberals on anything, but on the drug issue, I mostly agree with them. People of all races and backgrounds deal and use drugs. The numbers seem heavily tilted toward blacks because police tend to enforce drug laws in black communities moreso than in white ones. It could very well be that there are more black drug dealers than white drug dealers. I don't know. My point is only that unequal enforcement affects our perception. The actual split is probably not as extreme as the comparative rates of incarceration. White offenders are definitely shown more latitude than black ones, although I think that might have more to do with economic class than race.
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

The African American experience is exceptional in the fact that American society as a whole has been unable to properly incorporate them. Keep in mind that, again, much in the way of social progress did not start until the 1960s and continues to evolve today. For a variety of reasons, the experience is just exceptional. Sociologists have still found Africans immigrating to America have a better experience.

You just stated one of the reasons for such disparity, the "African American" instead of just American. Any grouping that sets itself apart is going to experience racism/sexism/etc because the very act of setting themselves apart creates animosity and tension. When you start focusing on providing services such as education based upon these artificial breakdowns of society instead of society as an homogeous whole then you break the system. Any group that hyphenates their American status needs to assimilate into the existing whole, not exist seperately.

I cannot say for the whole country, but in the local area, there are way to many blacks that seem to relish their poverty instead of working towards ending it. I don't know how many times I have overheard blacks refering to educated, successful blacks (outside of entertainment and sports) as "acting white" or "uppity N....." because they talk and sound educated and dress like other members of society instead of talking in the eubonic slang (or whatever name it goes by now) and wearing FUBU. Until the black communities break that kind of attitude and don't pass it on to students and the community as a whole, there is going to continue to be a disparity.

Urban schools that are mostly black or hispanic do face economic challenges due to the tax base they must work from. However, a much larger problem for schools in these economically depressed areas is disruptive influences. Gangs, drugs and disruptive students exist in all schools, but they do exist at higher per capita in these poorer school districts. These communities need to work to end or reduce these problems.

Marine mentioned DOD schools being better than public ones in the US. This is not an anomaly, it is due to the type of community in which they exist. These schools only exist in military communities. Military members, as a whole, value education, understand and accept higher standards of discipline, and demonstrate a much higher work ethic than is found in most American societies. They set a much better example for their children. Also, these schools exist in communities with much lower per capita rate of diruptive influences and have a greater ability to deal with disruptive students.
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

Marine mentioned DOD schools being better than public ones in the US. This is not an anomaly, it is due to the type of community in which they exist. These schools only exist in military communities. Military members, as a whole, value education, understand and accept higher standards of discipline, and demonstrate a much higher work ethic than is found in most American societies. They set a much better example for their children. Also, these schools exist in communities with much lower per capita rate of diruptive influences and have a greater ability to deal with disruptive students.

Amen to that....the military community has its own culture. After years of not living near a military base, we moved close to Luke AFB and started using the commissary. Just driving thru the gate is like entering a different world, a cleaner one, where people are more courteous, law abiding, cooperative, etc.
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

You just stated one of the reasons for such disparity, the "African American" instead of just American. Any grouping that sets itself apart is going to experience racism/sexism/etc because the very act of setting themselves apart creates animosity and tension. When you start focusing on providing services such as education based upon these artificial breakdowns of society instead of society as an homogeous whole then you break the system. Any group that hyphenates their American status needs to assimilate into the existing whole, not exist seperately.

That would somewhat remain true if it was an intentional breaking away or refusal to be incorporated, however, the evolution of the group label was occurring at the same time that they were being de jure and/or de facto differentiated in the United States.
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

State Approves Detroit Schools' Cuts -
22 Feb 2011 – The state of Michigan approved a plan for Detroit to close about half of its public schools and increase the average size of high-school ...

Detroit Public Schools Budget: Cuts, Cuts, Cuts
23 Jun 2011 – This story has been updated. Detroit Public Schools officials released the district's proposed 2012 budget Thursday, a plan rife with cuts and ...

Emergency Decree Cuts Wages for Detroit School Workers | Labor ...
2 Aug 2011 – Roberts, a retired GM executive appointed in May, says the Detroit school cuts will save $82 million, out of a deficit of $327 million.

Detroit school teachers to take 10 percent wage cut |
29 Jul 2011 – DETROIT (Reuters) - Detroit public school teachers will take a 10 percent wage cut and pay more for health care in what the school system's ...

Michigan approves plan to close half of Detroit schools - Feb. 22, 2011
22 Feb 2011 – The plan calls for the closure of 70 schools, which would cut the number of ... He said student enrollment in Detroit Public School's has been ...

Detroit Public Schools Face 'Draconian' Cuts
3 Mar 2011 – A state official's plan closes half the city's schools and dramatically increases class sizes in order to eliminate the school district's $327 million ...


Detroit Public School Teachers Protest School Cuts
16 Aug 2011 – About 400 teachers and employees from Detroit Public Schools gathered outside of the Detroit Federation of Teachers Tuesday to protest...

Pro-Life Hypocrisy: School Budget Cuts In Detroit - YouTube
Republicans in Detroit want to cut funding for a highly successful high school that caters to pregnant ...


Emergency manager cuts endanger Detroit schools » peoplesworld
17 Aug 2011 – DETROIT - Ten thousand Detroit Public Schools teachers and support staff are quickly finding out how undemocratic Michigan's emergency ...


Detroit Public Schools announces 10 percent pay cuts, massive layoffs
25 Jun 2011 – The cuts demanded by Emergency Financial Manager Roy Roberts are part of a broader dismantling of the public education system in Detroit.


CONTRACT BROKEN: Detroit School Emergency Mgr cuts all union ...
29 Jul 2011 – Unionized school employees in Detroit were dealt another blow today as Emergency Manager Roy Roberts wiped away their union contract ...

Detroit Public Schools to Cut 1500 Teachers Despite Lower Student ...
20 Sep 2011 – From Yahoo! News: Detroit Public Schools plans to cut 40 percent of its current teaching staff by fall 2015. Deep staffing cuts are part of a ...


Daily Kos: Detroit schools emergency financial manager imposes ...
29 Jul 2011 – One month after warning union workers that they would see a 10% wage cut next school year, Roy Roberts, the emergency manager for Detroit ...

[http://www.google.ca/search?sourcei...AW_enCA445CA373&q=detroit+school+cuts[/quote]
Given the never ending cuts to public education in Detroit, what makes the critics think there are any teachers left in the schools?
 
Last edited:
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

While the Trayvon Martin shooting was certainly tragic, and I do think Zimmerman should be charged...theres LOTS for the Sharptons of the world to get involved with. Blacks in America are getting slaughtered daily. There should be marches, demonstrations...protests across the country. Something should be done.

FBI- 2010
White on White murders 2,777
White on Black murders came to 218;
Black on White murders came to 447, while
Black on Black murders came to 2,459.

Tragic. Truly.

FBI — Expanded Homicide Data Table 6

This should be added to your post....

■Single victim/single offender situations accounted for 48.4 percent of all murders for which the UCR Program received supplemental data. (See Expanded Homicide Data Table 4.)

Expanded Homicide Data
 
Re: What blacks should be protesting: Detroit high students revolt against staff

[/url]
Given the never ending cuts to public education in Detroit, what makes the critics think there are any teachers left in the schools?

If there wasn't any teachers left in the schools then there would be no open schools.
 
Back
Top Bottom