• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine [/71]

Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Well, you are free to believe what you wish.

But Russian's are not going to be cold this winter if Europe shuts the gas pipe down.

But tens of millions of EU citizens might be.

And which group is going to scream louder to their politicians...especially when all the EU politicians have to do is simply not go along with the sanctions to turn the taps back on?

Plus, Russians have done without before in their relatively recent history...EU citizens (especially in the west) have not.

I think the freezing EU families will crack come November long before the somewhat (temporarily) poorer Russians will.

Which would you care more about...no gas to heat your home/family or a temporary cut in pay (because Russia will undoubtedly find other customers for their gas/oil)?

I think it's a no brainer for most people.

But the dependence is not that absolute. Actually the main European countries have much smaller dependence, like the numbers posted above show. Tiny places like Estonia and Latvia have 100% dependence but they've been trying to prepare too. In another thread there were posts about Estonia's new mobile gas refinery on a ship.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Who are "we"? The combined NATO forces are simply huge. If NATO as a whole (the United States plus the major NATO players like the UK, France, Germany, Italy) want to supply Ukraine with tanks and fighter jets, Ukraine could crush the Eastern rebellion in days or weeks.

Provided of course that Russia doesn't interfere... which I think they wouldn't, if NATO showed true resolve - for the sheer fact that NATO outnumbers Russia's military might 6:1. Putin is not suicidal.

who knows what Putin is thinking. he unleashes rabid wolves to create unrest in the crimea and grab that territory. now those same wolves are prowling in the eastern ukraine. Putin is engaging in asymmetrical warfare, which we have never been able to counter effectivilly.

personally i think the only thing that will change the putin's mind is to have him encounter his own gavrillo princip.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

But the dependence is not that absolute. Actually the main European countries have much smaller dependence, like the numbers posted above show. Tiny places like Estonia and Latvia have 100% dependence but they've been trying to prepare too. In another thread there were posts about Estonia's new mobile gas refinery on a ship.

True, but 36% of Germany's gas comes from Russia. That is the biggest EU country. And you, IMO, cannot just cut off 1/3 of your gas and have no noticeable effect on the economy.

Plus, as I added to my earlier post,

Putin does not have to run for re-election until 2018...why would he care if he drops in the polls for a year or two while he finds other buyers for his oil/gas?

And as I posted earlier, his numbers are skyrocketing despite the sanctions.

Russian Approval of Putin Soars to Highest Level in Years


Look, you believe Putin will blink first. I think the EU will.

We will see who is right.


Btw, thanks for debating like an intelligent adult...around here that is somewhat rare.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

True, but 36% of Germany's gas comes from Russia. That is the biggest EU country. And you, IMO, cannot just cut off 1/3 of your gas and have no noticeable effect on the economy.

Plus, as I added to my earlier post,

Putin does not have to run for re-election until 2018...why would he care if he drops in the polls for a year or two while he finds other buyers for his oil/gas?

And as I posted earlier, his numbers are skyrocketing despite the sanctions.

Russian Approval of Putin Soars to Highest Level in Years


Look, you believe Putin will blink first. I think the EU will.

We will see who is right.


Btw, thanks for debating like an intelligent adult...around here that is somewhat rare.

Hm... the 2018 election is a factor I hadn't thought of. It does indicate that he might blink last. Darn!

Oh well, if we can't really do much, it's depressing.

Thank you for your kind words.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Hm... the 2018 election is a factor I hadn't thought of. It does indicate that he might blink last. Darn!

Oh well, if we can't really do much, it's depressing.

Thank you for your kind words.

You are welcome.

Thanks for earning them.

Later.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

True, but 36% of Germany's gas comes from Russia. That is the biggest EU country. And you, IMO, cannot just cut off 1/3 of your gas and have no noticeable effect on the economy.

Plus, as I added to my earlier post,

Putin does not have to run for re-election until 2018...why would he care if he drops in the polls for a year or two while he finds other buyers for his oil/gas?

And as I posted earlier, his numbers are skyrocketing despite the sanctions.

Russian Approval of Putin Soars to Highest Level in Years


Look, you believe Putin will blink first. I think the EU will.

