• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

U.S. Marines Urinate On Dead Bodies In Afghanistan

Yes what did England do? She took a picture with a guy with a bag on his head or some guys in a pile. They pissed on a corpes. They in fact did the exact same thing. They should get what she got.


savages dead vs savages alive.

Your hatred of the us military from your couch is noted.


Unless guys deserve more sympathy than girls.


the Good Reverend loves the ladies, it's mutual I assure you.


Again trying to describe the ocean to one who has not seen it. :shrug:
 
Kenvin

I can see why you ignored my two posts... things like context, legality of killing in war, raping a live person versus peeing on a dead body and no culture raping dead bodies kind shot you down in a fire ball of flames...
 
Last edited:
I love it...

Terrorists blow up the twin towers. Many liberals: "We need to understand what motivated them to do this and understand how their situation contributed, not just blame them"

Soldiers pissed on dead enemies. Many Liberals: "Punish them to the full extent of the law and boot them out, who gives a **** about the situation they're in, the mindset instilled in them, or the type of things that could motivate them to take such action"

Reason behind terrorist actions...important. Reasons behind our soldiers actions...unimportant. Wonderful.
 
I love it...

Terrorists blow up the twin towers. Many liberals: "We need to understand what motivated them to do this and understand how their situation contributed, not just blame them"

Soldiers pissed on dead enemies. Many Liberals: "Punish them to the full extent of the law and boot them out, who gives a **** about the situation they're in, the mindset instilled in them, or the type of things that could motivate them to take such action"

Reason behind terrorist actions...important. Reasons behind our soldiers actions...unimportant. Wonderful.

Will you just stop being rational!!
 
Kenvin

I can see why you ignored my two posts... things like context, legality of killing in war, raping a live person versus peeing on a dead body and no culture raping dead bodies kind shot you down in a fire ball of flames...

Whatever go pee on a corpse if you think its ok
 
savages dead vs savages alive.

Your hatred of the us military from your couch is noted.





the Good Reverend loves the ladies, it's mutual I assure you.


Again trying to describe the ocean to one who has not seen it. :shrug:

She got kicked out so should they.
 
I love it...

Terrorists blow up the twin towers. Many liberals: "We need to understand what motivated them to do this and understand how their situation contributed, not just blame them"

Soldiers pissed on dead enemies. Many Liberals: "Punish them to the full extent of the law and boot them out, who gives a **** about the situation they're in, the mindset instilled in them, or the type of things that could motivate them to take such action"

Reason behind terrorist actions...important. Reasons behind our soldiers actions...unimportant. Wonderful.

Hey no need to put them in jail just kick them out and move on.
 
She got kicked out so should they.

Is that what happens in cod4 on your wii?


A dishonorable discharge ruins ones life. They did what you are unwilling to do, they made a mistake, i for one dont think thier lives should be ruined over it.
 
Is that what happens in cod4 on your wii?


A dishonorable discharge ruins ones life. They did what you are unwilling to do, they made a mistake, i for one dont think thier lives should be ruined over it.

They should get what England got as they committed essentially the same offence. Their lives won't be ruined. Also, the oops it was a mistake doesn't really work as a defence. Ask anyone who got a dui and said that to the judge.
 
Last edited:
Whatever go pee on a corpse if you think its ok

This is a "debate site"... not a "whining because you are unable to debate site"... Either debate the content and perspective of the post or admit that you are unable to and that you lost the point. I think you need to either start debating or go to a site that encourages whining.
 
Last edited:
I love it...

Terrorists blow up the twin towers. Many liberals: "We need to understand what motivated them to do this and understand how their situation contributed, not just blame them"

Soldiers pissed on dead enemies. Many Liberals: "Punish them to the full extent of the law and boot them out, who gives a **** about the situation they're in, the mindset instilled in them, or the type of things that could motivate them to take such action"

Reason behind terrorist actions...important. Reasons behind our soldiers actions...unimportant. Wonderful.

So you can show that the same people that said "we need to understand terrorists" are the exact same people that also said "we should punish the soldiers to the full extent of the law"?

