• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Schools may ban chocolate milk over added sugar

I don't know, I'm not hugely upset at the schools banning chocolate milk. It's a bit excessive and we probably should be doing more to make sure kids are getting physical activity. But we have a bunch of fatties now and it's a concern now and this isn't the worst of all things.

Kids are not fat because of chocolate milk. I drank chocolate milk as a kid (still do in fact -- many endurance athletes make chocolate milk a part of their diet) and am not fat. The kids need more veggies, but they also need more exercise... get the kids out and running around, playing basketball, or whatever... educate them to make healthy food choices... chocolate milk can very definately be part of a healthy diet...
 
As someone who had to rely on nutrition for performance I know what you are saying, but it isn't government's job to do this. I also broke the rules too... big time because it suited me and my performance better.

The best diet would be Atkins; but that ain't gonna happen any time soon. It is diametrically opposed to the Government Food Pyramid and the brainwashing the low fat craze they fomented..

The Atkins diet is actually rather controversial. It is not "proven" and for some people, especially endurance athletes, it would be rather foolish to follow that diet.

Why blame the "food pyramid"? Yes, it isn't ideal, but is that TRULY the cause of obesity? Look at the junk food people eat and the lack of physical activity. Are either of those within the government recommendations? No, they aren't. The "food pyramid" does not call for five servings of cookies/potato chips/Doritos a day.
 
They snack before school, and I don't know this for sure but my bet is the mother too lazy to make breakfast. Just send the kids off to the government and let someone else take responsibility for her responsibility.

This entitlement crap is disgusting and sends a bad message. In this piece you have three generations wrapped up in the entitlement poison. Great Aunt, Mother and kids. (puke icon).

.

Agreed... rediculous... I always had breakfast at home before going to school and we typically prepare breakfast at home before the girls go to school... occasionally, we eat at one of the local breakfast shops together, but only occasionally...
 
Kids are not fat because of chocolate milk. I drank chocolate milk as a kid (still do in fact -- many endurance athletes make chocolate milk a part of their diet) and am not fat. The kids need more veggies, but they also need more exercise... get the kids out and running around, playing basketball, or whatever... educate them to make healthy food choices... chocolate milk can very definately be part of a healthy diet...

As a kid I couldn't stand salad, was no fan of vegetables, wasn't a big fan of spuds, enjoyed meat and eggs, cheese was putrid, cereal with milk was the standard breakfast, drank a fair bit of milk and this didn't change a whole lot until I was in my mid-late 20's (except the milk; I stopped drinking it at about 18... except for milkshakes). At 20 I had a physical and the doc said with my cholesterol level I'd live to be 200; I was anything but fat.

I was an active kid, and eating breakfast was a slog... regardless of what it was.

As for the Food Pyramid... here's an article about it:

With obesity reaching epidemic proportions in the U.S., some critics say it's the government's food pyramid that should go on a diet.

The pyramid, dating from 1991, pictorially reflects the U.S. Department of Agriculture's guidelines ...

While the government has stood by this regimen for 11 years, some critics say it's no coincidence that the number of overweight Americans has risen 61% since the pyramid was introduced -- and almost instantaneously appeared on the sides of pasta boxes, bread wrappers and packages of other food products in the pyramid's six-to-11-servings category.

David S. Ludwig, an obesity researcher at Children's Hospital in Boston, says the pyramid and guidelines focus too much on reducing fat. He says people are getting fat because they are eating too many refined carbohydrates, such as those in white bread, that make them feel hungrier later so they overeat.


Among the most vocal of the pyramid's critics is Walter Willett, chairman of the Harvard School for Public Health's nutrition department. "The pyramid really ignored 40 years of data and condemned all fats and oils," he says. While the pyramid indicates that only fat calories count, Dr. Willet says, "calories are calories."

He and other critics say the government's focus on reducing calories from fat has helped propel sales of low-fat foods that still pack a lot of calories -- ..."That probably has contributed to the explosion in obesity," ...The trial is funded by the Robert C. Atkins Foundation, which advocates the Atkins low-carbohydrate diet.

And then there is exercise.

The Government's Food Pyramid Correlates to Obesity, Critics Say

A researcher at U Penn did a study about Atkins and cholesterol and thought... this will be the first and last, as he expected a huge increase. Wrong. he was blown away.

