• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Officials: Discovery of Weapons Cache Suggests Iranian Meddling in Afghan War

Scorpion89

Banned
Joined
May 29, 2009
Messages
2,629
Reaction score
527
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
Officials: Discovery of Weapons Cache Suggests Iranian Meddling in Afghan War - International News | News of the World | Middle East News | Europe News - FOXNews.com

The discovery of a weapons cache in western Afghanistan has raised concerns that Iran is interfering in the war-torn country, much like it did in Iraq, by supplying weapons used to attack and kill U.S. and coalition troops, U.S. officials tell FOX News.

Afghan and NATO forces uncovered the weapons cache on Aug. 29 in Herat. It included a small number of Iranian-made "explosively formed penetrators," hyper-powerful roadside bombs similar to the weapons used to kill U.S. forces in Iraq, a senior U.S. Defense Official told FOX News.

Also seized during the raid were 107 Iranian-made BM-1 rockets and dozens of blocks of Iranian C4 plastic explosives.

This is a very large problem that needs to be dealt with once and for all. The US and Mr. Obama need to send a very loud message to that idiot in Terhan first the State dept. needs to tell the UN that the Illegal Leader of Iran will not be issued a Visa second we need to start stopping all Iran flagged ships.
 
Officials: Discovery of Weapons Cache Suggests Iranian Meddling in Afghan War - International News | News of the World | Middle East News | Europe News - FOXNews.com

The discovery of a weapons cache in western Afghanistan has raised concerns that Iran is interfering in the war-torn country, much like it did in Iraq, by supplying weapons used to attack and kill U.S. and coalition troops, U.S. officials tell FOX News.

Afghan and NATO forces uncovered the weapons cache on Aug. 29 in Herat. It included a small number of Iranian-made "explosively formed penetrators," hyper-powerful roadside bombs similar to the weapons used to kill U.S. forces in Iraq, a senior U.S. Defense Official told FOX News.

Also seized during the raid were 107 Iranian-made BM-1 rockets and dozens of blocks of Iranian C4 plastic explosives.

This is a very large problem that needs to be dealt with once and for all. The US and Mr. Obama need to send a very loud message to that idiot in Terhan first the State dept. needs to tell the UN that the Illegal Leader of Iran will not be issued a Visa second we need to start stopping all Iran flagged ships.

Ugh, another reason to attack, and kill their leadership, and put in place some competents.
 
Somehow, the idea that Iran is meddling over there just does not surprise me.
 
That's plenty of justification for bombing Tehran into dust.
 
That's plenty of justification for bombing Tehran into dust.

Maybe just bombing it, we should kill their leaders, and put in Mousavie or whatever his name was, and take out Amadinejad.
 
Maybe just bombing it, we should kill their leaders, and put in Mousavie or whatever his name was, and take out Amadinejad.

I couldn't agree more, however targetting national leaders is illegal. Therefore, we must target the citizenry and hope Ahamdenijad gets caught up in the mix.
 
I don't think bombing is the answer at this time. I think we need to try diplomacy, and then when it fails(it probably will), do targeted bombings.
 
That.s why I said the first thing we should do is denie him a Visa and then go from their.
 
I don't think bombing is the answer at this time. I think we need to try diplomacy, and then when it fails(it probably will), do targeted bombings.

I think it's obvious that diplomacy isn't going to work with Iran's leadership.
 
I couldn't agree more, however targetting national leaders is illegal. Therefore, we must target the citizenry and hope Ahamdenijad gets caught up in the mix.

Honestly, f*** that s***. They don't obey the rules of war, using phosphorus on our troops, we shouldn't have to follow the rules upon the people giving them the phosphorous
 
I think it's obvious that diplomacy isn't going to work with Iran's leadership.

I don't think it will either, but I think we have to make the attempt. Every so often, surprising things do happen.
 
Honestly, f*** that s***. They don't obey the rules of war, using phosphorus on our troops, we shouldn't have to follow the rules upon the people giving them the phosphorous

Exactly what you are talking about? We use phosphorous all the time, its not a war crime.

I don't see a good solution to problem. As much as it might make you feel better, attacking Iran isn't going to stop the weapon flow. The likely response would actually be to increase the number of weapons shipped. Diplomacy is unlikely to succeed, but its costs nothing to try, so it is worth the attempt.
The best option would be to blockade the border with soldiers, but we don't have the manpower with soldiers tied up in Iraq. Using the CIA to straw purchase the weapons might work, but I doubt we have assets capable of pulling it off. For the time being, it looks like we are just going to have to handle the deadlier weapons.
 
I don't think bombing is the answer at this time. I think we need to try diplomacy, and then when it fails(it probably will), do targeted bombings.

Diplomacy doesn't work with terrorists. Therefore, diplomacy with Iran is doomed to fail.