We will see who is right.


Btw, thanks for debating like an intelligent adult...around here that is somewhat rare.

His ratings will drop like a stone after this tragedy of his making. I don't think the Russian people are as murderous as Putin.
Putin will back down before risking the loss of his oil and gas sales to Europe. Just wait and see.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

One tiny village in the Netherlands called Neerkant in Noord-Brabant has been especially deeply affected by the crash of flight MH17.

The village has less than 1800 inhabitants and the beloved Wals family was on board of the crashed plane. Mother Nicole, Father Jeroen and their 4 children, Solenn (9), Amèl (12), Jinte (15) and Brett (17) were killed.

The school that the youngest attended opened it's doors last night for villagers who wanted to talk/support each other, many then walked to the house of the family where lived to leave flowers or light a candle in their memory. The children were friends with a lot of the village children, largely due to either being schoolmates, members of the dance club, volleyball club, scouting or (in the case of the oldest) the soccer club.

The villagers knew almost certainly that the family had been killed because oldest child Brett had sent out a selfie from him inside the airplane. But it still took a long time before it was officially confirmed.

All around the Netherlands stories like this are coming out.

The town of Hilversum was also deeply affected due to three entire families who died in the crash.
 
I fear that once again a valuable learning lesson will be lost in the aftermath of this tragedy. This is about irresponsibility, not about any of the side issues we wish to champion that came before or after this horrible event.

As educated, intelligent, and presumably responsible individuals, you don't fly into war zones.

There must indeed be a faulty element in the gene that manifests intelligence as an evolutionary characteristic in the mammals known as human beings. All other animal species know by instinct when to fight, flee, or avoid.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

One tiny village in the Netherlands called Neerkant in Noord-Brabant has been especially deeply affected by the crash of flight MH17.

The village has less than 1800 inhabitants and the beloved Wals family was on board of the crashed plane. Mother Nicole, Father Jeroen and their 4 children, Solenn (9), Amèl (12), Jinte (15) and Brett (17) were killed.

The school that the youngest attended opened it's doors last night for villagers who wanted to talk/support each other, many then walked to the house of the family where lived to leave flowers or light a candle in their memory. The children were friends with a lot of the village children, largely due to either being schoolmates, members of the dance club, volleyball club, scouting or (in the case of the oldest) the soccer club.

The villagers knew almost certainly that the family had been killed because oldest child Brett had sent out a selfie from him inside the airplane. But it still took a long time before it was officially confirmed.

All around the Netherlands stories like this are coming out.

The town of Hilversum was also deeply affected due to three entire families who died in the crash.

That's awful.

When Pan Am 103 was incinerated in the air over Lockerbie, Scotland, in the late 1980s, there were a lot of Syracuse (NY) University students on the plane. Since SU is a journalism school (my field) and also in my neck of the woods, I know many people who knew close to half of the casualties. Syracuse has a memorial on campus and still commemorates that horrible day. So I can somewhat relate, but not nearly to that level.

My thoughts are with the people of that town in the Netherlands.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

First off, we've been training rebel fighters in Syria and not very choosy with whom we're helping. That doesn't mean their some grand conspiracy theory with us ... I don't are you saying we're using ISIS to ... what? Destabilize a country we just left? Take the tin foil hat off and think for a moment. This is just like those who were saying that Bin Laden was a CIA agent or some stupid thing, because we backed them in a fight against the Soviet Union.

US was training and using ISIS for Syria, that's all I am saying. ISIS had bigger plans then Syria and the US and NATO allies ignored those ISIS plans because they had the same goal.... Get rid of Al-Assad. There are also NSA documents leaked by Snowden that confirm that Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi (ISIS Leader) when released by the US was in fact made a US "intel asset". .

Bin Laden wasn't a CIA agent/asset and never said he was.. so don't assume what I think.

