Do you know what Evangelical means? An Evangelical is one who believes in preaching the gospel, i.e. the "good news" and converting lost souls to Christ. If you are crass enough to believe in brownie points, the worse the individual is, the more brownie points there are for conversion. Consequently, it goes against the doctrine to kill non-believers, etc. unless required by self defense because then they lose all chance at salvation.
A Muslim can defend his faith and be praised for killing an unbeliever just because he is an unbeliever. Christian theology is exactly the opposite. The heroes of the New Testament never killed. Ever. The closest you can get to it is Paul before he was converted. And then he was killing Christians. There are only two instances of "Christian" violence in the entire New Testament. 1) Christ used a whip when he drove the money changers out of the temple, and 2) When Peter cut off the ear of a man arresting Jesus at Gethsemane. Even then, he was admonished for it and the ear was healed.
I don't think you'll find that example in Islamic history.