• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Lie Detectors, Solitary: How South Korea Screens Refugees

truthatallcost

DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 1, 2014
Messages
26,719
Reaction score
6,278
Location
California
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Other
SEOUL (Reuters) - South Korea has spent decades screening refugees from a hostile neighbor but some enemy agents manage to get through, underlining the challenges Western nations face in dealing with a far larger influx of people escaping the war in Syria.

Seoul uses lie detectors, interrogation and a screening process that includes keeping people in solitary confinement to catch North Korean agents among genuine asylum seekers.

Still, between 2003 and 2013, of the 49 North Korean spies apprehended in the South, 21 entered the country posing as refugees, according to the country's justice ministry.

"The question of spies slipping through is always a problem, and we need to make the process more meticulous and advanced," said Shin Kyung-min, the ranking opposition member of the South Korean parliament's intelligence committee.

"But it's not like we can stop taking in North Korean defectors because of that," Shin told Reuters.

There are growing calls in the United States and in Europe to bar tens of thousands of refugees fleeing Syria's civil war following this month's Paris attacks because of concerns that vetting processes are not stringent enough and that extremists planning attacks could slip through.

More than 1,000 North Koreans defect to the South every year and are held for up to 180 days while they are screened. If they clear that, the refugees are transferred to a resettlement complex, which they cannot leave, for another 12 weeks to help them adjust to life in the South.

New North Korean arrivals to the South, who typically enter via a third country, are brought to a facility in Siheung on the southern outskirts of Seoul. There, they are separated for questioning on their backgrounds and lives in the North, spending time in solitary but comfortable rooms.

No exception is made for families or children, who are taken from their parents and face similar questioning, according to a civic group.

Lie detectors, solitary: How South Korea screens refugees | Reuters

And people say that we're too hard on asylum seekers! And forget immigrating to South Korea, only North Koreans are eligible, all others are deported.
 
SEOUL (Reuters) - South Korea has spent decades screening refugees from a hostile neighbor but some enemy agents manage to get through, underlining the challenges Western nations face in dealing with a far larger influx of people escaping the war in Syria.

Seoul uses lie detectors, interrogation and a screening process that includes keeping people in solitary confinement to catch North Korean agents among genuine asylum seekers.

Still, between 2003 and 2013, of the 49 North Korean spies apprehended in the South, 21 entered the country posing as refugees, according to the country's justice ministry.

"The question of spies slipping through is always a problem, and we need to make the process more meticulous and advanced," said Shin Kyung-min, the ranking opposition member of the South Korean parliament's intelligence committee.

"But it's not like we can stop taking in North Korean defectors because of that," Shin told Reuters.

There are growing calls in the United States and in Europe to bar tens of thousands of refugees fleeing Syria's civil war following this month's Paris attacks because of concerns that vetting processes are not stringent enough and that extremists planning attacks could slip through.

More than 1,000 North Koreans defect to the South every year and are held for up to 180 days while they are screened. If they clear that, the refugees are transferred to a resettlement complex, which they cannot leave, for another 12 weeks to help them adjust to life in the South.

New North Korean arrivals to the South, who typically enter via a third country, are brought to a facility in Siheung on the southern outskirts of Seoul. There, they are separated for questioning on their backgrounds and lives in the North, spending time in solitary but comfortable rooms.

No exception is made for families or children, who are taken from their parents and face similar questioning, according to a civic group.

Lie detectors, solitary: How South Korea screens refugees | Reuters

And people say that we're too hard on asylum seekers! And forget immigrating to South Korea, only North Koreans are eligible, all others are deported.
As many have pointed out, there are so much easier and quicker ways to enter the US, only bumblers would even want to try this avenue. And hopefully our national LEOs can handle a few bumblers.
 
As many have pointed out, there are so much easier and quicker ways to enter the US, only bumblers would even want to try this avenue. And hopefully our national LEOs can handle a few bumblers.

I don't want to rely on "hopefully" finding the bad ones. The real threat is probably years to come anyway, when the children of the refugees become young adults and decide to join jihadi groups, which was the case with the majority of the Paris attackers.
 
I don't want to rely on "hopefully" finding the bad ones. The real threat is probably years to come anyway, when the children of the refugees become young adults and decide to join jihadi groups, which was the case with the majority of the Paris attackers.
There is no way to be 100% sure regardless of how careful we are, get over your paranoia, you're only letting them beat you when you hype this stupidity.
 
There is no way to be 100% sure regardless of how careful we are, get over your paranoia, you're only letting them beat you when you hype this stupidity.

No, we're letting them beat us when they kill us. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. But you'll say "what, me worry?". Alfred E Newman is the mascot of the left.
 
No, we're letting them beat us when they kill us. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. But you'll say "what, me worry?". Alfred E Newman is the mascot of the left.

The very definition of paranoia. More Americans die from automobile accidents yearly than by terrorism.
 
Back
Top Bottom