And of course they were talking about setting up a new government. By that point, you weren't going to fight a hell of a lot of sympathy from the protesters for the ex president. And if it was already a forgone conclusion that the president had to leave, then there would have to be some sort of government to come into play afterwards. We found out from our experiences in Iraq what a colossally stupid idea it is to not think about the government that follows after you topple the old one. Also, this wasn't a dictatorship, although may of wished it so I suppose (maybe a soviet proxy like the cold war, let's just run them over with tanks huh?) In a democracy, people do really bad things sometimes. After all, we re-elected both Bush and Obama didn't we? That doesn't however give the government any right to slaughter people in the street who are executing their democratic right to protest. Once the bullets started flying, it really didn't matter which was the better deal. People were dying on the streets because a power hungry president was beholden to his Russian puppet masters and didn't (or couldn't) relent.

US had no reason to talk to them and pick and choose who was gonna run what.. if it was truly a Ukrainian people's movement. Sorry, that's interference in the will of the people correct? You wouldn't the EU picking who's gonna be the US President would you? Ukraine was given 2 real choices (Tymoshenko and Poroshenko), both of which the West highly favored and named by Victoria Nuland in that phone call in which she gave approval.. the rest were light weights who no money and access. Hmm.. who's gonna win? Just cause you have an election doesn't mean it's free or fair. North Korea has elections.. wanna know who wins that one? Oh that's right the only one that runs.

For a Libertarian you are ill-informed on what happen, but to each his or her own.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Or, third, the old government was kicked out and Russia has been fomenting rebellion in the east where a lot of Russian settlers went in when the old Soviet Union took over the place and kicked the native Ukrainians from their homes. Not sure why you keep white-washing Russian in this whole deal.

There is no third. I have yet to white-wash Russia here. There is always two sides to a fight. But let me drop some history on you.

Ukraine has barely existed for 100 years (in fact it's current borders will be 100 years old in 2017) and before that the reason was settled by Ottomans, Crimean Khanate, and a region known as Novorossiya (New Russia). This area had Tartars, Ottomans, Russians, Polish, Romanian and Ukrainian (Kievan Rus). The towns being fought over now, like Mariupol and Donetsk.. were and still are Russia cities. Where Russian is the key language, not Ukrainian. They identify as Russians. You are talking millions of people who feel Russian more then Ukrainian and they should. These towns and cities exist because Russians cleared out the Ottomans and Crimean Khanate 400 years ago and for 380 years they've been closer to Russia.

As a Libertarian I can't support a Government telling me I can't be who I want to be and that's exactly the new Ukrainian Government is telling the people in Eastern Ukrainian. Ukrainian's parliament voted to ban Russian as it's first official act. That's what set the people off in Eastern Ukraine.. Then incidents in Odessa made it worse. End of story is.. both sides are at fault. Both sides made mistakes. Both sides didn't learn from it and in a region in which weapons are plenty.. this is what happens.


It's never been about what you or I want, but what the Ukrainians want.

I never said it was about what I want. Rather what is an economic sound choice for you as a Ukrainian. You know damn well the Russian deal was the best for the Ukrainians and if Ukrainians weren't caught up in Nationalist ideals equal to that of United States, Nazi Germany or Soviet Union or even current Russian (and for other readers I am not saying US is like those others I listed but rather has Nationalistic tendencies over certain things), they really would have thought the process out. But like a petulant people, they never considered..

Take the Russian money and spend the next few years get their house in order and move slowly towards the west. That way their economy isn't harmed, they aren't reliant on Russia for fuel but explore their own oil fields. It's such a simple concept. But the West (EU) was forcing them to choose right then and there. Russia was saying you take that deal, consider yourself cut off. Ukraine could have been doing what it's been doing since 1991. Taking Russian money and moving more to the West. But alas, Nationalism got the best of them.


You do realize that you jut put three links to the same news story right? (Same topic, not same link, my bad.)

Yep, of a phone call about the Snipers in Kiev that were killing and wounding both Police and Protestors.



Of course they did. Because the Ukrainian Government were such nice and fuzzy people. No one ever died to government troops, and all those thousands of witnesses were just hallucinating or something right?

I never said they nice and fuzzy. You must not know that 18 police were killed and 130 were wounded by snipers as well. So both sides were shooting, right? Or those deaths didn't happen right?




