• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

VA Secretary Bob McDonald Likens VA Wait Times to Wating in Line at Disney World

I remind you of Lincoln's words: "a government of the people, by the people and for the people" which translates in you, your brother, parents, cousins, friends, neighbors etc being the government by your will. When they fail it is YOUR fault no one else's.

So when government fails, its the average American's fault?

You need to go back and read the Gettysburg Address. That's not what was implied in the phrase you quoted.

I'll bet you don't translate or form conclusions for a living.
 
We don't have VA clinics on every street corner, my area has three large military bases 2 AF, 1 Army with large retiree populations- the 'problem' clinics of Colorado and New Mexico don't have 'huge' populations to service either. I guess your fooking friends don't know about the Choice card... I do have a vet friend who is lower priority due to no service related injury nor doing a full 20 who does 50/50 Philly and Winter Park, Fl. he doesn't have long wait times either.

I doubt you see anything every freakin day- except right wing whine sites. Again you claim a lot but really don't give facts- my friend this, all my friends that. Lawton has a very small VA clinic- Civilian urgent care in town is bigger- but somehow it manages to take care of us.

Comparing my VA experience to my decades of private sector experience ( lots of 'funny' names on the doctor list in the private sector BTW)- I'll take VA any day. I do know the drunks and smokers clog the system up pretty bad- but I wouldn't blame VA for that... :peace

I have access the greatest naval hospital on the planet (Portsmouth Naval). My non retired friends have the Hampton VA. Do a quick Google on the Hampton Roads VA drug addiction scandal before you call anyone a liar,
and then bury a couple of your drug dependent buddies in the meantime, and then come back to me with your nonsense.
 
Μολὼν λαβέ;1065893412 said:
So when government fails, its the average American's fault?

You need to go back and read the Gettysburg Address. That's not what was implied in the phrase you quoted.

I'll bet you don't translate or form conclusions for a living.

Yes. When a government fails it is the fault of the citizens. We elect these leaders and allow them to stay in office. When your government does not represent you, you have an obligation to overthrow it. Either by ballot or by force.
 
Saw this earlier....almost puked. I had 2 friends commit suicide while being over prescribed with pain killers and anti depressants while waiting on operations. I had another commit suicide because he was too embarrassed to ask for help for PTSD for fear of being stigmatized.

Comparing the VA to Disney World is absolutely fitting.
 
That is all anecdotal. While not meaningless, we have no choice but to evaluate documented cases of veterans not seen but who should have been. In some cases losing their life before even a chance to be seen. We need to be thinking about underline reasons as to why the VA cannot seem to cover the workload of veterans needing medical attention of some regard. We have to have this conversation.

Who should have been- define that. If their illness isn't service related and they are not 20 year retirees they don't get a high priority. congress only gives so much money to run all of VA. Low pay doesn't attract doctors to contract with the VA. Limits on how much can be spent per patient doesn't allow non-service related illnesses to be put before vets with service related illnesses/chronic medical problems.

Draftees who did 2 years in Ft. Lee who drank or smoked their way to bad health don't get to bump men missing limbs out of the way. It would be interesting to know the ENTIRE story of why an extremely elderly vet wasn't seen in time. His health history, priority rating, and just how much effort did he make when medical treatment wasn't a matter of life or death.

There was a vet here who claimed his friend never got a call back from the automatic answering service. he himself never used the VA medical system either. i asked if the vet who wanted medical attention ever actually went to the VA processing center or the clinic. the answer was no, never made anymore of an effort than a single phone call. I heard the VA sucked so for decades I never went- finally i went to the VA office, they got copies of my medical records- submitted the claim, sent me to a third party evaluation and i got 60% disability. they got me my first appointment in the Clinic, I've had several since- one appointment I had to push off a bit because of a vacation. I had a very nice English speaking lady doctor who spend more time in one visit going over healthy lifestyle choices than ALL the private sector doctors combined. I do my best to have a healthy lifestyle, staying active- not smoke.

