- Joined
- Jun 14, 2006
- Messages
- 16,575
- Reaction score
- 6,767
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Libertarian - Left
Re: Who Do You Believe? A soldier or the soldiers?
Please show us this medical report that he was as healthy as his captors. It's interesting you like to spout things but don't back them up. Fact is NO doctor has declared him healthy yet YOU claimed he was.
And yet again I will say. I'm not saying the guy is innocent, but he doesn't deserve to be left with the Taliban. He deserves an investigation and if necessary a trial. THAT is what we do for our military. You don't really care, you believe in trial by media instead. Completely Un-American.
"healthy" is a vague term which can have many definitions. He was no more unhealthy then his captors. Look at the average Taliban fighter and you will see they are also very "unhealthy" just do to the nature of their profession. You can't live in a cave and run from place to place living off the meager wildlife in desolate area's and live a "healthy" life. The average age someone dies in Afghanistan is 58 years old. It only makes sense that he would suffer a bit health wise living like the average afghan for 5 years. So the term is relative. And any health issues he has are a result of living like an afghan Taliban fighter for 5 years, not from torture. Ask some WW2 POW's what they went thru and you will see what real torture is. What Bergdahl went thru was heaven in comparison.
Please show us this medical report that he was as healthy as his captors. It's interesting you like to spout things but don't back them up. Fact is NO doctor has declared him healthy yet YOU claimed he was.
And yet again I will say. I'm not saying the guy is innocent, but he doesn't deserve to be left with the Taliban. He deserves an investigation and if necessary a trial. THAT is what we do for our military. You don't really care, you believe in trial by media instead. Completely Un-American.