In Denmark they set up a trial and the people went to a special store where they received and monitored everything; all Atkins related. Their blood profiles improved.

It's simple and I notice it. If I eat a breakfast of eggs, ham, toast (not Atkins but I like toast with B & E) I am full the entire day up to late afternoon, early evening, and I don't tire. I don't follow Atkins as a religion, as I don't have a weight problem, BUT I found it interesting and applied it and his recommendations do suppress appetite. If I ever feel like I've got a couple pounds too many I knock off the beer, get outside a little more and in a 4 to 6 weeks I've lost the weight.. if not sooner.

.
 
Last edited:
"Banning!" is emotive hyperbole. In an age of rising childhood obesity, schools are declining to comply with overfeeding those in their care, and contributing to the problem.
 
Kids are getting fat at home...and the govt cant control that. Im not against the schools removing unhealthy food but its simplistic to believe its going to make any kind of impact on obesity. The biggest contributor to child obesity is Computers and computer games and Iphones...thats kids entertainment instead of hide and go seek and johnnylumplump and football. Want to really make an impact...get rid of cell phones and and get them off the computer.
 
Kids are getting fat at home...and the govt cant control that. Im not against the schools removing unhealthy food but its simplistic to believe its going to make any kind of impact on obesity. The biggest contributor to child obesity is Computers and computer games and Iphones...thats kids entertainment instead of hide and go seek and johnnylumplump and football. Want to really make an impact...get rid of cell phones and and get them off the computer.

Kids spend the majority of their awake day at school, however - and many (who have to ride an early bus) eat 2 meals there, not just one. My kids get up at 6:30 - off to school at 7:00 - 7:30 . . . gone for 8 - 8 1/2 hours - come home at 3:30 - 4:00 and bedtime is at 8:00 which is 3 1/2 or 4 hours after coming home.

Mine, though, eat breakfast, dinner and snack at home - lunch is the only thing consumed at school.

We're also fortunate enough to be in a school district that believes in healthy food options: they get fruit for a mid-afternoon snack at school and have options of fresh fruits/veggies (like the salad bar) at school - something that's missing from the majority of schools around the country.

Our younger 2 have recess during the afternoon - on Friday they have PE

Our oldest son is in Track - that's his only physical activity at school

Our 2nd son is in 5th grade - no physical-education classes at all right now.

I agree, however, that home plays a huge role: Have you seen a kid's football team lately? Several hours of intense physical activity every week - but a lot of those kids are overweight. So, yes, of course home-life and pre-school years play a role into further enabling unhealthy habits all around. A lot of kids come to pre-K already overweight. . . something that will never change throughout their life until they're adult and take control of their health, if they ever care.
When my 2nd son was on a tiger-cub football team there were two kids on the team who weighed more than me and would eat a Big-Mac meal before every practice session - that's over 1,000 calories right there.
 
It's simple and I notice it. If I eat a breakfast of eggs, ham, toast (not Atkins but I like toast with B & E) I am full the entire day up to late afternoon, early evening, and I don't tire. I don't follow Atkins as a religion, as I don't have a weight problem, BUT I found it interesting and applied it and his recommendations do suppress appetite. If I ever feel like I've got a couple pounds too many I knock off the beer, get outside a little more and in a 4 to 6 weeks I've lost the weight.. if not sooner.

.

I will not go by the Atkins diet. No need for me to. Like you, I go pretty big on breakfast. High on protein (meat, milk, eggs) and I spread my fruit intake throughout the day. Many people make the mistake of a fruit-heavy breakfast which causes them to feel hungry again by 10AM. Like you, I don't feel hungry until lunch time, regardless of how hard my morning workouts are.

I am sure Atkins helps some people, but to consider it a cure all for everyone is not really a good idea. Everyone is different and has different needs. I need a high protein and high carb diet (high carbs especially before races) because of the sports I participate in. But again, we all are different.

I still submit that the primary (not only) reason is the increased consumption of empty calories and junk foods along with reduced exercise.
 
I will not go by the Atkins diet. No need for me to. Like you, I go pretty big on breakfast. High on protein (meat, milk, eggs) and I spread my fruit intake throughout the day. Many people make the mistake of a fruit-heavy breakfast which causes them to feel hungry again by 10AM. Like you, I don't feel hungry until lunch time, regardless of how hard my morning workouts are.

