• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Villagers burn girl alive in 'honour killing'

SgtRock

Cancel Cancel Culture and Woke Supremacy
DP Veteran
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
7,025
Reaction score
2,896
Location
Deep in the Heart of Texas
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Conservative
Source: Scotsman
Date: March 24, 2009

A TEENAGE girl was burned to death at her home in India in an "honour killing" by neighbours.
Four residents of her village in Ghaziabad, north India, allegedly set the 16-year-old Muslim girl alight after they suspected her of having a relationship with a boy.

Villagers burn girl alive in 'honour killing' - Scotsman.com News

Four men have been arrested and are being charged with murder. They were asked by the girls father to straighten out his daughter for seeing a boy.

People who do things like this are mentally ill. I know that some of you think that this issue is an obsession of mine. Well you are correct. I must speak out about these stories for they are to often ignored. This girl must not be forgotten. Her name was Imrana.

16-year-old burnt in Gzb honour killing - Lucknow - Cities - The Times of India

2 more in net for Gzb honour killing - Delhi - Cities - The Times of India
 
I felt sick reading that article. WTF is wrong with those guys? And what happened to the supposed boy in the relationship with the girl? I'm sure he was burned alive too. :roll:
 
I feel sick, too. I'm going to go to my new happy place now (a line up window with a gaggle of penises).
 
Sick people. I'm waiting for the Muslim Hate Brigade to roll in here and spew some nonsense.
 
i disagree with teh mentally ill diagnosis in the OP
they just have a twisted view of what is right in the world
unless you consider religion a mental illness
this is just some ****ed up individuals
 
i disagree with teh mentally ill diagnosis in the OP
they just have a twisted view of what is right in the world
unless you consider religion a mental illness
this is just some ****ed up individuals

Some ****ed up individuals. Studies have been done on this. In some countries such as Pakistan, Afghanistan, Jordan, and Kurdistan the majority of people believe that honor killings are necessary to clense a families honor.
 
Some ****ed up individuals. Studies have been done on this. In some countries such as Pakistan, Afghanistan, Jordan, and Kurdistan the majority of people believe that honor killings are necessary to clense a families honor.
absolutely
but bad programing does not equate to mental illness
****ed in the head, sure, but not mentally ill
 
absolutely
but bad programing does not equate to mental illness
****ed in the head, sure, but not mentally ill

Ok, maybe your right. But consider this. If a father and his sons stabbed to death his daughter while the mother held her down, hacked her body to pieces, then set the pieces on fire because she was raped and brought shame on the family would you consider them mentally ill? Isn't ****ed in the head and mental illness one in the same? If they are not ill then what are they? If they are ill then they should recieve treatment in a mental institution. On second thought maybe they should spend the rest of thier lifes in prison.

In 2004 a Christain woman in Plano Texas Dena Schlosser cut off the arms of her baby because she wanted to give her to god. When police arrived she was playing a gospel hymn and singing her body covered in blood and still holding the kitchen knife. Unfortunatly she has been released after treatment in a state mental institution. She has been ordered to see a psychiatrist once a week, take medication, be on a phsycian-approved birth control and not have any unsupervised contact with children.
 
It is funny how SgtRock only shows the Muslim honour killings but does not mention the many other honour killings in the same societies by non muslims.. hypocrite with an agenda? A Muslim hater?
 
It is funny how SgtRock only shows the Muslim honour killings but does not mention the many other honour killings in the same societies by non muslims.. hypocrite with an agenda? A Muslim hater?

Isn't it funny that you can call me a hater and not condemn the monsters that kill there own family members in the most horrible ways. Hindus and muslims commit most all honour killings. If I hated muslims why would I be donating time and money to organizations that are trying to shed light on these atrocities and stop honour killings of muslim women?
 
It's gotten to the point that honor killings are so common and is brought up so much i have become densensitized to it. I just do not care anymore and that is a sad thing, women who are victims of this will always have my sympathy but so do those children who starve in Africa and raped to remove AIDs.

This is just another set of victims and victims is nothing new to this world.
 
It is funny how SgtRock only shows the Muslim honour killings but does not mention the many other honour killings in the same societies by non muslims.. hypocrite with an agenda? A Muslim hater?




it's funny how our resident savage apologist comes in here to defend honor killings.
 
Isn't it funny that you can call me a hater and not condemn the monsters that kill there own family members in the most horrible ways. Hindus and muslims commit most all honour killings. If I hated muslims why would I be donating time and money to organizations that are trying to shed light on these atrocities and stop honour killings of muslim women?
Hindus? I find that extremely hard to believe. Maybe they call themselves Hindus, but a Hindu would never burn their child.
 
SgtRock posted:
Quote
(If I hated muslims why would I be donating time and money to organizations that are trying to shed light on these atrocities and stop honour killings of muslim women?)

Naturally we only have YOUR word regarding donation of time and money!
 
Ok, maybe your right. But consider this. If a father and his sons stabbed to death his daughter while the mother held her down, hacked her body to pieces, then set the pieces on fire because she was raped and brought shame on the family would you consider them mentally ill? Isn't ****ed in the head and mental illness one in the same? If they are not ill then what are they? If they are ill then they should recieve treatment in a mental institution. On second thought maybe they should spend the rest of thier lifes in prison.

