- Joined
- Jan 5, 2007
- Messages
- 9,349
- Reaction score
- 3,947
- Location
- Montana
- Gender
- Female
- Political Leaning
- Undisclosed
He's not. It's amazing how many people rely on this trick of arguing that another poster is absurdly comparing x to z.
He's stretching the logic that says if homosexuality is a genetic trait then we must allow/tolerate/accept ~insert behavior~. If that is the case, then what other genetic traits must compel us to allow/tolerate/accept ~insert behavior~.
The poster is not suggesting that drug use, theft are analogous to homsoexuality. He is suggesting that if you're going to argue that the genetic basis for homosexuality requires us to allow/tolerate/accept gay marriage or any other activity, then you must apply that logic consistently and that would have absurd results such as allowing/tolerating/accepting crime because someone may be genetically predisposed to committing crime.
Get it?
That may be, but he is comparing them as negative behaviors and has yet to offer why homosexuality, like doing drugs and stealing, is a negative behavior.