Not all liberals are the same just like not all conservatives are the same. Nice intellectual dishonesty there though. Just saying.
 
This is a "debate site"... not a "whining because you are unable to debate site"... Either debate the content and perspective of the post or admit that you are unable to and that you lost the point. I think you need to either start debating or go to a site that encourages whining.


So you're whining about his whining? Wow lol
 
So you can show that the same people that said "we need to understand terrorists" are the exact same people that also said "we should punish the soldiers to the full extent of the law"?

Not all liberals are the same just like not all conservatives are the same. Nice intellectual dishonesty there though. Just saying.

Having talked with many I have yet to hear one conservative ever mention understanding the hardship of the terrorist and the oppressive and invasive policies of the United States that justifies the terrorists fighting back and I have heard MANY liberals argue just that. I think that Zyphlins statement is spot-****ing-on.
 
So you're whining about his whining? Wow lol

Not really... encouraging or bashing. Neither would constitute whining... that is, unless you are whining about me whining about his whining.
 
This is a "debate site"... not a "whining because you are unable to debate site"... Either debate the content and perspective of the post or admit that you are unable to and that you lost the point. I think you need to either start debating or go to a site that encourages whining.

Exactly stop whining. Their act should be punished under the military rules Just like Lyndsy England was. I want them judged faily, but they must face consequences. Her consequenses were to be kicked out. I would think the same rules should apply to these men.
 
Their act should be punished under the military rules Just like Lyndsy England was. I want them judged faily, but they must face consequences. Her consequenses were to be kicked out. I would think the same rules should apply to these men.

What military law discusses peeing on a dead enemy combatant?
 
What military law discusses peeing on a dead enemy combatant?

Well depends on how they want to do this. They can use the general conduct unbecoming or they can be specific in "public exposure". Either way the Marine Corps has even denounced this act as wrong. Not sure why you are arguing it's illegality.
 
Having talked with many I have yet to hear one conservative ever mention understanding the hardship of the terrorist and the oppressive and invasive policies of the United States that justifies the terrorists fighting back and I have heard MANY liberals argue just that. I think that Zyphlins statement is spot-****ing-on.


Again, you need to actually read what I typed.

Show me where the majority of liberals said that we need to "We need to wait to find out what was wrong with the terrorists in 9/11" AND are denouncing the Marines quickly. Go ahead.
 
Platoon commander among Marines who urinated on corpses, officials say


One of the Marines shown urinating on three corpses in Afghanistan in a widely distributed Internet video was the unit's platoon commander, two U.S. military officials have told McClatchy, raising concerns that poor command standards contributed to an incident that may have damaged the U.S. war effort.

Even before the unit deployed to southern Afghanistan last year, it suffered from disciplinary problems while the troops were based at Camp Lejeune, N.C., the officials said.

As Pentagon officials investigate the incident _ the latest in a string of high-profile cases of U.S. troops abusing Afghans and Iraqis on the battlefield _ the revelations renew questions about whether the U.S. military will hold commanders responsible when their troops misbehave or commit crimes.

Despite U.S. military doctrine stating that commanders ultimately are responsible for their units' behavior in combat _ and Geneva conventions barring the desecration of dead bodies _ the Pentagon rarely has charged commanders in cases where troops have knowingly killed, injured or mistreated Afghans and Iraqis. Instead, lower-ranking troops or those directly responsible for crimes have been charged while commanders have only faced administrative penalties, like dismissal or demotion.

Experts say that the U.S. military hasn't made the treatment of locals on the battlefield a priority for commanders. However, the military in Afghanistan has found that coalition troops' behavior toward Afghans, including such acts as urinating in front of them, is a contributor to what one U.S. report last year called "a crisis of trust and cultural incompatibility" that has sometimes led to Afghan soldiers turning their weapons on their coalition partners."

Platoon commander among Marines who urinated on corpses, officials say | pennlive.com
 
I swear to God.

Just because America lost the battle for the global economy, the government thinks they have the right to bomb their way back to supremacy?

Who gave them that right?

This is an odd statement.

What are you talking about?

What do you think I am talking about?
 
Back
Top Bottom