In 2004 a Christain woman in Plano Texas Dena Schlosser cut off the arms of her baby because she wanted to give her to god. When police arrived she was playing a gospel hymn and singing her body covered in blood and still holding the kitchen knife. Unfortunatly she has been released after treatment in a state mental institution. She has been ordered to see a psychiatrist once a week, take medication, be on a phsycian-approved birth control and not have any unsupervised contact with children.
i see a huge difference between mental illness and religious beliefs

btut thats just me, or maybe not just me
 
Isn't it funny that you can call me a hater and not condemn the monsters that kill there own family members in the most horrible ways.

I have, in every thread I have chosen to reply and correct you for your words and hypocrisy.

But lets do it one more time. I condemn narrow-minded morons who have traditions that accept the murder of anyone based on honour.

Hindus and muslims commit most all honour killings.

Ahh now you mention another religion than Islam.

But why dont you mention the honour killings in India more? There are far more reported there, both officially and unofficially there than any where else. Women are burned, have thrown acid in their faces because their "husbands'" family was offended by the size of her dowery and so on? You do know that honour punishment is ripe and very well entrenched in especially the poor parts of Indian society right? And here in fact it is illegal, and yet the police and the legal system in the local community not only protect but often participate in the acts of violence against women..

If I hated muslims why would I be donating time and money to organizations that are trying to shed light on these atrocities and stop honour killings of muslim women?

Good for you, but it does not change the fact that your whole focus in almost every thread is about the Islamic world and how "bad" it is.

If you were at all remotely non partisan you would not constantly be drawing out the "islamic" part of the killing, because as anyone with half a brain and even remote knowledge of honour killings and punishment knows... honour killings have NOTHING to do with Islam and everything to do with ancient traditions in the local society.

Yes honour killings are horrible, as are 12 year old forced bribes, women being punished with acid and burning, and so on, but it is not religiously based but by tradition.

It is like saying that the freaks of that compound in Texas (the mormon one) that abuse their girls at young age is a "Christian" thing, when it is in fact a warped tradition found by a bunch of paedophiles centuries ago.

It is like saying that all Muslims practice female genitalia mutilation just because a bunch of areas in Northern Africa think it is part of their faith but in reality is an ancient tradition brought down from the pre Islamic times.

It is like saying that all Christians still practice witch burning because the evangelical Christians of Nigeria and the area burn young girls for witchcraft.
 
Hindus? I find that extremely hard to believe. Maybe they call themselves Hindus, but a Hindu would never burn their child.

It use to be quite common that the wife of a dead man was burned on the funeral pyre with him... burned alive.
 
Source: Scotsman
Date: March 24, 2009



Villagers burn girl alive in 'honour killing' - Scotsman.com News

Four men have been arrested and are being charged with murder. They were asked by the girls father to straighten out his daughter for seeing a boy.

People who do things like this are mentally ill. I know that some of you think that this issue is an obsession of mine. Well you are correct. I must speak out about these stories for they are to often ignored. This girl must not be forgotten. Her name was Imrana.

16-year-old burnt in Gzb honour killing - Lucknow - Cities - The Times of India

2 more in net for Gzb honour killing - Delhi - Cities - The Times of India

That will teach her, last time she will let her self get raped. see this is why women should remain covered.

True, but at least she brought honor to her family .. one small step.
 
Last edited:
I have, in every thread I have chosen to reply and correct you for your words and hypocrisy.

But lets do it one more time. I condemn narrow-minded morons who have traditions that accept the murder of anyone based on honour.



Ahh now you mention another religion than Islam.

But why dont you mention the honour killings in India more? There are far more reported there, both officially and unofficially there than any where else. Women are burned, have thrown acid in their faces because their "husbands'" family was offended by the size of her dowery and so on? You do know that honour punishment is ripe and very well entrenched in especially the poor parts of Indian society right? And here in fact it is illegal, and yet the police and the legal system in the local community not only protect but often participate in the acts of violence against women..



Good for you, but it does not change the fact that your whole focus in almost every thread is about the Islamic world and how "bad" it is.

If you were at all remotely non partisan you would not constantly be drawing out the "islamic" part of the killing, because as anyone with half a brain and even remote knowledge of honour killings and punishment knows... honour killings have NOTHING to do with Islam and everything to do with ancient traditions in the local society.

Yes honour killings are horrible, as are 12 year old forced bribes, women being punished with acid and burning, and so on, but it is not religiously based but by tradition.

It is like saying that the freaks of that compound in Texas (the mormon one) that abuse their girls at young age is a "Christian" thing, when it is in fact a warped tradition found by a bunch of paedophiles centuries ago.

It is like saying that all Muslims practice female genitalia mutilation just because a bunch of areas in Northern Africa think it is part of their faith but in reality is an ancient tradition brought down from the pre Islamic times.

It is like saying that all Christians still practice witch burning because the evangelical Christians of Nigeria and the area burn young girls for witchcraft.




notice how pete likes to bash christians in a thread where christianity is not the topic.


notice how pete wants to play protect the savage in order to attack sgt rock.
 




"Why don't you have a seat over there?"

chris_hansen.gif
 
Back
Top Bottom