• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Russia cargo jet crash kills 11

Scorpion89

Banned
Joined
May 29, 2009
Messages
2,629
Reaction score
527
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
BBC NEWS | Europe | Russia cargo jet crash kills 11

A Russian cargo plane has crashed in the far-eastern Yakutia region, killing all 11 crew members on board.

The government plane had just unloaded its cargo at Mirnyi airport. It took off and crashed 25 km (15 miles) away, Russian state media reports.

The Ilyushin came down in a deserted area and there were no casualties on the ground, local officials say.

A special commission of the Russian Interior Ministry has left Moscow to investigate the cause of the accident.

"After being unloaded the plane... took off but then deviated from the course and crashed 25 km away from the runway," an official from the Russian Emergencies Ministry told reporters.

Bodies of the 11 crew members from the interior ministry plane have been recovered from the crash scene, reports say.

This is becoming a serious issue with Russia there Cargo Fleet is aging very fast and maintance is very poor, this is the 5th Il-76 to be lost this year.
 
One of the notable failings of the Soviet Union was their technology which on the surface seemed in many ways to equal the west or even surpass it in some areas was that it was in many cases slapped together with the use of old and new methods in manufacturing. Jet engines for example were built that could push fighter planes to reach astounding speeds but only for a very short time and the engines had to be either rebuilt or replaced because of poor metallurgic content. They built cargo planes capable of lifting extremely heavy loads then over loaded them on a regular basis taxing the structural integerty of the aircraft.
These factors along with the aforementioned maintainability are major factors in all Russian equipment from the planes to their Subs many of which are rusting into oblivion in places like Murmansk.
It's another symptom and result of the Socialist/Communist with a completely failed economy and making do with what you have because you can't do better.
Then again it could be a simple as contaminated fuel.
 
BBC NEWS | Europe | Russia cargo jet crash kills 11

A Russian cargo plane has crashed in the far-eastern Yakutia region, killing all 11 crew members on board.

The government plane had just unloaded its cargo at Mirnyi airport. It took off and crashed 25 km (15 miles) away, Russian state media reports.

The Ilyushin came down in a deserted area and there were no casualties on the ground, local officials say.

A special commission of the Russian Interior Ministry has left Moscow to investigate the cause of the accident.

"After being unloaded the plane... took off but then deviated from the course and crashed 25 km away from the runway," an official from the Russian Emergencies Ministry told reporters.

Bodies of the 11 crew members from the interior ministry plane have been recovered from the crash scene, reports say.

This is becoming a serious issue with Russia there Cargo Fleet is aging very fast and maintance is very poor, this is the 5th Il-76 to be lost this year.

Is there any quality oversight for Cargo jets in Russia?
 
Is there any quality oversight for Cargo jets in Russia?

Yes and No while the Russian Air Force does an alright job on certain stuff in general most of the Russian Air Force is in need of major over haul. As far as the Civilian stuff well it's hit or miss. Let's put it this way I would never get on anything Russian Builded Airliner stuff.
 
Yes and No while the Russian Air Force does an alright job on certain stuff in general most of the Russian Air Force is in need of major over haul. As far as the Civilian stuff well it's hit or miss. Let's put it this way I would never get on anything Russian Builded Airliner stuff.

I am not shedding any tears for the Russians who dies since I do not wish to be a hypocrit. I do agree that I also would not fly on anything built by Russia, the old defunct Soviet Union, or for that matter any former Svoviet Republic's aircraft.
 
I am not shedding any tears for the Russians who dies since I do not wish to be a hypocrit. I do agree that I also would not fly on anything built by Russia, the old defunct Soviet Union, or for that matter any former Svoviet Republic's aircraft.

Oh don't get me wrong the Russian build some rugged aircraft, but you need to keep them up. I've got a few hours in both Mig-15 and 17s but mind you these are ex Polish and Chinese aircraft. The best Warsaw build aircraft are from Poland and Romania pure craftmens involved in these Countries.

My Dad used to own a An-2 that came out of East Germany not the best thing going but you couldn't kill it trust me I tried a few times :shock:;)
 
Oh don't get me wrong the Russian build some rugged aircraft, but you need to keep them up. I've got a few hours in both Mig-15 and 17s but mind you these are ex Polish and Chinese aircraft. The best Warsaw build aircraft are from Poland and Romania pure craftmens involved in these Countries.

My Dad used to own a An-2 that came out of East Germany not the best thing going but you couldn't kill it trust me I tried a few times :shock:;)

I did not think that the Soviets let the Poles or the Roumanians build MIGS. Even on licnse. I do believe that the Poles were allowed to build some training and light utility and light transport aircraft. The Czecks were allowed to build training aircraft that I know.

I know that the ChiComs were allowed to build MIG -15'S and Mig 17's .

I will check on the Czechs and see what the POLES did. I will be very surprised if the Poles were allowed to build MIGS.
 
Oh don't get me wrong the Russian build some rugged aircraft, but you need to keep them up. I've got a few hours in both Mig-15 and 17s but mind you these are ex Polish and Chinese aircraft. The best Warsaw build aircraft are from Poland and Romania pure craftmens involved in these Countries.

My Dad used to own a An-2 that came out of East Germany not the best thing going but you couldn't kill it trust me I tried a few times :shock:;)

I checked and yes not only were the Czechs allowed to build MIGS but Poland and China also. I knew about the ChiComs buut yes I was surprised about Poland !!! Maybe the Soviets did not think that the Poles werea joke.
 
Oh don't get me wrong the Russian build some rugged aircraft, but you need to keep them up. I've got a few hours in both Mig-15 and 17s but mind you these are ex Polish and Chinese aircraft. The best Warsaw build aircraft are from Poland and Romania pure craftmens involved in these Countries.

My Dad used to own a An-2 that came out of East Germany not the best thing going but you couldn't kill it trust me I tried a few times :shock:;)

The An-2 are you talking about the Antonov An-2 that was from the Antonov design bureau in Kiyiv ( once know by the name Kiev).
 
Last edited:
The An-2 are you talking about the Antonov An-2 that was from the Antonov design bureau in Kiyiv ( once know by the name Kiev).

yep the one and same the last operational Biplane in the World, you can drive faster then it fly's :shock:
 
I checked and yes not only were the Czechs allowed to build MIGS but Poland and China also. I knew about the ChiComs buut yes I was surprised about Poland !!! Maybe the Soviets did not think that the Poles werea joke.

The Polish Build Migs-15 is consider the best of the Countries that build the 15. They are the one who improved the duel control version by bumping the rear seat up a few inch's giving the instructor a better view.

Most of the Migs were build by WSK-Mielec and went under the code Lim-2/Mig15bis
 
Back
Top Bottom