• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

U.S. Marines Urinate On Dead Bodies In Afghanistan

I find calling folks on the internet, a very ironic act....... That said. I don't see pissing on the dead as "desecration" in the same light as say hanging bodies from a bridge....

Wow, you keep sinking lower and lower.

If the taliban pissed on U.S. dead soldiers, would you say that?
 
Wow, you keep sinking lower and lower.

If the taliban pissed on U.S. dead soldiers, would you say that?



I would expect to feel how the taliban feels, pissed off. I've seen enemies do worse. It's war. We kill and break things until they lose thier will.


Tell me, what should happen to these Marines?
 
Last edited:
I'm not going to do your homework for you. Can't understand properly constructed sentences? Not my problem.

Communication is a two-way street. It doesn't matter whose fault it is when there's a misunderstanding - it's not unreasonable to ask for clarification. If you won't give it, I will go by what I read in the first place. Which means I proved you wrong. If you don't think so, you'll have to explain why.

I agree, Misterman.

Then stop spewing it.
 
Is that wrong or is it okay?

If it's wrong, it was wrong to piss on them.

If it's okay, then it's okay when they piss on our soldiers or burn them and hang them from bridges.

Which is it?

once you're dead it really shouldn't matter. be upset that they killed me, not that they pissed on me afterwards
 
I would expect to feel how the taliban feels, pissed off.

I asked you if you would say it wasn't desecration in the same way burning bodies is. That was may question. Can you answer it?

Oh, and you still haven't answered my other question - is desecration wrong, or okay?
 
once you're dead it really shouldn't matter. be upset that they killed me, not that they pissed on me afterwards

So you're okay with your dead body being pissed on. Noted for future use if opportunity arises. Be sure to inform your next of kin not to get upset.

:roll:

Also, if it ever happens to a dead U.S. soldier, tell his family what you just told me. I dare you.
 
I asked you if you would say it wasn't desecration in the same way burning bodies is. That was may question. Can you answer it?

Oh, and you still haven't answered my other question - is desecration wrong, or okay?



I don't do "pidgeonholing" if my answer is not acceptable to you, not my problem....



Tell me, Tell me, what should happen to these Marines?
 
So you're okay with your dead body being pissed on. Noted for future use if opportunity arises. Be sure to inform your next of kin not to get upset.

:roll:

Also, if it ever happens to a dead U.S. soldier, tell his family what you just told me. I dare you.

I dare you.... :lamo at the interwebz toughguy.

those of us who have seen war have a very different opinion than those of you who sit back and complain about it from the safety of your own home.
 
I don't do "pidgeonholing" if my answer is not acceptable to you, not my problem....

Coward.

Tell me, Tell me, what should happen to these Marines?

Prosecuted for violating whatever laws they broke in the international laws of war the U.S. Uniform Code of Military Justice. Duh.
 
I dare you.... :lamo at the interwebz toughguy.

You said you wouldn't care. Why so angry now?

those of us who have seen war have a very different opinion than those of you who sit back and complain about it from the safety of your own home.

That crap doesn't work on me.
 

Do you think you even could stand in the shadow of the Greatness that is the Good Reverend? When he tell's knock knock jokes, people answer the door! :pimpdaddy:


Prosecuted for violating whatever laws they broke in the international laws of war the U.S. Uniform Code of Military Justice. Duh.


Article 15?

Court martial?

Dishonorable discharge?

Jail time? If so how long?
 
Last edited:
Tell me, Tell me, what should happen to these Marines?

Our military officials have no real choice other than to do a proper investigation and - if evidence warrants it - to then prosecute the individuals involved. There really is no other alternative now that this video has gone viral.

I will not prejudge the results nor pass sentence.
 
Article 15?

Court martial?

Dishonorable discharge?

Jail time? If so how long?

I'm not the judge.

I've told you what I think - can't you tell me what you think should happen? Come on, answer the question - how should peeing on the dead enemy be handled?
 
you appear to be the one who is angry. I am laughing at you

Sure you are.

you would have to understand it for it to work on you.

That crap doesn't work on me either.

I know it's hard to face the fact that someone on your side did something wrong. But an adult can handle it. You simply say it was wrong, and move on.
 
Article 15. fine them 1/2 of one month's pay and give them 30 days additional duty. both actions suspended

So if the Taliban piss on our dead, the Afghanis can give them the same sentence and its over. Right?
 
I dare you.... :lamo at the interwebz toughguy.

those of us who have seen war have a very different opinion than those of you who sit back and complain about it from the safety of your own home.
Not really, several veterans have agreed with non-vets on both sides of the argument.
 
I'm not the judge.

I've told you what I think - can't you tell me what you think should happen? Come on, answer the question - how should peeing on the dead enemy be handled?

they should be punished for being dumb enough to video it, not for the act of pissing on dead terrorists
 
Our military officials have no real choice other than to do a proper investigation and - if evidence warrants it - to then prosecute the individuals involved. There really is no other alternative now that this video has gone viral.

I will not prejudge the results nor pass sentence.




I think they are ****ed. The last thing you want to do in country, is attract this sort of attention. They are going to get it alot worse than they deserve, imo, and that's regrettable. They did an immature thing, and it will cost them for the rest of thier lives.
 
I've told you what I think - can't you tell me what you think should happen? Come on, answer the question - how should peeing on the dead enemy be handled?

Had the video not been posted up, it should have been handled by their next-ranking commanding officer. "Knock it off!!" Now that it's on the internet? Well, as Haymarket says, we've no choice but to handle it through formal military justice. Too bad.
 
they should be punished for being dumb enough to video it, not for the act of pissing on dead terrorists

Yes, we already know that you approve of pissing on the dead, including U.S. soldiers. If video of that ever surfaces, destroy it immediately.
 
I'm not the judge.

I've told you what I think - can't you tell me what you think should happen? Come on, answer the question - how should peeing on the dead enemy be handled?



Article 15, reduction in rank.


You can cop out of saying what you think they deserve that's your perrogative. I have no problem suggesting what I think they deserve.
 
Yes, we already know that you approve of pissing on the dead, including U.S. soldiers. If video of that ever surfaces, destroy it immediately.

are you really that stupid? (rhetorical) not wetting myself and wringing my hands over it =/= approval. but, hey, thanks for playing
 
Back
Top Bottom