• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

GOP's Snowe will vote for Democratic health bill

problems insuperable, obstacles to obamacare:

1. it creates incentives for employers to drop coverage

2. folks then will buy for themselves, their expenses capped at 13% of income

3. the govt is to pick up the balance, exploding the deficit

4. it lets the young and healthy off the hook by lowering the fines on those who refuse to insure themselves, skyrocketing premiums for the sick and elderly

5. it puts unmanageable mandates on to the states, ask feinstein and reid

6. it criminalizes the uninsured, just like driving is handled in CA

7. it cuts medicare and medicaid a half a tril

8. it scores 10 years of revenues and only 7 years of cost

9. it generalizes funding for abortion, ask the catholic bishops

10. its enforcements against the inclusion of illegals is weak

11. it puts terrible taxes on small business, incubus of job creation, in the midst of our deperession

12. it taxes the rich

13. it taxes benefit packages, offending 170 letter signers in pelosi's place

14. no tort reform, no addressing of "defensive medicine" costs

15. no purchasing plans across state lines

16. it leaves 25 million uncovered

17. it taxes makers of medical devices, sure to increase the costs of hearing aids, wheelchairs, prosthetic hips...

18. the difficulty of merging baucus and HELP appears impossible to overcome

19. the nuclear option, senate reconciliation, is off the table after 10-15, thursday, day after tomorrow

20. progressives in the house are pissed at baucus and snowe, they want a public option, they are revolted by the taxing of benefits (unionists)

21. too much has been given to entice the flirtatious senator from maine

22. bluedogs are irate over the cramming of PO into 3200, and abortion

23. house/senate reconciliation is gonna be a bitch

24. insurance companies will run massive ad campaigns ala harry and louise, which killed hillary-care last time

25. it attemps salary controls on insurance industry employees, possibly extra-constitutionally

26. there are constitutional questions as well concerning the mandates on individuals

27. but i'm not interested in supreme court issues, i'm talking the politics, on both floors

28. since employers are practically encouraged to drop their plans, the president's promise that you can keep what you like rings hollow

29. leadership is lost---across the board tax increases are now in writing, in violation of the central tenet of the campaign; the taxing of benefits; the unkeepability of packages folks are satisfied with; etc

30. the "day after decision dictum," which states: at all places and all times thru history, when nations are faced with crisis the human reaction is teeth gnashing and hair tearing, what should we do, what should we do---UNTIL leadership takes steps---then, instantly, within 24 hours, all indecision is replaced with certainty, even anger---it's called REACTION

31. snowe came along in committee (LOL!) simply to maintain her relevance, ask msnbc's lawrence odonnell, former chief of staff of senate finance back in 1993

32. finding massive savings in M&M in waste, fraud and abuse---why wait, if it's so doable to trim it out, then trim it out NOW, why does the party require a bill?

33. cbo's scoring of baucus depends on downward re-schedulings of medicare outlays, a promise that's been mandated every year for a decade and always put off, or so says elmendorf

34. pelosi has been working on and making massive changes to 3200 in a closet, secretly, reid will now do the same to merge baucus and HELP, the body of the party and the entire public is being frozen out

35. thirty dem senators refused to sign a letter to reid demanding the PO, yet leadership is insistent on forcing it in

that's a lot of trouble spelled out

most dp LIBS don't support most of the stuff above

how do YOU feel about half trillion dollar cuts to M&M?

how do you think mr conrad's and ms lincoln's constituents feel?

screwing with seniors is suicide in american politics

baucus is the lowest threshold

congrats on not being officially killed, quite, yet

encoding into law even one third of the 35 points above spells the doom of the democratic party

have at it
 
Last edited:
I'm AMAZINGLY surprised.

Olympia Snowe, vote for ****ty legislation that is as far from republican and conservative in principle as possible?

I'd NEVER imagine.

She makes John McCain look like Barry Goldwater.

Sadly its the state of affairs in the north east that its generally extreme liberal democrats vs liberal republicans. Kind of like choosing between a shot in the groin and a shot in the foot. I don't want my foot having a bullet hole in it but by god I'm not choosing the other place.

The plan for this has been obvious from the start. Get it to committee, throw in the stuff that people don't want in one side of the house, and get it shoved through after that point so they can say they didn't really "Vote" for it at first. Only good thing is it takes so long to go into effect maybe it can be repealed before people are actually suckling off the governments teet
 
Last edited:
31. snowe came along in committee (LOL!) simply to maintain her relevance, ask msnbc's lawrence odonnell, former chief of staff of senate finance back in 1993

You know what Prof **** you buddy, first off you have no idea what your talking about when it come's to Sen. Snowe as I ask you in my last post not to go their I'm only going to ask you one more time after that then the kit glove's come off do you understand.
 
