• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

GOP's Brown wins Mass. Senate seat in epic upset

My step son recently got the flu and the Dr. proscribed some medicine. It is a fairly recently available and its promise is the sooner taken the sooner the flu is knocked out. Within roughly 36 or less the fever was gone aftet the med was taken. W/O insurance the med was something like 200 + bucks and even with the insurance it was still 67 bucks.

Was it antibiotics? If so, your doctor is part of the problem, not the solution.

Also, do you really need to "cure" the flu? Every time I got the flu I just stayed in bed and ate chicken noodle soup. Always worked well for me...
 
So I guess every exact detail is necessary for you to understand a point.

OK, my cousin didn't have insurance and got sick. He tried to ride it out, taking over the counter medicine. He got sicker and sicker until his wife took him to the emergency room. He was diagnosed with pneumonia and was admitted to the hospital where he spent X number of days (only a couple if I remember correctly) and was then sent home to continue to recover. His bill was approx. 10k.

He has been paying off his bill for 2 years. He was out of work nearly 2 months. Who paid for his lack of productivity? We all did.

Is there some evidence that using emergency rooms is cheaper than preventative care?


Your cousin is a MORON. Would he have taken his car to the mechanic if it was sputtering and idling fast? Or would he have waited until his car stalled on the highway? There's something called personal responsibility, and your cousin clearly doesn't have much of it. If he was that sick and didn't bother going to the doctor because he was too cheap, then his priorities are out of wack. But I bet he pays out the nose for his cell phone and cable service.

I am one of those Americans without health insurance, and I absolutely do not want it from the gov't. I *choose* to take care of my own medical bills so *I* can make my own choices as far as what drs I see and when. We do have catastrophic insurance because we're not idiots. Because the state I live in has some BS gov't run heathcare and started dicking around with too many insurance regulations, it's now way too cost prohibitive for a middle class family to self insure. My monthly premium skyrocketted to well over my monthly mortgage payment, and I built my house when house prices were through the roof.

There have been many times I've thought to myself, "do I really need to see a dr and pay $125 for an office visit?" And you know, if I'm sick, I freaking do it. In fact yesterday, we just received a bill for $500 for me to have some basal cell removed. So the freak what. I'll pay a lot more than that on my electricity bill over the next few months, and I don't expect the gov't to pay for that either (what? electricity in the US should be a right!:roll:). I'll pay a lot more than that for the luxury of flushing my toilets this year.

So when I think of these people (who you know dang right well have iPods and awesome cellphones) who are too cheap to drop $100 to see a dr to take care of their health, I don't have a lot of sympathy. If you're dirt poor, the gov't will pay it anyway. If you're not dirt poor, poney up the cash and quityerbitchen.

/rant
 
Was it antibiotics? If so, your doctor is part of the problem, not the solution.

Also, do you really need to "cure" the flu? Every time I got the flu I just stayed in bed and ate chicken noodle soup. Always worked well for me...

It was probably tamiflu. If my kid were sick, I would pay the 200 bones OOP for it. I drop $200/week to send him to camp, so I surely wouldn't with hold that money to make him feel well. It's about priorities, people.
 
:applaud
Your cousin is a MORON. Would he have taken his car to the mechanic if it was sputtering and idling fast? Or would he have waited until his car stalled on the highway? There's something called personal responsibility, and your cousin clearly doesn't have much of it. If he was that sick and didn't bother going to the doctor because he was too cheap, then his priorities are out of wack. But I bet he pays out the nose for his cell phone and cable service.

I am one of those Americans without health insurance, and I absolutely do not want it from the gov't. I *choose* to take care of my own medical bills so *I* can make my own choices as far as what drs I see and when. We do have catastrophic insurance because we're not idiots. Because the state I live in has some BS gov't run heathcare and started dicking around with too many insurance regulations, it's now way too cost prohibitive for a middle class family to self insure. My monthly premium skyrocketted to well over my monthly mortgage payment, and I built my house when house prices were through the roof.

There have been many times I've thought to myself, "do I really need to see a dr and pay $125 for an office visit?" And you know, if I'm sick, I freaking do it. In fact yesterday, we just received a bill for $500 for me to have some basal cell removed. So the freak what. I'll pay a lot more than that on my electricity bill over the next few months, and I don't expect the gov't to pay for that either (what? electricity in the US should be a right!:roll:). I'll pay a lot more than that for the luxury of flushing my toilets this year.

So when I think of these people (who you know dang right well have iPods and awesome cellphones) who are too cheap to drop $100 to see a dr to take care of their health, I don't have a lot of sympathy. If you're dirt poor, the gov't will pay it anyway. If you're not dirt poor, poney up the cash and quityerbitchen.