You don't look at this stuff independently. You, and others like you, like to say these things because you want to feel above the fray and somehow smarter than everyone else. But your not, you're just spouting Russian propaganda because you have some beef with western society. Maybe it's because you think you should be entitled to everything free and those who succeed should pay for it, or you think "the man" is holding you down or some other juvenile excuse. I find it fascinating how people like you also discount these news sources when they report something you don't like (for example: Ukraine’s Forces Escalate Attacks Against Protesters, but then dismiss them the moment they put up a story that is contrary to the narrative you want to believe in. This conversation has moved into Conspiracy Theory territory, and there's a sub-forum for that if you wish to indulge your fantasies, as I have no interest in it. I'll allow you the last word, so go ahead and lash out or spout more GRU propaganda, I don't really care.

Woah, woah.. I do look at this stuff independently have. I don't feel above the fray and never have. I personally think the only people ever innocent in this world are Children until they start paying taxes. Once you start paying taxes to the State/Country (which ever one you may live in) you bare responsibility for it's actions or lack of action.

Nah.. I've long said it was two sides who made this situation and you can't even admit that.
Hmm
EU questions your version..
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Actually I was making more during the Bush years then at any time of Obama.

I was making even more money during the Clinton years and now during Obama I'm making more money than ever and paying less in taxes. Unemployment is under 5 percent here btw.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

I was making even more money during the Clinton years and now during Obama I'm making more money thsn ever and paying less in taxes.

I'm making more money now than I did during the Clinton years too! Of course, I was 24 when Clinton left office.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

US was training and using ISIS for Syria, that's all I am saying. ISIS had bigger plans then Syria and the US and NATO allies ignored those ISIS plans because they had the same goal.... Get rid of Al-Assad. There are also NSA documents leaked by Snowden that confirm that Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi (ISIS Leader) when released by the US was in fact made a US "intel asset". .

Bin Laden wasn't a CIA agent/asset and never said he was.. so don't assume what I think.



US had no reason to talk to them and pick and choose who was gonna run what.. if it was truly a Ukrainian people's movement. Sorry, that's interference in the will of the people correct? You wouldn't the EU picking who's gonna be the US President would you? Ukraine was given 2 real choices (Tymoshenko and Poroshenko), both of which the West highly favored and named by Victoria Nuland in that phone call in which she gave approval.. the rest were light weights who no money and access. Hmm.. who's gonna win? Just cause you have an election doesn't mean it's free or fair. North Korea has elections.. wanna know who wins that one? Oh that's right the only one that runs.

For a Libertarian you are ill-informed on what happen, but to each his or her own.

Yep! Getting rid of president Assad has caused us once again to compromise our principles.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

One tiny village in the Netherlands called Neerkant in Noord-Brabant has been especially deeply affected by the crash of flight MH17.

The village has less than 1800 inhabitants and the beloved Wals family was on board of the crashed plane. Mother Nicole, Father Jeroen and their 4 children, Solenn (9), Amèl (12), Jinte (15) and Brett (17) were killed.

The school that the youngest attended opened it's doors last night for villagers who wanted to talk/support each other, many then walked to the house of the family where lived to leave flowers or light a candle in their memory. The children were friends with a lot of the village children, largely due to either being schoolmates, members of the dance club, volleyball club, scouting or (in the case of the oldest) the soccer club.

The villagers knew almost certainly that the family had been killed because oldest child Brett had sent out a selfie from him inside the airplane. But it still took a long time before it was officially confirmed.

All around the Netherlands stories like this are coming out.

The town of Hilversum was also deeply affected due to three entire families who died in the crash.

What a tragedy!
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

I am now assuming what happened is the rebels shot down the plane using an SA-11 missile(s).

But apparently that missile cannot on it's own differentiate between military and civilian aircraft - you need additional radar assets for that. And the rebels do not appear to have that kind of radar system operational.

So, my guess is that they saw the Malaysian 777 on the radar, assumed it was a Ukranian transport plane (since they probably thought civilian airline flights would not stray into a known war zone) and shot it down with a SA-11 missile.

So, it was probably a reckless, though unintentional, mistake.


All of this still begs the question...what the heck was a modern airliner doing flying near/over a known war zone?
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

I am now assuming what happened is the rebels shot down the plane using an SA-11 missile(s).