We need to know a lot more about the vets who died. i told you my story, my comparison between private sector and VA in the same town. I can't help but wonder why civilians who die in ER rooms or waiting for operations in the private sector don't get the same outrage. I mean many claim our extremely high priced health care system is the best in the world.

The discussion needs to be actual cases examined rather than- a friend of mine... :peace
 
We don't have VA clinics on every street corner, my area has three large military bases 2 AF, 1 Army with large retiree populations- the 'problem' clinics of Colorado and New Mexico don't have 'huge' populations to service either. I guess your fooking friends don't know about the Choice card... I do have a vet friend who is lower priority due to no service related injury nor doing a full 20 who does 50/50 Philly and Winter Park, Fl. he doesn't have long wait times either.

I doubt you see anything every freakin day- except right wing whine sites. Again you claim a lot but really don't give facts- my friend this, all my friends that. Lawton has a very small VA clinic- Civilian urgent care in town is bigger- but somehow it manages to take care of us.

Comparing my VA experience to my decades of private sector experience ( lots of 'funny' names on the doctor list in the private sector BTW)- I'll take VA any day. I do know the drunks and smokers clog the system up pretty bad- but I wouldn't blame VA for that... :peace

For your pleasure!

As VA scandal grows, local veterans highlight more problems at Hampton VA Medical Center | WTKR.com

Doctor: Veterans get hooked, not healed, at VA hospital | Military | pilotonline.com

VA mismanagement, malpractice detailed in reports

Nurse at Hampton VA hospital convicted of sexually assaulting patient | WTKR.com

Doctor: Veterans Get Hooked, Not Healed, At VA Hospital | Veterans Administration Medical Malpractice Information

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articl...-alone-local-authorities-need-to-step-up.html

http://www.countyofkings.com/home/showdocument?id=12845

http://wtkr.com/2014/06/10/hampton-...ntee-more-than-800-vets-recieved-timely-care/

http://articles.dailypress.com/2014...-center-va-secretary-eric-shinseki-phoenix-va

http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/national/2014/05/30/how-the-va-developed-its-culture-of-coverups/

I can post a few hundred more if you like.
 
VA Secretary Disneyland-wait time comparison draws ire
Veterans affairs secretary Disneyland comparison criticized - CNNPolitics.com

" Veterans Affairs Secretary Bob McDonald downplayed Monday the time it takes for veterans to receive medical treatment by comparing the "experience" of waiting for health care to Disneyland guests waiting for a ride.

"When you go to Disney, do they measure the number of hours you wait in line? Or what's important?" McDonald told reporters at a Christian Science Monitor breakfast in Washington. "What's important is what's your satisfaction with the experience?"

Hey McDonald, what if the waits so long you never get on the ride ?

307,000 vets may have died awaiting VA care, report says - CNNPolitics.com

The whole VA scandal should clue even the most brain dead American of just how bad Single Payer would be for the average American. Has ANYONE been held accountable for the VA scandal yet ?

Nope.

Amazing. The guy's either brain dead or incredibly emboldened by his boss.
 
Μολὼν λαβέ;1065893412 said:
So when government fails, its the average American's fault?

You need to go back and read the Gettysburg Address. That's not what was implied in the phrase you quoted.

I'll bet you don't translate or form conclusions for a living.

Average Americans--you and me--out these clowns in office. There aren't many of them, Republican, nor Democrat, that are putting these bureaucratic dip sticks in the unemployment line.
 
Is the Hampton VA still a crap heap on beautiful grounds? Had an uncle who got treatment there in the 80'S. Back then the outside was relaxing and great views even did a little fishing on a visit or two. The inside was decorated in cockroaches and blood stains.
 
First, if our Govt treats our Veterans this poorly, imagine how they're going to treat the average American

Next, the VA scandal is a cautionary tale. It for one highlights a alarming lack of accountability and it exposed a policy thats focus is on protecting bureaucrats, federal employees and Political appointees over holding those responsible accountable for what they've done.

