Yes the Dissent nails it while i feel the ruling talks endless circles, more logic based on personal opinion and not law and a ruling that feels. . . well . .. . not like a ruling at all but like a complete dodge of the issue. How he circle talked and danced around whether a state has an interest was almost eye numbing. Referring to cases like Abbot but at the same time basically ignoring them is hilarious.
IMO I think the dodge and lack of a solid ruling was done on purpose but thats just my opinion. It was done to push it up the chain, which is fine by me. Forcing SCOTUS to rule is likely a faster path to equal rights.
I pointed out how DOMA was HUGE and would create dominoes and it did, ive been saying that i feel it wont be any longer than 2016 but now it might as well be as soon as next year.
Im actually happy theres a circuit break because IMO i think the road to equal rights victory will be even faster now.