• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Gwyneth Paltrow: Mean words hurt water's feelings

Maybe when you talk to water, you can ask it how to debate on a political forum and it will give you much needed tips in it's crystalline form.
:lamo
Strange that you would think water would give an interpretable response.
Like I already stated.
Anybody can talk to water. What is not to believe about that?
It is if you think the water is answering where the problem occurs.
And apparently from what you stated, you think water answers.
Strange indeed.
 
Is that what you think? Interesting.

They didn't give any context for the photos, did they?


Here's Mozart's icecube in BS major:

water-mozart.jpg


Here's one that listens to heavy metal:

heavy-metal-music.jpg


Notice how you can see pits and such in the surface of the heavy metal ice, but not in the Mozart's? That's because it's at a higher zoom. It could very well be the same crystal, given the concentric rings present in the surface of both, just at a higher resolution.


Of course, the photos show just one crystal out of the hundreds that form when a drop of water freezes. That this is somehow representative of an entire water bottle is bull****.
 
:lamo
Strange that you would think water would give an interpretable response.
No stranger than you believing water has feelings.
 
No stranger than you believing water has feelings.
Strange.
I see you are not paying attention to what I have said and that which you have even quoted in post #12.
More strangeness indeed.

Nor is it that water has feelings, but more like you transfer your feelings unto the water.
 
Of course, the photos show just one crystal out of the hundreds that form when a drop of water freezes. That this is somehow representative of an entire water bottle is bull****.
Is that what you think?
Interesting.
Have you reproduced the experiment?
 
You have to admit that maybe she is on to something... her son Moses is perhaps training to speak to the water and have it part the seas for her daughter Apple.
 
Is that what you think?
Interesting.
Have you reproduced the experiment?

Experiment making love to your water and see how it responds.
 
We're composed mainly of water, so she's technically correct..
 
Experiment making love to your water and see how it responds.
Better yet you do what you absurdly suggest and let us know how it turned out.
 
Is that what you think?
Interesting.

Isn't that what he's claiming, that a single aesthetically pleasing ice crystal shows that water likes Beethoven, and a single, aesthetically unpleasant ice crystal shows that water doesn't like heavy metal, and that from this, you can extrapolate that water has the same sense of aesthetics as people, and responds to stimuli, understands multiple languages, is literate, can see, and will form ice crystals on the basis of this.


Have you reproduced the experiment?

I don't have a microscope camera, but if you buy me one, I'll gladly put some water in a jar and take photos of it.
 
Better yet you do what you absurdly suggest and let us know how it turned out.

Nothing would happen... water reacts to sound waves, wind, hot and cold and basically nothing more, and especially not feelings or words. That idea is stupid.
 
Isn't that what he's claiming, that a single aesthetically pleasing ice crystal shows that water likes Beethoven, and a single, aesthetically unpleasant ice crystal shows that water doesn't like heavy metal, and that from this, you can extrapolate that water has the same sense of aesthetics as people, and responds to stimuli, understands multiple languages, is literate, can see, and will form ice crystals on the basis of this.
No to me he isn't.
It appears to me that a person's spoken feelings and music (which are nothing more than vibrations) somehow has an affect on the structure of the water when it freezes.
Do you think it unusual that vibrations may affect such?


I don't have a microscope camera, but if you buy me one, I'll gladly put some water in a jar and take photos of it.
You have other options besides someone making a purchase for you.
I would suggest you figure out what they are and pursue one or more of those routes.
 
Nothing would happen... water reacts to sound waves, wind, hot and cold and basically nothing more, and especially not feelings or words. That idea is stupid.
:doh:doh:doh
The spoken word is vibrations. Or in other words - Sound waves.
 
No to me he isn't.
It appears to me that a persons feeling and music (which are nothing more than vibrations) somehow has an affect on the structure of the water when it freezes.
Do you think it unusual that vibrations may affect such?

It's not a persons feelings, it's a persons feeling towards symbols on a piece of paper on a petri dish. And I don't see vibrations from Mozart allowing a crystalline structure to form, but somehow heavy metal prevents that. (Assuming they're played at the same volume)
You have other options besides someone making a purchase for you.
I would suggest you figure out what they are and pursue one or more of those routes.

I'll consider it.
 
A guy uses a computer, created by 300 years of scientific knowledge and complemented by 50 years of scientific research put into the internet to complain about science by linking it to pseudoscience. Lol.

Mkaaaaaaay.
 
:doh:doh:doh
The spoken word is vibrations. Or in other words - Sound waves.

Words spoken about hate but in a lovely voice or a simple expression of feelings in a monotone voice will not produce angry water crystals because water can't denote meaning, just sound. That is the point so yo u can take your idiotic misunderstanding and do what you always idiotically do... compound the idiocy.
 
It's not a persons feelings, it's a persons feeling towards symbols on a piece of paper on a petri dish.
It is a person's verbalized feelings.

Again.
Do you think it unusual that vibrations may affect such?
 


I am not growing properly because of these sounds. Do you have any Prince? I bet I could get my toes to grow a few inches if you put on some Prince.
 
Back
Top Bottom