But apparently that missile cannot on it's own differentiate between military and civilian aircraft - you need additional radar assets for that. And the rebels do not appear to have that kind of radar system operational.

So, my guess is that they saw the Malaysian 777 on the radar, assumed it was a Ukranian transport plane (since they probably thought civilian airline flights would not stray into a known war zone) and shot it down with a SA-11 missile.

So, it was probably a reckless, though unintentional, mistake.


All of this still begs the question...what the heck was a modern airliner doing flying near/over a known war zone?

The answer to your question could be in the communications between the ATC's and the pilot.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

The answer to your question could be in the communications between the ATC's and the pilot.

Agreed.

Additionally, if the Ukranian high command knew that the rebels did not have the radar assets to differentiate 'friend or foe' (which I assume they did), then they would also probably know that any plane that flew into rebel airspace would be shot at (as many had before).

And if the above is true, if one were cynical, one could argue that the Ukranian high command deliberately diverted that plane into rebel air space - hoping that they would shoot it down, cause a huge international backlash against the rebels and receive huge amounts of aid/assistance to end the war sooner and/or force the Russians to stay out of it completely.

Btw,

'It now appears that answer will not be forthcoming because as the BBC reports "Ukraine's SBU security service has confiscated recordings of conversations between Ukrainian air traffic control officers and the crew of the doomed airliner, a source in Kiev has told Interfax news agency."'

Ukraine's Security Service Has Confiscated Air Traffic Control Recordings With Malaysian Jet | Zero Hedge


'Malay Mail Online — July 18, 2014

Pro Russian militia survey the wreckage of MH17 at the crash site. Click to enlarge
Malaysia Airlines (MAS) said tonight that it was told to fly low over Ukrainian airspace by ground controllers, putting it at 33,000 feet, just skimming 1,000 feet above restricted altitude.

In a statement here, MAS explained that MH17 had initially filed a flight plan requesting to fly at 35,000 feet above Ukrainian territory, which it described as close to the “optimum altitude”.

“However, an aircraft’s altitude in flight is determined by air traffic control on the ground.

“Upon entering Ukrainian airspace, MH17 was instructed by Ukrainian air traffic control to fly at 33,000 feet,” the national carrier said.'


http://www.thetruthseeker.co.uk/?p=101049


Finally, there were no Ukranians on board MH17.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_17#Passengers_and_crew
 
Last edited:
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

It is pathetic that people are so readily buying the rather shoddy Washington-Kiev case for responsibility. Social media posts? Give me a break and no one should buy any audio or video "proof" from the people who tried to perpetrate this fraud on the public. This whole situation makes me think of Halabja. It would not be the first time Ukraine's military shot down a civilian airliner by accident and had someone else try to cover it up for them and exploit it for political purposes at the same time.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Oh great the conspiracy forum is spilling over again.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Oh great the conspiracy forum is spilling over again.

After all the various times the U.S. has been caught misrepresenting or outright fabricating evidence in pursuit of its foreign policy objectives, one would think people would stop throwing out the c-word every time someone suggests a shoddy case from unreliable sources might actually be pure garbage.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

After all the various times the U.S. has been caught misrepresenting or outright fabricating evidence in pursuit of its foreign policy objectives, one would think people would stop throwing out the c-word every time someone suggests a shoddy case from unreliable sources might actually be pure garbage.

It is pathetic though to accuse everyone of being pathetic. Nothing like alienating everyone that disagrees with you.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Agreed.

Additionally, if the Ukranian high command knew that the rebels did not have the radar assets to differentiate 'friend or foe' (which I assume they did), then they would also probably know that any plane that flew into rebel airspace would be shot at (as many had before).

And if the above is true, if one were cynical, one could argue that the Ukranian high command deliberately diverted that plane into rebel air space - hoping that they would shoot it down, cause a huge international backlash against the rebels and receive huge amounts of aid/assistance to end the war sooner and/or force the Russians to stay out of it completely.

Btw,

'It now appears that answer will not be forthcoming because as the BBC reports "Ukraine's SBU security service has confiscated recordings of conversations between Ukrainian air traffic control officers and the crew of the doomed airliner, a source in Kiev has told Interfax news agency."'