You think its a Bull **** argument? Name ONE person thats been held accountable for the hundreds of thousands of examples of neglect

Name one politician that increased the VA budget high enough to cover the repercussions of the 1st and 3rd longest conflicts in this nation's history. Oh yeah, and fought at the same time.

Hold the VA accountable all you would like, in some ways I may agree with you. But we are foolish to ignore the politicians that are happy to send our troops to fight, happy to spend on the latest equipment to do so... but all of a sudden get concerned about our fiscal position when the subject of the VA comes up.
 
Progressives lie, Progressive Politicians and their progressive supporters all lie. Being morally and ethically reprehensible is one of their defining characteristics.

I posted that video to remind you and the rest of the posters on this thread that reality and bull **** empty promises from corrupt left wing Politicians are two different things.
Your right wing rant is still not applicable. The issue is whether a single payer system could benefit veterans who certainly deserve better care than the VA is currently providing. Also fact remains that single payer system is feasible and it is used by all industrialized nations and by every metric they are healthier and have better longevity than the US.
 
Wanted to slap you, then I got it!

What's disgraceful, is that no one in Congress is filing impeachment papers in this dumbass. He needs to go to his office tomorrow morning to get his **** and go look for another job.
 
Who should have been- define that. If their illness isn't service related and they are not 20 year retirees they don't get a high priority. congress only gives so much money to run all of VA. Low pay doesn't attract doctors to contract with the VA. Limits on how much can be spent per patient doesn't allow non-service related illnesses to be put before vets with service related illnesses/chronic medical problems.

Draftees who did 2 years in Ft. Lee who drank or smoked their way to bad health don't get to bump men missing limbs out of the way. It would be interesting to know the ENTIRE story of why an extremely elderly vet wasn't seen in time. His health history, priority rating, and just how much effort did he make when medical treatment wasn't a matter of life or death.

There was a vet here who claimed his friend never got a call back from the automatic answering service. he himself never used the VA medical system either. i asked if the vet who wanted medical attention ever actually went to the VA processing center or the clinic. the answer was no, never made anymore of an effort than a single phone call. I heard the VA sucked so for decades I never went- finally i went to the VA office, they got copies of my medical records- submitted the claim, sent me to a third party evaluation and i got 60% disability. they got me my first appointment in the Clinic, I've had several since- one appointment I had to push off a bit because of a vacation. I had a very nice English speaking lady doctor who spend more time in one visit going over healthy lifestyle choices than ALL the private sector doctors combined. I do my best to have a healthy lifestyle, staying active- not smoke.

We need to know a lot more about the vets who died. i told you my story, my comparison between private sector and VA in the same town. I can't help but wonder why civilians who die in ER rooms or waiting for operations in the private sector don't get the same outrage. I mean many claim our extremely high priced health care system is the best in the world.

The discussion needs to be actual cases examined rather than- a friend of mine... :peace

Look at post #32, I am not talking about "a friend of mine"... I am talking about story after story of the VA just not dealing with a veteran.
 
Yes. When a government fails it is the fault of the citizens. We elect these leaders and allow them to stay in office. When your government does not represent you, you have an obligation to overthrow it. Either by ballot or by force.

Take credit for the failures of our current government if you want to. That's on you.
 
Μολὼν λαβέ;1065893412 said:
So when government fails, its the average American's fault?
No, just the voting ones.

You need to go back and read the Gettysburg Address. That's not what was implied in the phrase you quoted.
Actually it does.

I'll bet you don't translate or form conclusions for a living.
NO that is probably what you do and not well at all.
 
VA Secretary Disneyland-wait time comparison draws ire
Veterans affairs secretary Disneyland comparison criticized - CNNPolitics.com

" Veterans Affairs Secretary Bob McDonald downplayed Monday the time it takes for veterans to receive medical treatment by comparing the "experience" of waiting for health care to Disneyland guests waiting for a ride.