:doh
 
Officials: Discovery of Weapons Cache Suggests Iranian Meddling in Afghan War - International News | News of the World | Middle East News | Europe News - FOXNews.com

The discovery of a weapons cache in western Afghanistan has raised concerns that Iran is interfering in the war-torn country, much like it did in Iraq, by supplying weapons used to attack and kill U.S. and coalition troops, U.S. officials tell FOX News.

Afghan and NATO forces uncovered the weapons cache on Aug. 29 in Herat. It included a small number of Iranian-made "explosively formed penetrators," hyper-powerful roadside bombs similar to the weapons used to kill U.S. forces in Iraq, a senior U.S. Defense Official told FOX News.

Also seized during the raid were 107 Iranian-made BM-1 rockets and dozens of blocks of Iranian C4 plastic explosives.

This is a very large problem that needs to be dealt with once and for all. The US and Mr. Obama need to send a very loud message to that idiot in Terhan first the State dept. needs to tell the UN that the Illegal Leader of Iran will not be issued a Visa second we need to start stopping all Iran flagged ships.

The most amazing thing about this news is how LITTLE play it is getting. Why do you think that is? :cool:
 
I don't think it will either, but I think we have to make the attempt. Every so often, surprising things do happen.

We've already made the attempt. American soldiers are dieing, now. The time for talk is over.
 
Wait, I thought the Iranians weren't looking for trouble and that the War on Terrorism is over.
 
I couldn't agree more, however targetting national leaders is illegal. Therefore, we must target the citizenry and hope Ahamdenijad gets caught up in the mix.

Didn't really stop us in Iraq.

And for the love of Christ here, how many more undeclared, occupational wars do you want to get us into? Of course Iran is doing ****, we're ****ing around in their backyard. If say communist Russia was waring in Mexico or Canada, you think we wouldn't do anything? Iran's probably scarred that they're on the list of what to take out next, not without cause either. Why would anyone be surprised that they are aiding our enemies when they view us as the enemy?
 
Didn't really stop us in Iraq.

And for the love of Christ here, how many more undeclared, occupational wars do you want to get us into? Of course Iran is doing ****, we're ****ing around in their backyard. If say communist Russia was waring in Mexico or Canada, you think we wouldn't do anything? Iran's probably scarred that they're on the list of what to take out next, not without cause either. Why would anyone be surprised that they are aiding our enemies when they view us as the enemy?

And if we did something when Russia was waring in Mexico, we could expect a response from Russia in retaliation. Just ike Iran should be prepared fo our response for killing American soldiers.
 
Didn't really stop us in Iraq.

And for the love of Christ here, how many more undeclared, occupational wars do you want to get us into? Of course Iran is doing ****, we're ****ing around in their backyard. If say communist Russia was waring in Mexico or Canada, you think we wouldn't do anything? Iran's probably scarred that they're on the list of what to take out next, not without cause either. Why would anyone be surprised that they are aiding our enemies when they view us as the enemy?

What I find fascinating about this rationalizing about a despotic nation that has a history of violating even the most basic diplomatic practice, taking over an embassy, is that it ignores facts:

(1) The USA does not have a history of invading nations that have not violated another nation’s sovereignty nor does it have a history of occupying nations in an effort to expand an imperialist agenda regardless of the emotional hysterics of those who claim we do.

(2) Iran is rightfully concerned as it is a rogue nation that it is in defiance of its own agreements and is under sanctions for those violations.

(3) Iran is rightfully concerned because it is illegally arming terrorists to blow up UN peace keepers attempting to restore order in Iraq and Afghanistan which is in direct violation of legitimacy for any nation.

The ONLY reason for Iran to act in this way is that it is indeed a ROGUE nation that promotes TERRORISM. If Iran abided by international standards and rescinded its efforts to produce enriched uranium, which has only ONE purpose, it would have ZERO to fear from ANYONE.

But alas, people like you prefer the absurd rationale that it is OUR actions in Iraq and Afghanistan that “provokes” such irrational paranoid behavior instead of the rogue actions of that nation.

It is as asinine as suggesting that the reason our troops are dying is because Bush sent them there instead of the efforts of the thugs, despots and terrorists who are doing the killing and who offer NOTHING to those they murder other than more of the same while we are fighting for their freedom to elect their own representative governments.

:doh
 
(1) The USA does not have a history of invading nations that have not violated another nation’s sovereignty nor does it have a history of occupying nations in an effort to expand an imperialist agenda regardless of the emotional hysterics of those who claim we do.

Well there is the second Iraq war. And of course, all the death squad/black ops sort of thing we did back in the day, particularly the 60's-80's. And of course, we are currently occupying Iraq. But yeah...besides a few decades of our most recent behavior...we're good one that point.

Also...the first Iraq war, Iraq attacked Kuwait because they were side drilling into Iraqi territory. Of course, that does not justify invasion; but it's not like Saddam woke up one day and was like, "You know...today is a good day to invade Kuwait!".

(2) Iran is rightfully concerned as it is a rogue nation that it is in defiance of its own agreements and is under sanctions for those violations.