Ukraine's Security Service Has Confiscated Air Traffic Control Recordings With Malaysian Jet | Zero Hedge


'Malay Mail Online — July 18, 2014

Pro Russian militia survey the wreckage of MH17 at the crash site. Click to enlarge
Malaysia Airlines (MAS) said tonight that it was told to fly low over Ukrainian airspace by ground controllers, putting it at 33,000 feet, just skimming 1,000 feet above restricted altitude.

In a statement here, MAS explained that MH17 had initially filed a flight plan requesting to fly at 35,000 feet above Ukrainian territory, which it described as close to the “optimum altitude”.

“However, an aircraft’s altitude in flight is determined by air traffic control on the ground.

“Upon entering Ukrainian airspace, MH17 was instructed by Ukrainian air traffic control to fly at 33,000 feet,” the national carrier said.'


Ukraine air traffic controllers instructed MH17 to fly lower, MAS says


Finally, there were no Ukranians on board MH17.

Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Why are people making such a fuss about 35K feet versus 33K feet? the SA-11 Buk launcher unit can hit planes up to 72K feet. These 2K feet of difference between what the pilot wanted and what the ATC wanted make no difference whatsoever. People are reaching for straws.

About the suggestion that this particular plane was intentionally diverted into a war zone by the Ukrainian authorities to be shot, this is absurd. There were several other airlines at the time using the same corridor. Apparently what happened is that people thought that being above 32K feet was enough protection since the previous incidents of military planes getting shot were rather by much shorter range missiles and nobody was expecting a sophisticated Buk unit to be operated by the rebels.
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

It is pathetic that people are so readily buying the rather shoddy Washington-Kiev case for responsibility. Social media posts? Give me a break and no one should buy any audio or video "proof" from the people who tried to perpetrate this fraud on the public. This whole situation makes me think of Halabja. It would not be the first time Ukraine's military shot down a civilian airliner by accident and had someone else try to cover it up for them and exploit it for political purposes at the same time.

Really? Please explain then why are the rebels hindering the international "crime scene investigation"? What do they have to hide, if as you suggest Ukraine's military are the culprits for downing the plane?
 
Re: Report: Malaysia Airlines flight crashes in Ukraine

Really? Please explain then why are the rebels hindering the international "crime scene investigation"? What do they have to hide, if as you suggest Ukraine's military are the culprits for downing the plane?

Are they?

First off this is a conflict zone, and is controlled by the rebels. These rebels are hardly well organized and never have been.

Secondly this is a conflict zone.. yes it needs repeating. Everyone is suspicious of everyone else. The rebels could be expecting an attack or that the Kiev forces would exploit this tragedy to move in and take over the area. There is in fact reports of an attack near the site this morning.

Thirdly the rebels are being played by the western media. I in no way support the rebels, but the crap the media and Kiev/west have been pulling the last few days is mind-boggling. First the rebels were not giving access, when the investigators were not even there. Should the rebels give access to Kiev people? HAHAH yea right. Then the rebels were not doing enough to take care of the corpses and secure the scene... despite the scene being massive. Then there was an outrage that it was taking so long to get the corpses away and that they were rotting in the hot sun. Then the rebels did remove them and suddenly they were "kidnapping" the corpses. Come on....Then the accusation is that the black boxes have been stolen.. eh? The rebels have said they have them, and that they will be handed over to the international aviation investigation group or whatever it is called. The rebels might have done this (most likely) but damn they cant do anything right it seems according to Kiev and the west..

The investigators are in the area and have been for days, something that the media often forgets to mention. Problem is the area the wreckage covers is huge.. we are talking 10+ square miles and even in the west that would be damn hard to secure not to mention control.. and this is a conflict zone.

Now the rebels are being blamed for not handing over the corpses, which they did put on a train.. a refrigeration train... a very good thing. Of course the rebels wont send the train through government control areas.. and the west wont accept it goes via Russia.. then what the hell do you do?

Are the rebels trying to "hide" things.. maybe, but the Kiev government and the west are also trying to define the narrative. This tragedy has turned into another propaganda bitch fight by the west vs Russia.
 
Back
Top Bottom