/rant

Absolutely outstanding post, :applaud you nailed it. The entitlement mentality individual however will never get it.
 
We should all be charitable from within our own hearts. Having you tell me for example, what I should give, and to whom is not correct.


j-mac

Yes we should but since we won't, what should be done?

You see, that's why SS was started in the first place; people who needed charity couldn't get it or were too ashamed to ask people they know (the government being faceless) and therefore suffered and died.
 
Yes we should but since we won't, what should be done?

You see, that's why SS was started in the first place; people who needed charity couldn't get it or were too ashamed to ask people they know (the government being faceless) and therefore suffered and died.

If I couldn't afford to buy food for my family, the first thing I'd do is let go of my stupid ego, and I'd ask someone for help. Or maybe that's just a little too much work for some people. It's easier to wait on your azz for a check while watching Jerry Springer. Get real. :roll:
 
Your entire argument is premised on the assumption that if he had had insurance, none of this would have happened because he would have gone to see a doctor when he first got the flu symptoms and that would have changed the whole course of events. In reality, if he had had insurance and gone to see the doctor, the doctor most likely would have told him to get some bed rest, drink lots of fluids, and take some acetaminophen, aka Nyquil. Which is what he did.
And your argument is based on the assumption that having insurance wouldn't have made a difference.

If he had insurance he could have gone back to the doctor saying that he's feeling even worse than last week. The doctor could then have prescribed medication.
 
And your argument is based on the assumption that having insurance wouldn't have made a difference.

If he had insurance he could have gone back to the doctor saying that he's feeling even worse than last week. The doctor could then have prescribed medication.

Does your cousin have a cell phone? Cable service? iPod? Does he ever go out on the weekends and piss away half his paycheck on partying?
 
And your argument is based on the assumption that having insurance wouldn't have made a difference.

If he had insurance he could have gone back to the doctor saying that he's feeling even worse than last week. The doctor could then have prescribed medication.

I imagine if he wasn't willing to cough up the $75-$100 to see the doctor in the first place, insurance wouldn't have moved him to care for his health any better.

And Right's argument made no such assumption. Right's argument pointed out the likely fact that your relative did exactly as the doctor would have first instructed him anyway.
 
Plus, what else did he do? Did he stay in bed and get the needed rest? Or did he just take the NyQuil and keep plodding on as normal?

Flu doesn't generally lead to pneumonia unless you aggravate it.

I think he worked for the first week, because, you know, he needs to pay the rent. I'm sure you'll call him an idiot now because he WANTED to keep working.
 
I think he worked for the first week, because, you know, he needs to pay the rent.

That was thoughtful of him to spread the germs around his work. Who is this f*cknut? I hope I don't end up in an elevator with him.
 
Was it antibiotics? If so, your doctor is part of the problem, not the solution.

Also, do you really need to "cure" the flu? Every time I got the flu I just stayed in bed and ate chicken noodle soup. Always worked well for me...

Well bully for you. What a great guy you must be. Good thing you can afford to take a week off work. Lack of empathy noted. :roll:
 
Well bully for you. What a great guy you must be. Good thing you can afford to take a week off work. Lack of empathy noted. :roll:

If it took him a full week to get over a little flu, then that's the least of his problems.

And it isn't about taking the week off when you get sick. It's about saving for such an eventuality while you are not sick.
 
Well bully for you. What a great guy you must be. Good thing you can afford to take a week off work. Lack of empathy noted. :roll:


Maybe he should find a more affordable rent if he's living pay check to pay check.

Not taking care of his health when he first got sick certainly took him out of work for a while, didn't it? Lesson learned, I hope.
 
Your cousin is a MORON. Would he have taken his car to the mechanic if it was sputtering and idling fast? Or would he have waited until his car stalled on the highway? There's something called personal responsibility, and your cousin clearly doesn't have much of it. If he was that sick and didn't bother going to the doctor because he was too cheap, then his priorities are out of wack. But I bet he pays out the nose for his cell phone and cable service.

I am one of those Americans without health insurance, and I absolutely do not want it from the gov't. I *choose* to take care of my own medical bills so *I* can make my own choices as far as what drs I see and when. We do have catastrophic insurance because we're not idiots. Because the state I live in has some BS gov't run heathcare and started dicking around with too many insurance regulations, it's now way too cost prohibitive for a middle class family to self insure. My monthly premium skyrocketted to well over my monthly mortgage payment, and I built my house when house prices were through the roof.