I am sure Atkins helps some people, but to consider it a cure all for everyone is not really a good idea. Everyone is different and has different needs. I need a high protein and high carb diet (high carbs especially before races) because of the sports I participate in. But again, we all are different.

I still submit that the primary (not only) reason is the increased consumption of empty calories and junk foods along with reduced exercise.

I'm on a moderate diet - rather than doing anything 'low' - moderate consumption of calories, fats, sugars, fiber, carbs - it works for me.

That's the key to dieting - everyone is different psychologically. People have to find a new routine that they feel is maintainable and controllable. I'm going in the direction where my bodyfat loss is slow but I don't feel deprived - I still have the sweets and treats I crave, I just don't consume them in high quantities or extremely frequently.

But that won't work for others - others can't handle moderating intake of their favorite candy, so some choose to just abstain altogether. . . .whatever works.

But, first, people have ti give a damn
 
As a kid I couldn't stand salad, was no fan of vegetables, wasn't a big fan of spuds, enjoyed meat and eggs, cheese was putrid, cereal with milk was the standard breakfast, drank a fair bit of milk and this didn't change a whole lot until I was in my mid-late 20's (except the milk; I stopped drinking it at about 18... except for milkshakes). At 20 I had a physical and the doc said with my cholesterol level I'd live to be 200; I was anything but fat.

I was an active kid, and eating breakfast was a slog... regardless of what it was.

As for the Food Pyramid... here's an article about it:



A researcher at U Penn did a study about Atkins and cholesterol and thought... this will be the first and last, as he expected a huge increase. Wrong. he was blown away.

In Denmark they set up a trial and the people went to a special store where they received and monitored everything; all Atkins related. Their blood profiles improved.

It's simple and I notice it. If I eat a breakfast of eggs, ham, toast (not Atkins but I like toast with B & E) I am full the entire day up to late afternoon, early evening, and I don't tire. I don't follow Atkins as a religion, as I don't have a weight problem, BUT I found it interesting and applied it and his recommendations do suppress appetite. If I ever feel like I've got a couple pounds too many I knock off the beer, get outside a little more and in a 4 to 6 weeks I've lost the weight.. if not sooner.

.

I agree that the food pyramid is a joke... I've heard that the pyramid is the same proportions of food used in pigs diet to fatten them up for slaughter.

Atkins diet, well, dr Atkins died of a massive heart attack. So, maybe he should not be held in such high esteem, but he was probably right about the refined carbs...
 
I agree that the food pyramid is a joke... I've heard that the pyramid is the same proportions of food used in pigs diet to fatten them up for slaughter.

Atkins diet, well, dr Atkins died of a massive heart attack.
So, maybe he should not be held in such high esteem, but he was probably right about the refined carbs...

your continued level of FAIL in all posts is astounding...

Diet guru Dr. Robert Atkins dead at 72 - CNN
Dr. Robert Atkins, creator of the high-protein, low-carbohydrate Atkins Diet, died Thursday after an accidental fall on April 8 left him comatose.

Atkins, 72, was rushed to New York Weill Cornell Medical Center by his colleague, Dr. Keith Berkowitz, where surgeons removed a blood clot to relieve pressure in his brain on April 9.

Atkins slipped on an icy sidewalk outside his New York office.

"We are hoping for a miracle," Richard Rothstein, a spokesman for Atkins told CNN April 11, "but the chances for a meaningful recovery are slim.

Here's more detailed information on his death:
USATODAY.com - Statements on Atkins' death
 
Last edited:
your continued level of FAIL in all posts is astounding...

Diet guru Dr. Robert Atkins dead at 72 - CNN


Here's more detailed information on his death:
USATODAY.com - Statements on Atkins' death

*applause* you made a legitimate point for a change...

But it was actually a misunderstanding... he WAS being treated for cardiomyopathy, which I probably only read half paying attention, so you're correct that was unrelated to his cause of death, and probably the source of what got twisted into a heart attack.

I agree in principal with the high protein / low carb diet, and maybe it's just downplaying veggies in the ads, but if you're not getting a good mix of veggies in your diet you better be taking nutritional supplements.