They are rightfully concerned because they saw us just **** up two countries, and one for no good legitimate reason. They've never been terribly friendly with us, they know we're kinda looking for reasons. They want us out of the region and out of their hair. Understandable I say. I wouldn't want other people over here ****ing with my **** and trying to use military force to make me obey their will.

(3) Iran is rightfully concerned because it is illegally arming terrorists to blow up UN peace keepers attempting to restore order in Iraq and Afghanistan which is in direct violation of legitimacy for any nation.

Of course they're arming the terrorists. The enemy of my enemy is my friend. And we did it too, Iran Contra mean anything to you? ****, we trained those terrorists in the ME to fight the terrorists the Russians were training. The whole of that area is messed up due to the Western intervention for decades upon decades. They don't hate us for our freedom or any other bull**** like that. The region hates the west because we've ****ed with them for so long.

The ONLY reason for Iran to act in this way is that it is indeed a ROGUE nation that promotes TERRORISM. If Iran abided by international standards and rescinded its efforts to produce enriched uranium, which has only ONE purpose, it would have ZERO to fear from ANYONE.

No, we took that one away with Iraq II. People best fear us, we can and will eliminate countries and governments if we don't like. That's the lesson to the governments in that area from Iraq II.

But alas, people like you prefer the absurd rationale that it is OUR actions in Iraq and Afghanistan that “provokes” such irrational paranoid behavior instead of the rogue actions of that nation.

It is as asinine as suggesting that the reason our troops are dying is because Bush sent them there instead of the efforts of the thugs, despots and terrorists who are doing the killing and who offer NOTHING to those they murder other than more of the same while we are fighting for their freedom to elect their own representative governments.

:doh

But alas, people like you prefer to ignore history and consequence and use abusrd rationale that they hate us for our freedom or other crap. Pretending instead that the US has had a stellar history full of doing nothing wrong and that our interventionist policies cannot possibly have consequence or blowback.

It is as asinine as suggesting that the reason our troops are dying is because we are fighting for the democracy of another country instead of there for personal reasons and trying to establish a foothold in an area where we don't belong.
 
And if we did something when Russia was waring in Mexico, we could expect a response from Russia in retaliation. Just ike Iran should be prepared fo our response for killing American soldiers.

Fair enough, and in our scenario Russia most likely had no legitimate reason to be in Mexico or Canada. We had legitimate reason to be in Afghanistan, it's just that we shouldn't be surprised that the people we've pissed off the most and have very poor relations with are helping the people we're fighting. The enemy of my enemy is my friend sort of thing.
 
Fair enough, and in our scenario Russia most likely had no legitimate reason to be in Mexico or Canada. We had legitimate reason to be in Afghanistan, it's just that we shouldn't be surprised that the people we've pissed off the most and have very poor relations with are helping the people we're fighting. The enemy of my enemy is my friend sort of thing.

I'm not surprised, at all. Alls I'm saying, is that it's time to retaliate against Iran. I say we drop a few thousand tons of munitions on Tehran, then see if they're willing to bow out of the war in Afghanistan.
 
I'm not surprised, at all. Alls I'm saying, is that it's time to retaliate against Iran. I say we drop a few thousand tons of munitions on Tehran, then see if they're willing to bow out of the war in Afghanistan.

I don't know if that's a good solution. We've been at war over there for what...like 8 years now. I don't know if starting another war with another country in the same area is going to do anything good for us. Besides bog us down even further. It just seems like there's always call for more and more war, and perpetual warfare is not going to do us any good. Not for our people, our liberty, or our economy.
 
I don't know if that's a good solution. We've been at war over there for what...like 8 years now. I don't know if starting another war with another country in the same area is going to do anything good for us. Besides bog us down even further. It just seems like there's always call for more and more war, and perpetual warfare is not going to do us any good. Not for our people, our liberty, or our economy.

it'll be a good oppurtunity to kill more jihadists. I don't see how that can be a negative. I doubt anyone is going to complain if the mullahs are removed.
 
it'll be a good oppurtunity to kill more jihadists. I don't see how that can be a negative. I doubt anyone is going to complain if the mullahs are removed.

First off, in the process of killing jihadists we're going to take out many civilians. Second, the culture in the ME most amicable towards western style republic is most probably Iran. They have the demographics and education for it, I think it can be more highly encouraged there and adopted there than any other country in the ME. Now, of course there is theocratic control right now; but just outright bombing the country and killing civilians may not be the way to foster better relations which can lead to the establishment of a democratic republic. Third, does this end? A good opportunity to kill more jihadists...but you'll make more by doing so. You're just playing out the propaganda they purport. Fourth, does this end? Perpetual warfare is not good, it will not lead to nice places; it puts our people, our liberty, our economy at risk.

I think we have to start thinking of consequences of our actions before we just start acting out. We are not on a sustainable road here and it's very important to realize that.
 
Back
Top Bottom