There have been many times I've thought to myself, "do I really need to see a dr and pay $125 for an office visit?" And you know, if I'm sick, I freaking do it. In fact yesterday, we just received a bill for $500 for me to have some basal cell removed. So the freak what. I'll pay a lot more than that on my electricity bill over the next few months, and I don't expect the gov't to pay for that either (what? electricity in the US should be a right!:roll:). I'll pay a lot more than that for the luxury of flushing my toilets this year.

So when I think of these people (who you know dang right well have iPods and awesome cellphones) who are too cheap to drop $100 to see a dr to take care of their health, I don't have a lot of sympathy. If you're dirt poor, the gov't will pay it anyway. If you're not dirt poor, poney up the cash and quityerbitchen.

/rant

Rant all you want, you don't have any of the facts correct and you simply built a strawman in order to set it on fire. This makes you, and your pals that thanked you, the real morons. :2wave:
 
Rant all you want, you don't have any of the facts correct and you simply built a strawman in order to set it on fire. This makes you, and your pals that thanked you, the real morons. :2wave:

Yeah, but I'm not the moron stuck with a 2 year payment plan to the hospital because I was stupid enough to pretend I wasn't sick in order to save a few bucks.

How many people did he infect at work?
 
It was probably tamiflu. If my kid were sick, I would pay the 200 bones OOP for it. I drop $200/week to send him to camp, so I surely wouldn't with hold that money to make him feel well. It's about priorities, people.
It was probably a miracle cure that wiped out the flu. I could continue to make up some more stupidity like you did but I'll just stop there.
 
It was probably a miracle cure that wiped out the flu. I could continue to make up some more stupidity like you did but I'll just stop there.

There's a miracle cure that wipes out the flu?!? Who is the one making up stupidity?

Does your cousin ever piss away money at titty bars?
 
If I couldn't afford to buy food for my family, the first thing I'd do is let go of my stupid ego, and I'd ask someone for help. Or maybe that's just a little too much work for some people. It's easier to wait on your azz for a check while watching Jerry Springer. Get real. :roll:

Yes, I'm sure the old folks back in 1935 were just stupid lazy old farmers watching something that hadn't been invented yet. You're a real wizard!! lack of empathy noted.

Seems like a lot of conservatives lack empathy.
 
And your argument is based on the assumption that having insurance wouldn't have made a difference.

No, I'm not relying on any assumption, but merely pointing out the flaws in your argument and the attendant problems with making policy by anecdote.

If he had insurance he could have gone back to the doctor saying that he's feeling even worse than last week. The doctor could then have prescribed medication.

I think he worked for the first week, because, you know, he needs to pay the rent. I'm sure you'll call him an idiot now because he WANTED to keep working.

So he refused to take off a day from work to stay at home and rest, but your theory is that he would have taken two days off from work to go see the doctor?

And you've just admitted that even if he had had health insurance, he still wouldn't have stayed home and rested, which is probably what caused him to get pneumonia in the first place.
 
Does your cousin have a cell phone? Cable service? iPod? Does he ever go out on the weekends and piss away half his paycheck on partying?
Nope, he's a single father (black man go figure eh?) with 2 small children. His wife died of ovarian cancer in march 2009, she was undiagnosed until January 2009. No cell phone, basic cable, old car, renting.

I bet you've seen people on food stamps buying steaks, people on welfare driving mercedes and union workers taking 4 hour breaks. :roll:
 
That was thoughtful of him to spread the germs around his work. Who is this f*cknut? I hope I don't end up in an elevator with him.
I wish you would and I wish he knew it.
 
No, I'm not relying on any assumption, but merely pointing out the flaws in your argument and the attendant problems with making policy by anecdote.
No you're making an assumption that things wouldn't have been different had he had insurance.

So he refused to take off a day from work to stay at home and rest, but your theory is that he would have taken two days off from work to go see the doctor?
No, he couldn't afford to take time off. So he worked, undiagnosed but ill, until he was unable to continue working.

And you've just admitted that even if he had had health insurance, he still wouldn't have stayed home and rested, which is probably what caused him to get pneumonia in the first place.
If he had health insurance his doctor could have diagnosed the flu and not just a seasonal cold, prescribed medication, given him a note for his employer so he wouldn't lose his position, told him to get bed rest. He probably wouldn't have gotten pneumonia.
 
I wish you would and I wish he knew it.

And you say conservatives are not compassionate. :roll: You and your cousin Billy Bob sound like real swell fellers ... just the kind of people I'd love to foot the bill for your medical costs. :roll:


I certainly have.

Me as well.
 
Back
Top Bottom