Anyway, I stand corrected.

And your next post is going to tell me that I need to reconsider my entire life because Atkins didn't die of a heart attack.
 
Last edited:
I will not go by the Atkins diet. No need for me to. Like you, I go pretty big on breakfast. High on protein (meat, milk, eggs) and I spread my fruit intake throughout the day. Many people make the mistake of a fruit-heavy breakfast which causes them to feel hungry again by 10AM. Like you, I don't feel hungry until lunch time, regardless of how hard my morning workouts are.

I am sure Atkins helps some people, but to consider it a cure all for everyone is not really a good idea. Everyone is different and has different needs. I need a high protein and high carb diet (high carbs especially before races) because of the sports I participate in. But again, we all are different.

I still submit that the primary (not only) reason is the increased consumption of empty calories and junk foods along with reduced exercise.

I agree... no diet is a cure all, hence I dislike government recommendations. And the Government Food Pyramid turned into the Government Sugar Pyramid.

I agree that the food pyramid is a joke... I've heard that the pyramid is the same proportions of food used in pigs diet to fatten them up for slaughter.

Atkins diet, well, dr Atkins died of a massive heart attack. So, maybe he should not be held in such high esteem, but he was probably right about the refined carbs...
I recall Atkins died from slipping on ice, but the veg-O-matic crowd, including some unethical MD's tried to spin his death as caused by his diet.
Years after his death in 2003, the rumor that Dr. Robert Atkins "died of his own diet" persists. The falsehoods concerning his death are mainly propagated by the vegan group the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine and related groups and individuals. However, even the mainstream media is not blameless. In March 2007, Newsweek magazine published an opinion piece by Dr. Dean Ornish which contained the same untruths, which were later retracted by the magazine*.

* In March 2007, Newsweek magazine published a correction stating, "An earlier version of this story contained an inaccurate account of events surrounding the death of Dr. Robert Atkins. Newsweek regrets the error."

In 2000, Dr. Atkins developed cardiomyopathy, an incurable heart condition which has quite a few different causes. His was thought to be from a viral illness, and his physician stated at the time that there was no evidence that his diet contributed to the condition. His coronary arteries were reported to have been checked at that time and found to be free of blockages.

On April 8, 2003, at age 72, Dr. Atkins slipped on the ice while walking to work, hitting his head and causing bleeding around his brain. He lost consciousness on the way to the hospital, where he spent two weeks in intensive care. His body deteriorated rapidly and he suffered massive organ failure. During this time, his body apparently retained an enormous amount of fluid, and his weight at death was recorded at 258 pounds. His death certificate states that the cause of death was "blunt impact injury of head with epidural hematoma".

How Did Atkins Die - Death Of Dr. Robert Atkins
.
 
Kids spend the majority of their awake day at school, however - and many (who have to ride an early bus) eat 2 meals there, not just one. My kids get up at 6:30 - off to school at 7:00 - 7:30 . . . gone for 8 - 8 1/2 hours - come home at 3:30 - 4:00 and bedtime is at 8:00 which is 3 1/2 or 4 hours after coming home.

Mine, though, eat breakfast, dinner and snack at home - lunch is the only thing consumed at school.

We're also fortunate enough to be in a school district that believes in healthy food options: they get fruit for a mid-afternoon snack at school and have options of fresh fruits/veggies (like the salad bar) at school - something that's missing from the majority of schools around the country.

Our younger 2 have recess during the afternoon - on Friday they have PE

Our oldest son is in Track - that's his only physical activity at school

Our 2nd son is in 5th grade - no physical-education classes at all right now.

I agree, however, that home plays a huge role: Have you seen a kid's football team lately? Several hours of intense physical activity every week - but a lot of those kids are overweight. So, yes, of course home-life and pre-school years play a role into further enabling unhealthy habits all around. A lot of kids come to pre-K already overweight. . . something that will never change throughout their life until they're adult and take control of their health, if they ever care.
When my 2nd son was on a tiger-cub football team there were two kids on the team who weighed more than me and would eat a Big-Mac meal before every practice session - that's over 1,000 calories right there.

