- Joined
- Oct 28, 2007
- Messages
- 23,899
- Reaction score
- 16,363
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Independent
Helping the Kurds is key I agree my only worry is with Turkey and how they will react to a potential free Kurdish state which could potentially happen especially if we arm them/ fund them. Another worry with that is that if were to support the Kurds we could potentially see Iraq break up as each region looks to defend its borders and its own cultural identity.
I like most of your points except negotiation with the Assad government, Don't you think that given the weapons he has used and the brutal tactics he has been implementing that the West could possibly discredit itself by entering talks with them? Especially given the relationship they have with Russia?
Turkey has had its chance and shown itself happy to sit watching Kobane burn, ISIS recruits openly walking past Turkish border guards into Syria (and back).
We aren't doing enough to coerce Turkey to take a stand, the Kurds should be supported much more, they are dying in large numbers at the hands of ISIS and I think if we start training and arming the Kurds with much more potent weaponry then Turkey would be pressured into doing more than she does now.
as for the breakup of Iraq - do you remember a few years ago when the idea was first mooted as the sunni / shia strife started to really take hold? Some (including on DP and myself) argued this should have happened when it could have been managed peaceably. Nouri al-Maliki and Turkey argued for Iraq to be kept whole and their ideas and policies have failed. Their reasons for keeping Iraq as a contiguous nation were not for the right reasons.