• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Church Ousts Nun Who OK'd Abortion to Save Woman

Meanwhile, back at the Vatican, the pope is greasing up another alter boy.

And people wonder why the **** I hate the Catholic church (note - church as in the leaders and priests, not the people who attend mass . . . there's a HUGE difference there).

Actually there's no difference at all, if you look at how the Church is structured.

The lay person attending mass is every bit as much "the church" as the Pope.

When you say you hate the Church you are saying you hate all Catholics. Your qualifiers don't work because you don't target individuals.
 
Hey come on. The Catholic Church can't be held responsible for the actions of 99% of its leaders.
Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted is hardly 99% of the leadership :roll:
 
Actually there's no difference at all, if you look at how the Church is structured.

The lay person attending mass is every bit as much "the church" as the Pope.

When you say you hate the Church you are saying you hate all Catholics. Your qualifiers don't work because you don't target individuals.

Don't spoon-feed me that tripe.

The Catholic members are separate from their Pope and other leaders. How? the members who attend service and mass don't have the weight or power within the church to make decisions on what happens, how services are conducted and so on, so forth.

They have menial influence in the Catholic-priesthood and Vatican body. As it is in almost every church out there.

I don't believe for one moment that the people are guilty of child-molestation or are ok with it even though their Church's Priest might have committed it and their Pope turned a blind eye to it.
 
In this case the nuns were acting very much within the Church's control.

It's a single Bishop who stepped out of line.

Sorry Jerry. You must apply this to all Catholics and the church as a whole if you want to truly bask in the bigotry. :roll:
 
Don't spoon-feed me that tripe.

The Catholic members are separate from their Pope and other leaders. How? the members who attend service and mass don't have the weight or power within the church to make decisions on what happens, how services are conducted and so on, so forth.

They have menial influence in the Catholic-priesthood and Vatican body. As it is in almost every church out there.

I don't believe for one moment that the people are guilty of child-molestation or are ok with it even though their Church's Priest might have committed it and their Pope turned a blind eye to it.

So when Clinton cheated on his wife that means all democrats are wife cheaters?

Do you ever stop to actually think about your remarks or are you so wrapped up in the Christian bashing you can't see past your own nose?
 
So when Clinton cheated on his wife that means all democrats are wife cheaters?

Do you ever stop to actually think about your remarks or are you so wrapped up in the Christian bashing you can't see past your own nose?

If you believe that logic, then you hate America.

Now, are you guys suggesting that if I say I think this Pope is awful that means I hate all Catholics?
 
Last edited:
I actually have a catholic side of the family(on my mother side), so I don't hate all Catholic's. I just find them hypocritical. :)
 
Don't spoon-feed me that tripe.

The Catholic members are separate from their Pope and other leaders. How? the members who attend service and mass don't have the weight or power within the church to make decisions on what happens, how services are conducted and so on, so forth.

They have menial influence in the Catholic-priesthood and Vatican body. As it is in almost every church out there.

I don't believe for one moment that the people are guilty of child-molestation or are ok with it even though their Church's Priest might have committed it and their Pope turned a blind eye to it.

I suppose you don't think you're a part of DebatePolitics.com, either :doh
 
Sorry Jerry. You must apply this to all Catholics and the church as a whole if you want to truly bask in the bigotry. :roll:

When other Catholics enter the spot lite of this story, I sure will.
 
So when Clinton cheated on his wife that means all democrats are wife cheaters?

Do you ever stop to actually think about your remarks or are you so wrapped up in the Christian bashing you can't see past your own nose?

Why do people toss Clinton's affair into things - just randomly out of the blue - it's been tossed into so many threads when it means nothing and has no bearing on the point or subject being had?

Since the dawn of man men and women have cheated on their spouses and partner it's *really* just a reflection of human nature more than anything else - but somehow people want to make some type of *point* by bringing up the fact that a guy cheated on his wife . . . as if it's something *new* :confused:

But we digress. No, I don't support the leaders of the Catholic Church at all. It's not the religion itself, it's basic beliefs, that are so offensive (like - believing in God, Believing that Jesus was crucified, etc - it's not these things) - it's what *people* (Like Popes throughout history and large number of leaders) it's what these people have *done* in the name of their religion that make it SO foul.

Religion would be fine - if it weren't for wretched people using it as fulcrum to do terrible things to mass numbers of people.

Wretched things done in the name of religion:

The Inquisition
Salem Witch Trials (and other witch trials throughout history)
The Children's Army
Islamic Jihad
Human Sacrifices in Burma
Heaven's Gate

The list can go on for a mile.

Religion itself is innocent and fine - Religion is dangerous and offensive when the leaders go insane and start maiming and inflicting torture and passing judgment on people simply because they don't agree or follow with them.

so, forgive me if my hangup on these offenses against humanity that have gone on since the dawn of man bar me from respecting the religious-bodies that ordain and commit them.

:shrug:

I didn't use to be like this, though. My tipping point could have happened earlier but I pin it to when I was in the foyer of my Dad's former church and I heard our church's treasurer talking about how our "nigger janitor not being able to do his job right" . . .what did he do? Well, he was born black, for one thing - so criminal, I know :roll: And he failed to vacuum the foyer carpet all in the same direction.

Yep, so atrocious, he vacuumed up and down - and then in some places he vacuumed side to side.

Wow, yeah, that really slammed the door on my religious-totter heart. Up until that comment at that point I really was troubled by my religious imbalance.

She was actually later found to be guilty of thieving money from the church - over $100,000 over a long period of time, in fact, so maybe she was one of those people who went to church to continually ease her guilty heart.

All those years being behind the scenes at the church - the church laymen never did anything 'wrong' - all the offenses that were committed were done so by the leaders. And this continues to be quite true for almost every religion that's plagued with foul entities.