"When you go to Disney, do they measure the number of hours you wait in line? Or what's important?" McDonald told reporters at a Christian Science Monitor breakfast in Washington. "What's important is what's your satisfaction with the experience?"

Hey McDonald, what if the waits so long you never get on the ride ?

307,000 vets may have died awaiting VA care, report says - CNNPolitics.com

The whole VA scandal should clue even the most brain dead American of just how bad Single Payer would be for the average American. Has ANYONE been held accountable for the VA scandal yet ?

Nope.

These vets are getting exactly what they agreed to accept - a VA-level of care.

If they're unhappy with the level of compensation they recieve, I offer the suggestion every rightwinger offers when the issue of raising the minimum wage comes up - get a better job with better pay and benefits
 
Thats the thing about Nationalized Healthcare, the small detail Sanders and his supporters leave out of their grand scheme to provide healthcare as a " right "

The Govt is never held to account legally or otherwise for it's unprecedented levels of corruption and mismanagement

The Left sees Single payer as the answer, as societal evolution but it would destroy what's left of this Nation. Reason being is no matter how poorly it was run, no matter how many people died due to Govt incompetence, corruption and mismanagement, no matter how much economic damage it did or how fiscally unsustainable it became, they would still be out there claiming it was a " resounding success "

Govt officials and bureaucrats would be protected from prosecution or even losing their jobs just like at the VA. But instead of your Father or Grandfather or Uncle ( which is bad enough ) being neglected it would be your Son, your Daughter, your wife

Well, single payer isn't the same as healthcare provided by the VA or even to active duty Service Members. For them, it's actually healthcare providers that are run and operated. Single payer would only be insurance. It wouldn't be government-run hospitals and doctors.
 
These vets are getting exactly what they agreed to accept - a VA-level of care.

If they're unhappy with the level of compensation they recieve, I offer the suggestion every rightwinger offers when the issue of raising the minimum wage comes up - get a better job with better pay and benefits

I'm sure the level of training and education the military members being referenced here, those who place themselves in harm's way, far exceeds pushing a broom or flipping burgers.

However I can't say I'm surprised with your disdain for American military men and women.

What a patriot..
 
Μολὼν λαβέ;1065893581 said:
I'm sure the level of training and education the military members being referenced here, those who place themselves in harm's way, far exceeds pushing a broom or flipping burgers.

If they're so highly skilled, they should have demanded better care before signing up

However I can't say I'm surprised with your disdain for American military men and women.

The only disdain I see comes from the right wingers who portray service members as ignorant dupes

The right wingers are a bunch of phony patriots.
 
If they're so highly skilled, they should have demanded better care before signing up



The only disdain I see comes from the right wingers who portray service members as ignorant dupes

The right wingers are a bunch of phony patriots.

Ignorant dupes are those who want tax payers to fund a broom pusher's livelyhood for life.

Patriots are the service men and women you disparage.
 
Well, single payer isn't the same as healthcare provided by the VA or even to active duty Service Members. For them, it's actually healthcare providers that are run and operated. Single payer would only be insurance. It wouldn't be government-run hospitals and doctors.

Like they tried to implement in Vermont. Green Mountain Care ?

As it turns out, the massive tax increases needed to fund Vermonts medicaid for all expansion would have tanked their local economy, even after MIT's Jonathan Gruber and Harvard's William Hsioa clamed it would save Vermont 1.6 Billion over 10 years
 
Μολὼν λαβέ;1065893507 said:
Take credit for the failures of our current government if you want to. That's on you.

It is on me. It is on you. It is on every one of us. We allow Barack Obama to stay in office. We allow each Representative and each Senator to keep their job.
 
Like they tried to implement in Vermont. Green Mountain Care ?

As it turns out, the massive tax increases needed to fund Vermonts medicaid for all expansion would have tanked their local economy, even after MIT's Jonathan Gruber and Harvard's William Hsioa clamed it would save Vermont 1.6 Billion over 10 years

Well, the fiscal realities are a whole 'nother ball of wax.
 
Back
Top Bottom