Alot of what you said is true...but I think your overstating the amount of time spent in school. Most kids are in school umm what 150-160 days out of 365. Most kids eat just lunch and some bring it.
The number of kids actually on the football team is minimal when you look at the schools total. Whats making the kids fat in my mind aunt spiker, they sit on the school bus, <we walked to school> The sit most of the day in school, the come home eat and sit again till dinner, then sit again till bedtime...then some on the weekend sit and play WOW and playstation all weekend...they just arent moving like they used too...like someone else said we had our fat kids...but it wasnt and epidemic.
Schools cannot and should not be responsible for your kids, WE ARE the ones that chose to bring them in this world.
Parents that are too lazy to cook a balanced healthy meal everyday and order delivery, pizza, chinese.
If we want to stop this obesity epidemic...two things have to happen, kids have to get OFF their ass and Parents have to make them and make sure when they are home they arent eating garbage. 160 days of one meal in school cannot change obesity in my mind
 
Will they ban every other food item that contains sugar too?
 
I agree... no diet is a cure all, hence I dislike government recommendations. And the Government Food Pyramid turned into the Government Sugar Pyramid.


I recall Atkins died from slipping on ice, but the veg-O-matic crowd, including some unethical MD's tried to spin his death as caused by his diet.

.

Ya, ok, that makes more sense then, that others were trying to spin this and that's where I got the misunderstanding...
 
Anyway, I stand corrected.

And your next post is going to tell me that I need to reconsider my entire life because Atkins didn't die of a heart attack.

No. You need to reconsider your life for many other reasons, not because of how Dr. Atkins died.
 
Alot of what you said is true...but I think your overstating the amount of time spent in school. Most kids are in school umm what 150-160 days out of 365. Most kids eat just lunch and some bring it.
The number of kids actually on the football team is minimal when you look at the schools total. Whats making the kids fat in my mind aunt spiker, they sit on the school bus, <we walked to school> The sit most of the day in school, the come home eat and sit again till dinner, then sit again till bedtime...then some on the weekend sit and play WOW and playstation all weekend...they just arent moving like they used too...like someone else said we had our fat kids...but it wasnt and epidemic.
Schools cannot and should not be responsible for your kids, WE ARE the ones that chose to bring them in this world.
Parents that are too lazy to cook a balanced healthy meal everyday and order delivery, pizza, chinese.
If we want to stop this obesity epidemic...two things have to happen, kids have to get OFF their ass and Parents have to make them and make sure when they are home they arent eating garbage. 160 days of one meal in school cannot change obesity in my mind

Yeah - I agree - a lot of kids are sedentary. . . to be healthy/lose weight you have to do all - not just tackle one or the other. . . .diet and daily activity must all be considered and improved. You can trim down a diet but stay unactive and actually see no major changes. Vise versa.

It is hard for me to imagine how others live - my kids are active to the point where we worry about them being underweight. I can't imagine letting them just be bumps on a log all the time and then wonder why they're so chubby *shrug*
 
Way to not get my point :lol:

Kids shouldn't be forced to go hungry in school period. Most kids pay for their lunches, and if we can't provide food for kids who have no control over their situation, then that's not a country I want to live in.

How is the school "forcing" kids to go hungry? That's quite a stupid comment you made.
 
Imagine the distress caused to these children by not being offered an unhealthy diet choice. :roll:

Who do these people think they are, educators?
 
Last edited:
Schools may ban chocolate milk over added sugar - Yahoo! News


Let's see, recesses are being shortened, high activity games are either banned or heavily structured for fear of "lawsuits" cause kids might "get hurt".

It's not what you eat, it's what you do. The more parents abdicate their responsibilities of raising their kids to the Gov't, the more problems we keep having.

Amazingly the answer seems to be "more control"! It's like the world has entered a dark time of stupid.

When it comes to the topic of education and school policy, I would hope the illiteracy rate would take precedence over chocolate mile.
 
When it comes to the topic of education and school policy, I would hope the illiteracy rate would take precedence over chocolate mile.
The more important things never take precedence which is why congress passed a law against commercials being louder than programming without hesitation, but took ten years to pass a budget.
 
The more important things never take precedence which is why congress passed a law against commercials being louder than programming without hesitation, but took ten years to pass a budget.

Ten years to pass a budget, and we're supposed to trust them with our medical expenses......sounds ligit.
 
Back
Top Bottom