So, give the leaders a pass? No
They accept and embrace their Religion's history when they decide to become a man of the cloth or what have you. It's not like they're all blissfully ignorant of their founder's aggressions.

The people, though, who go to church every Sunday (or mass, or Wednesday service) are merely satisfying a need and fulfilling a want in life.

Even my own Dad is guilty of something I consider to be absolutely unacceptable from a Minster - what is it? I'll keep that to myself. But my view doesn't leave him out of the riptide.
 
Last edited:
If you believe that logic, then you hate America.

Now, are you guys suggesting that if I say I think this Pope is awful that means I hate all Catholics?

Notice the difference between the statements "I hate the Catholic church" and "I think this Pope is awful".

The first addresses the entire community, the second addresses a single individual.

It is the same difference between "I hate DebatePolitics.com" and "I think the Admin is awful".

The first statement regards every member, every thread and post, the Tavern, the Basement, the award system, Arcade, social groups, the type and location of the server the site is hosted on.....everything.

The second statement only regards one individual's behavior.
 
Last edited:
Church Ousts Nun Who OK'd Abortion to Save Woman - CBS News

CBS took the PC route and used the word "oust" instead of "excommunicate."



And from NPR:
Nun Excommunicated For Allowing Abortion : NPR


Short version: Woman has heart problem, continued pregnancy was going to kill her. The administrator who approved the abortion was a nun, gets excommunicated.

Given a clear cut choice between kill the child and kill both, the church would have chosen both, apparently. I feel bad for everyone involved.


One Bishop hardly sounds like the entire catholic church. I guess all libs who are against the way must be like Code Pink, or the God hates Fags church that protest at the funerals of fallen soldiers and marines. Or maybe all Muslims are terrorist because of what a bunch of Muslim terrorist did.
 
Last edited:
Notice the difference between the statements "I hate the Catholic church" and "I think this Pope is awful".

The first addresses the entire community, the second addresses a single individual.

It is the same difference between "I hate DebatePolitics.com" and "I think the Admin is awful".

The first statement regards every member, every thread and post, the Tavern, the Basement, the award system, Arcade, social groups, the type and location of the server the site is hosted on.....everything.

The second statement only regards one individual's behavior.

Ah, I see that point. You're right, to religious people the term 'the church' is in reference to everyone in the entire church - I tend to forget that.

From here on out I'll be certain to write it "I loath the Catholic Church Hierarchy - thus, not including the laymen of the church"
 
Notice the difference between the statements "I hate the Catholic church" and "I think this Pope is awful".

The first addresses the entire community, the second addresses a single individual.

It is the same difference between "I hate DebatePolitics.com" and "I think the Admin is awful".

The first statement regards every member, every thread and post, the Tavern, the Basement, the award system, Arcade, social groups, the type and location of the server the site is hosted on.....everything.

The second statement only regards one individual's behavior.

I see the difference and believe me, I have a lot of problems with the Catholic Church; but I don't hate it.

I don't hate any individuals for their religious choices and I don't blame them for what others of their faith do even if I have problems with that faith.

But this Pope (as opposed to his predecessor) hasn't done much for the reputation of the Church with the rest of the world. Don't know that it's necessarily his job; but wow...

This wasn't his decision, but it just adds to a problematic image that the Church can't seem to shake.
 
Ah, I see that point. You're right, to religious people the term 'the church' is in reference to everyone in the entire church - I tend to forget that.

From here on out I'll be certain to write it "I loath the Catholic Church Hierarchy - thus, not including the laymen of the church"

Please do beat up on the pedophiles and those who protect them.
 
Jerry the people that protect them are the ones who are in the Catholic church, so that is a logical fallacy.


On my mother side, of the family they are in the catholic church, so I am not being biased for pointing out hypocrites in the church. Which I consider the higher ups hypocrites too the fullest. :2wave:
 
Jerry the people that protect them are the ones who are in the Catholic church, so that is a logical fallacy.

People who want them persecuted are also in the Catholic Church.

Oh, and claiming that something is a logical fallacy is not how a logical fallacy is exposed and dealt with :2wave:
 
People who want them persecuted are also in the Catholic Church.

Oh, and claiming that something is a logical fallacy is not how a logical fallacy is exposed and dealt with :2wave:

True, it seem you doing a lot of protect the hypocrites, and trying to defend them more often than you should.
 
True, it seem you doing a lot of protect the hypocrites, and trying to defend them more often than you should.

Why do you claim that the nun who approved the abortion and the hospital staff who carried it out are hypocrites?
 
Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted is hardly 99% of the leadership :roll:

The Catholic Church is not some decentralized evangelical church, where no one is accountable to anyone else. The Catholic Church is more like the US military: highly structured with a clear chain of command. This bishop has people above him in the chain of command. If they don't undo his wrongdoing, then they are just as guilty as he is.
 
Last edited:
Hey come on. The Catholic Church can't be held responsible for the actions of 99% of its leaders.

I am Catholic and I understand that the Church has given some license to people like you to make snide comments about the leadership and the church in general regarding inappropriate sexual behavior and paedophilia by some of their priests. But you ought to be able to argue a specific issue without grossly exaggerated statements. It just makes you look ignorant or like someone with an anti-religious agenda. The sum of what is the Catholic Church is not defined by the sexual misconduct issue.

On the face of it, it seems the nun made the right decision but people with agendas often leave out details that may make it seem otherwise. Let's hope a proper investigation by the Church will shed some light.
 
Well I see the usual church bashers are out in force even if I disagree with their decision taking the opportunity to display your own extreme bigotry towards Christianity isn't warranted.

The Biggest Bigot being the man who styles himself 'Vicar of Christ'.
 
Back
Top Bottom