You can't reason anyone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into in the first place.
should a Muslim cake maker be forced to make a cake with Muhammad's picture on it If I walk in and demand one? with bacon and men kissing on it as figurines? or should they be arrested for denying that?
For example, in California you can even walk into a Jewish establishment in Nazi regalia and they cannot (legally) refuse service. This would never be apparent from the statute, but the court decided that someone's Nazi political beliefs are analogous to religion and therefore they could not be denied service.