I'm AMAZINGLY surprised.

Olympia Snowe, vote for ****ty legislation that is as far from republican and conservative in principle as possible?

I'd NEVER imagine.

She makes John McCain look like Barry Goldwater.

Sadly its the state of affairs in the north east that its generally extreme liberal democrats vs liberal republicans. Kind of like choosing between a shot in the groin and a shot in the foot. I don't want my foot having a bullet hole in it but by god I'm not choosing the other place.


Hey Zpy **** you, you have no idea what the hell your talking about when it comes to Sen. Snowe I suggest you and the rest of you so-called expert to stop now before this esculates to something some of you really don't want. Also since your a Mod I suggest you go and read the pm I sent to the Mods on this subject and underssand that I will not back down you will have ot ban me right now understand me.
 
Clearly you don't know much about Maine Politics so I suggest you keep your trap shut on this one.

Yea and the thing is no one outside of us Mainers really know how Olympia votes and how she reacts.

You are so out of line Scorpion. :shock: I'm not even going to bother to quote the rest of your rant. These people have every right to comment on the RINO Snowe. I don't care if you're the guy who makes her hair greasy (though I severely doubt you are), you have no business talking to anyone like this. I am a Mainer, and I agree with them.
 
i forgot to mention virginia, 3 weeks from today

it's surely going red, which will terrify centrists, moderates, dogs and red staters

and if new jersey turns the same day, more problematic, admittedly, but a better than even money bet, progressives will also hear the message loud and clear

obamacare has almost no chance, sorry

baucus is low hanging fruit

congrats, tho, on reaching it

political PHYSICS, however, must ultimately prevail

sorry
 
You know what Prof **** you buddy, first off you have no idea what your talking about when it come's to Sen. Snowe as I ask you in my last post not to go their I'm only going to ask you one more time after that then the kit glove's come off do you understand.

ooh, scary

tell it to odonnell

"you're," not "your"

"there," not "their"

4th grade

"kid gloves:" english idiom
 
ooh, scary

tell it to odonnell

"you're," not "your"

"there," not "their"

4th grade

"kid gloves:" english idiom

Paragraphs, second grade.
 
Olympia looks like she has scoliosis. Sandbagger.
 
complete sentences, same thing

obamacare is as good as dead

virginia will kill it

virginia's a bitch

So anybody who shoots the Republican party in the ass is a Bitch?
 
No it didn't you have no idea what your talking about when it come's to Sen. Snowe what it does mean it goes to the floor for debate and mind you Sen. Snowe in the past has done this only to turn around and veto against the items he help get sent to the floor.

You don't want to get into a discussion with me on Olympia you will lose very hard on this topic. Trust Me Prof. this is one area I'm going to ask you not to get into.
You need to calm down. What's the point of sending it to the floor and then voting against it? Does that kill the issue forever?
 
Snowe reiterates opposition to public option, support for triggered public option, and Collins says "... she's open to voting for a sweeping health care overhaul this year. Maine Sen. Susan Collins said Wednesday the status quo is unaccaptable and she shares the goal of passing responsible health care legislation to expand coverage and curb costs."


Read more at: Another GOP senator open to health care overhaul
 
You need to calm down. What's the point of sending it to the floor and then voting against it? Does that kill the issue forever?


She doesn't want to kill the issue, she wants to move the bill forward. Which is probably why she voted for the bill. Same reason Rockerfeller did - move the bill out of committee, and get busy on the hard work of merging with the HELP committee bill and hammering out amendments on the floor of the full Senate, etc etc etc.
 
So why is he getting all nuts because we disagree with Snowe. She's a lamer.
 
Snowe reiterates opposition to public option, support for triggered public option, and Collins says "... she's open to voting for a sweeping health care overhaul this year. Maine Sen. Susan Collins said Wednesday the status quo is unaccaptable and she shares the goal of passing responsible health care legislation to expand coverage and curb costs."


Read more at: Another GOP senator open to health care overhaul



The Plumline says the AP story exaggerated Collins' position:


Susan Collins Open To Supporting Reform Proposal? Her Office Suggests Otherwise

Is Senator Susan Collins open to supporting the health care reform proposal in the Senate?

The Associated Press caused a bit of a stir in Democratic circles this morning by reporting that Collins, the other moderate GOPer from Maine, may be “open” to backing the reform bill, along with Olympia Snowe.

But Collins’ office sends over the statement that the AP story is based on, and it’s very hard to see how the AP reads it this way. If anything, the statement makes it pretty conclusive that she’ll oppose the final proposal.

more ...

Susan Collins Open To Supporting Reform Proposal? Her Office Suggests Otherwise | The Plum Line
 
Back
Top Bottom