Re: Police: Multiple Victims in South Carolina church shooting [W:224]
You have now taken your SECOND giant step into irony in this discussion. You accused me of basing my argument on something I read in Wikipedia... only to now try and defend your argument using... Wikipedia. :roll:
I didn't accuse you of anything. I pointed out that you didn't bother to actually read your own source. Good grief, reading comprehension REALLY is hard for you.
But it's funny to see you destroying your own argument here. My initial statement was that the shooter had a mental illness, you claimed he wasn't.
Nope, I claimed there is no evidence to suggest he was mentally ill. There isn't. Reading comprehension. Use it.
I showed you that thoughts of homicidal ideation are classified under delirium in ICD-10. Now you have come back to prove me wrong by arguing that homicidal ideation is not mental illness, but rather a symptom of mental illness,
It's almost like you didn't read it: The source said
MAY result from mental illness, not that it is specifically a symptom of it. Again, reading comprehension.
meaning that those who present homicidal ideation are mentally ill, 89% of which are due to psychosis and the rest primarily substance induced mental illness.
Lol, again reading comprehension, what the source is stating is that psychosis includes
substance induced psychosis. Seriously, if you can't even read the basics of the very sources you're reading, why go into the more complex stuff that has commas?
So again, as I said, seeing a group of people at a bible study and thinking they were a threat to you worthy of killing you have presented clear evidence of mental illness through the clear display of homicidal ideation.
Still trying this silly argument? I'd give it up after failing so horribly to comprehend your own source.
So what you are holding out for is some subset of the 11% that are not born of psychosis, and that vast majority of the cases that are clearly born of mental illness are just not good enough for you?
Good grief, you do realize that the source states that 50 to 91% of the US population has had homicidal ideation? If your reading comprehension was anywhere near as good as you pretend it is, we'd then have to say that
45% to 81% of the US is mentally ill. However, the most
liberal estimates put it somewhere at ~20% (or 1 in 5 Americans). Do you not see a contradiction within this? How only ~20% of the population can be
mentally ill by the most liberal estimates but if your flawed attempt to play psychologist works, psychologists have been off by a a factor of 2 or 3 at best?
That should give you a damn clue as to how silly your entire statement is. Homicidal ideation is the thought of wanting to kill somebody. It's not a mental illness, it can be a symptom of it, but not necessarily. However, even with that said, there is no evidence to suggest that this person was mentally ill. That remains true. :shrug:
He told the mostly female Bible study group that he was there to stop them from raping white women... are you ready to accept my diagnosis yet?
He blamed all blacks for perceived crimes. Your diagnosis is WebMD nonsense. :shrug: