• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Specter: Protests not 'representative of America'

ReverendHellh0und

I don't respect you.
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 13, 2007
Messages
79,903
Reaction score
20,981
Location
I love your hate.
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian
Specter: Protests not 'representative of America


WASHINGTON – Sen. Arlen Specter said Wednesday he thinks people who have been angrily disrupting town hall meetings on overhauling the health care system are "not necessarily representative of America," but should be heard.

"It's more than health care," said Specter, 79, who earlier this year left the Republican Party and became a Democrat. "I think there is a mood in America of anger with so many people unemployed, with so much bickering in Washington ... with the fear of losing their health care. It all boils over."

Specter and Sen. Claire McCaskill, a Missouri Democrat, appeared on a nationally broadcast news show Wednesday, a day after town hall meetings they hosted erupted in the same kind of catcalls, jeers and shouting that has characterized many such forums in recent weeks. "There were a couple of tough moments," McCaskill said of her experience, "but it lasted two hours and there were thousands of people there."




Seriously, If you want to save face in regards to attacking town hall citizens making thier voice heard, you should at least be honest:


A new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey shows that opposition to the plan has increased to 53%, up nine points since late June.

Support for Congressional Health Care Reform Falls to New Low - Rasmussen Reports



Most Americans Mr. Specter are against the plan. They are more "repesentative of America" than you and your ilk.
 
How dare people question The Obama and His plan?
 
Most Americans Mr. Specter are against the plan. They are more "repesentative of America" than you and your ilk.

53% (many misinformed) does not equal 'Most'.

We live in a Republic with democratic elections. What Americas 'want' is represented by the current make-up of the House and the Senate. I want more of a balance and will cast future votes accordingly.

We don't live in a direct democracy--I'm not sure everyone attending these Town Halls understand this.
 
53% (many misinformed) does not equal 'Most'


it is more "most" than the 26% (many misinformed) that strongly support it...


We live in a Republic with democratic elections. What Americas 'want' is represented by the current make-up of the House and the Senate. I want more of a balance and will cast future votes accordingly.

We don't live in a direct democracy--I'm not sure everyone attending these Town Halls understand this.


This is unfair, no one is suggesting "direct democracy", they are "petitioning the government for redress", and are directly petitioing thier representatives for grievenses....


Its right there in the constitution....



I am much more concerned with Obama using an 8 year old to elicit an emotional response in a fake "town hall meeting" he was holding.
 
The wacko fringe that are showing up disrupting these meetings are not representative of America. They are representative of the same wacko fringe that Sarah Palin used to attract.

The public overwhelmingly was in favor of healthcare reform until the insurance companies and the right-wing radio nuts began their campaign of distortions (ala...death panels and kill granny).

The right-wing once again has shown that they are very very good at using the politics of fear and distortion to sway that segment of the population that doesn't educate themselves and can be influenced with 10 second sound bites.

We will get healthcare reform....despite the efforts of the insurance corporations. The only question will be whether it will be meaningful change or just a bandaid.
 
The wacko fringe that are showing up disrupting these meetings are not representative of America. They are representative of the same wacko fringe that Sarah Palin used to attract.

The public overwhelmingly was in favor of healthcare reform until the insurance companies and the right-wing radio nuts began their campaign of distortions (ala...death panels and kill granny).

The right-wing once again has shown that they are very very good at using the politics of fear and distortion to sway that segment of the population that doesn't educate themselves and can be influenced with 10 second sound bites.

We will get healthcare reform....despite the efforts of the insurance corporations. The only question will be whether it will be meaningful change or just a bandaid.



Gotta love when the fringe left resorts to lies and slander as they get desparate.


Obama care is currently less popular than hilary care was. This will not pass. and that is GOOD for America.
 
The wacko fringe that are showing up disrupting these meetings are not representative of America.
Their anti-health-care-plan position is. That the majority of the majority of Americans that oppose it are not as vocal as these people doesn't change that.

The public overwhelmingly was in favor of healthcare reform until the insurance companies and the right-wing radio nuts began their campaign of distortions (ala...death panels and kill granny).
Prove that these things had any effect whatesoever.
That is, show the causal relationship rather than simple correlation.

The right-wing once again has shown that they are very very good at using the politics of fear and distortion to sway that segment of the population that doesn't educate themselves...
Like the left does with global warming or guns or Social Security or any number of other things... right?
 
Seriously, If you want to save face in regards to attacking town hall citizens making thier voice heard, you should at least be honest:


A new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey shows that opposition to the plan has increased to 53%, up nine points since late June.

Support for Congressional Health Care Reform Falls to New Low - Rasmussen Reports



Most Americans Mr. Specter are against the plan. They are more "repesentative of America" than you and your ilk.

So you are saying most people support disrupting town hall meetings? Or did you misunderstand his point? Or, most likely, are you just misrepresenting what he said?

I also noticed you did not include this quote from him:

"These people have a right to be organized," the senator said on CBS's "The Early Show."
 
Gotta love when the fringe left resorts to lies and slander as they get desparate.


Obama care is currently less popular than hilary care was. This will not pass. and that is GOOD for America.

Seriously Rev....Do you believe the death panels and Kill Granny B.S?

Seriously.
 
Seriously Rev....Do you believe the death panels and Kill Granny B.S?

Seriously.



Obama Says Grandmother?s Hip Replacement Raises Cost Questions - Bloomberg.com




Oregon health plan covers assisted suicide, not drugs, for cancer patient (if you need another source, just ask)



You tell me. Honestly we don't know what we would get. But to say that what you posted is impossible, I have just proved wrong.



That said, I have cash, I have equity, I will provide for myself no matter what happens. My opposition to this is my love for my country.
 
The wacko fringe that are showing up disrupting these meetings are not representative of America. They are representative of the same wacko fringe that Sarah Palin used to attract.
So 53% of the Rasmussen poll, which is a cross sampling of the United States public is now a fringe? Is that what you want to go on record as stating?

The public overwhelmingly was in favor of healthcare reform until the insurance companies and the right-wing radio nuts began their campaign of distortions (ala...death panels and kill granny).
No, it wasn't, it UHC never polled over 49% in favor if my memory serves correctly, and if you'd care to read what is happening in countries with plans similar to the one proposed you would see that it is hardly a distortion.

The right-wing once again has shown that they are very very good at using the politics of fear and distortion to sway that segment of the population that doesn't educate themselves and can be influenced with 10 second sound bites.
Oh Bull ****! People can read the bill that the house passed for themselves and there exists a ton of gray area that is more than open for the exact abuses your side wants to call distortions.

We will get healthcare reform....despite the efforts of the insurance corporations. The only question will be whether it will be meaningful change or just a bandaid.
First off, it's not looking good for the current bill, which isn't reform, if they don't get the bill, which isn't reform by the break, the chances of the non-reform reform bill passing are slim. Also, it is NOT insurance company efforts bringing these people who want reform(not the current bill) to these meetings, it's the politicians mis-representing this effort as "reform" and the lack of real reform bringing these people out, and then calling these same concerned citizens nazis, and a mob is pissing them off, which will pretty much kill the non-reform "reform" bill if it isn't dead already.
 
53% (many misinformed) does not equal 'Most'.

We live in a Republic with democratic elections. What Americas 'want' is represented by the current make-up of the House and the Senate. I want more of a balance and will cast future votes accordingly.

We don't live in a direct democracy--I'm not sure everyone attending these Town Halls understand this.

It appears that one thing you posted is exactly right. That being the (many misinformed) portion. However those who seem to be most misinformed are those of you who haven't bothered to read HR-3200 along with people like Specter who are not showing a great deal of intelligence by attempting to support a program they clearly know little or nothing about.
I realize it takes time to read it, but you might wish to take the time to do so rather than ape Obama's views that only serve to make some look uninformed or worse lacking the intelligence to recognize it for what it truly is.

Specter is right Americans are mad, and it's because of the forcing of extremest Socialist programs and take overs on a Nation Obama promised to destroy on March 15th 2008, When he said: "My friends, we live in the greatest nation in the history of the world. I hope you'll join with me as we try to change it".
He's doing everything he can to do that and Specter and others are helping it come true.
 
Last edited:
Obama Says Grandmother?s Hip Replacement Raises Cost Questions - Bloomberg.com




Oregon health plan covers assisted suicide, not drugs, for cancer patient (if you need another source, just ask)



You tell me. Honestly we don't know what we would get. But to say that what you posted is impossible, I have just proved wrong.



That said, I have cash, I have equity, I will provide for myself no matter what happens. My opposition to this is my love for my country.

From your first link:

Obama said “you just get into some very difficult moral issues” when considering whether “to give my grandmother, or everybody else’s aging grandparents or parents, a hip replacement when they’re terminally ill.

Does not say he is setting up death panels or plans to kill granny.

Second link is about Oregon, not the US.
 
From your first link:



Does not say he is setting up death panels or plans to kill granny.

Second link is about Oregon, not the US.




My point is that these claims are fact, my point is, they are not made up or impossible, what I have shown, is that these things are being considered in order to make UHC work.


It's being discussed. so stating that its made up, is in itself, well made up.
 
My point is that these claims are fact, my point is, they are not made up or impossible, what I have shown, is that these things are being considered in order to make UHC work.


It's being discussed. so stating that its made up, is in itself, well made up.

Your claims are not fact. There is no death panel, there is not plan to kill granny. If legislation is started in favor of either, then talk about it, but talking about the current plan with those terms is misleading, and intentionally so.

Also, please go back to my first post in this thread. You misrepresented what Spectre said. Please defend it.
 
Your claims are not fact. There is no death panel, there is not plan to kill granny. If legislation is started in favor of either, then talk about it, but talking about the current plan with those terms is misleading, and intentionally so.

Also, please go back to my first post in this thread. You misrepresented what Spectre said. Please defend it.



:lol: I meant it was fact that it was being discussed, not that Obama or the house is ACTUALLY pushing for it.

We do not know what obama's plan is, he is relying on the house and senate to come up with it... There are some very scary provisions that can lead to some of this nastiness coming true...

Furthermore, my links show, it is on the table, and has happened in the past... That is the point, not that they ARE GOING TO DO IT, but that these things are not impossible like many on the left are claiming.



I did not misrepresent what he said. That is misleading, and intentionally so. ;)
 
So you are saying most people support disrupting town hall meetings? Or did you misunderstand his point? Or, most likely, are you just misrepresenting what he said?

I also noticed you did not include this quote from him:




Strawman.


He claimed that they do not represent America, I have clearly shown him to be wrong, most likley deliberatly so.
 
Your claims are not fact. There is no death panel, there is not plan to kill granny. If legislation is started in favor of either, then talk about it, but talking about the current plan with those terms is misleading, and intentionally so.
I can't find the link at the moment, but there was an event where Obama tried to deflect when a guy was talking about his 101 year old parent who got a pacemaker when the second surgeon determined that the person obviously wanted to live, after the first surgeon said the parent was too old. Obama said something that was callous, something to the effect of the parent would need to realize that they were done with life or along those lines.
 
I can't find the link at the moment, but there was an event where Obama tried to deflect when a guy was talking about his 101 year old parent who got a pacemaker when the second surgeon determined that the person obviously wanted to live, after the first surgeon said the parent was too old. Obama said something that was callous, something to the effect of the parent would need to realize that they were done with life or along those lines.
I recall this incident as well.
 
:lol: I meant it was fact that it was being discussed, not that Obama or the house is ACTUALLY pushing for it.

We do not know what obama's plan is, he is relying on the house and senate to come up with it... There are some very scary provisions that can lead to some of this nastiness coming true...

Furthermore, my links show, it is on the table, and has happened in the past... That is the point, not that they ARE GOING TO DO IT, but that these things are not impossible like many on the left are claiming.



I did not misrepresent what he said. That is misleading, and intentionally so. ;)

There is zero evidence that these things have any likelihood to be put into the health care plan currently under consideration. Suggesting otherwise is misleading. You would be quick to call a liberal trying to do something like that.

You did misrepresent his words. Let's look at the quote.

Sen. Arlen Specter said Wednesday he thinks people who have been angrily disrupting town hall meetings on overhauling the health care system are "not necessarily representative of America," but should be heard.

Note the bolded part. Not people opposed to the bill, but people disrupting the town hall meetings.
 
Back
Top Bottom