• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Lake Mead is shrinking -- and with it Las Vegas' water supply

Conservation, such as not having lawns and golf courses, might help some. Desalinization would produce more water, but is expensive. What we need is a water delivery system to bring water from the rain soaked north west down to the desert areas where crops can be grown.

Crossing the Columbia River on a trip north once, I found that it was dumping a million cubic feet per second into the ocean. Bring even a little of that water to California and southern Nevada, and we'd have plenty.
 
Conservation, such as not having lawns and golf courses, might help some. Desalinization would produce more water, but is expensive. What we need is a water delivery system to bring water from the rain soaked north west down to the desert areas where crops can be grown.

Crossing the Columbia River on a trip north once, I found that it was dumping a million cubic feet per second into the ocean. Bring even a little of that water to California and southern Nevada, and we'd have plenty.
 
because it is a childish lie ... Bush signed the law handing out free cell phones to s.s. And welfare recipients early in 2008.
It is at least as stupid as it would be to call obamacare, bushcare.
Hey, come to think of it, since bush senior and bob dole came up with the idea of the individual mandate maybe i'll start calling the aca bushcare. Bush senior needs some kind of a legacy other than "read my lips, no new taxes". Why not give him the credit for his idea?
I tell you what ...i'll start calling them "obama phones" if you start calling the aca "bush care" ... Hows that? individual mandate, now vilified by gop, was supported by george h.w. Bush
bush mobile phone,*shop411.com

ooooobama-phone
 
cool--I can tell you this--the Western range of Rocky Mtn Natl Pk, called the Never-Summer mtns,
still has its water diverted to Denver and the Front Range.
What side of the Great Divide ? That's important.
I'm counting on you to talk intelligent drought stuff with me, please.
What do you know of any talk over the decades about desalination plants ?
 
Ban housing developments in what used to be deserts from "watering" lawns and changing the ecosystem.
Teach them to build a lawn that "absorbs" water from the air, saving ground-water .

I believe that's already being done. At least LV has been encouraging it for some time now. So-called Desert Landscaping is all the rage there. We've replaced toilets before, now replace them with waterless. That alone should do the trick with no need for desalinization which is just another one of those moves that solves a temporary problem only to create greater problems down the line.
 
Conservation, such as not having lawns and golf courses, might help some.
Desalinization would produce more water, but is expensive.
I believe the initial investment in desalinization must happen.
Too bad we don't have nuclear fusion yet.
Any time Teddy Roosevelt feels like being reincarnated with his Great Ideas would be welcome.
What we need is a water delivery system to bring water from the rain soaked north west down to the desert areas where crops can be grown.
This is an outstanding idea and I look at it as what I'm working on,
water-piping our flood water from East of the Mississippi to the Ogallalla aquifer and further west.

Crossing the Columbia River on a trip north once, I found that it was dumping a million cubic feet per second into the ocean.
Bring even a little of that water to California and southern Nevada, and we'd have plenty.
All it would take is another "ERIE Canal".
The creator of that was ridiculed at first .
 
cool--I can tell you this--the Western range of Rocky Mtn Natl Pk, called the Never-Summer mtns,
still has its water diverted to Denver and the Front Range.

I'm counting on you to talk intelligent drought stuff with me, please.
What do you know of any talk over the decades about desalination plants ?

I already posted about the Santa Barbara desalination plant above on this thread. It's been put in mothballs back during the early 1990's. It laid out the cost to reactivate the plant and how much it will cost to produce in dollars per acre feet of water. The post above that one informs everyone how many gallons are in an acre feet of water.

As the city of Santa Barbara points out, desalination is so expensive that the city will only reactivate the desalination plant as the last resort.
 
Let me ask this.
If a new desalination plant would be built along the coast, is the technology any better and how has the expense changed ?
I already posted about the Santa Barbara desalination plant above on this thread. It's been put in mothballs back during the early 1990's. It laid out the cost to reactivate the plant and how much it will cost to produce in dollars per acre feet of water. The post above that one informs everyone how many gallons are in an acre feet of water.

As the city of Santa Barbara points out, desalination is so expensive that the city will only reactivate the desalination plant as the last resort.
 
It's good to hear that these measures are being done.
I believe that's already being done. At least LV has been encouraging it for some time now. So-called Desert Landscaping is all the rage there. We've replaced toilets before, now replace them with waterless.
As per post #176 of this thread, where are you on the "one million cubic feet per second" of water being dumped into the ocean.
Is there potential for water pipelines to begin on the south side of the Columbia R.?
Even more dreaming, how about an "ERIE-style" Canal, to begin East of the Cascades for obvious land-feature reasons?
That alone should do the trick with no need for desalinization which is just another one of those moves that solves a temporary problem only to create greater problems down the line.
With what we're hearing that it will take at least 20 years for the West to come out of this thing with good moisture,
it appears to me that eventually the expense of desalination will be worth it for certain areas.
 
Let me ask this.
If a new desalination plant would be built along the coast, is the technology any better and how has the expense changed ?

You might want to ask Roguenuke if she's floating around. She's familiar with desalination units since most Navy ships have desalination units aboard to produce fresh water for the ships crew. An aircraft carrier is a small city.

Most advancement in technology have always come from the military industrial complex. If there's a new technology in the pipeline it will becoming from DARPA.

Just doing a light search.

2013/06/25 Improved Water Purification Technology Reduces SWaP Logistics Burden

PORTABLE SOLAR POWERED WATER PURIFICATION AND DESALINATION SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT | SBIR.gov

DARPA by Marc Andelman | Desalination.com

Saudi Desalination Investing
 
But who has dibs on your water?
Summit County Western slope.
Also, any more to the talk of damming the Arkansas River?
Last I heard, Colorado Springs wanted that water .

Also heard some mega-capitalist from Ft. Collins/Longmont has gotten the go-ahead to dam the Cache de Poudre ?
 
In the west, whisky is for drinking. Water is for fighting over.
 
And oil is for pumping .
 
You might want to ask Roguenuke if she's floating around. She's familiar with desalination units since most Navy ships have desalination units aboard to produce fresh water for the ships crew. An aircraft carrier is a small city.

Most advancement in technology have always come from the military industrial complex. If there's a new technology in the pipeline it will becoming from DARPA.

Just doing a light search.

2013/06/25 Improved Water Purification Technology Reduces SWaP Logistics Burden

PORTABLE SOLAR POWERED WATER PURIFICATION AND DESALINATION SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT | SBIR.gov

DARPA by Marc Andelman | Desalination.com

Saudi Desalination Investing

I've always figured that we don't use desalination as much on land because we seem to be much less willing to combine operations on land than we do on Navy vessels, besides just the cost compared to other land based water gathering methods. For instance, as a mechanic/engineer onboard the ship, I helped make the steam, electricity and water for the ship all in basically the same space or working with people in the space next to ours to do this. We used all of these things together to make the others. For civilians to do this and be as efficient as possible, they would basically have to integrate the desalination plants into close operation with an electric power plant near a large body of water, preferably the ocean. Plus there is the issue of more pollution being in the water closer to land than at sea. That means ensuring better monitoring of water than we do (we don't generally have to worry about foreign chemicals in our water, just microbes, bacteria, and maybe some algae, by the time we make the water, the chemicals have already diluted to pretty much undetectable levels). And then there is the matter of what to do with the "brine" (concentrated salt water left over with other sealife/crud within it that we simply pump back out to sea) that is left. We simply pump it back out to sea as we pass, whereas piping would be needed to this on land but it might need to be processed to meet pollution standards.

It's certainly possible to do that right now, I just think most people feel it isn't worth it when there are other sources available that are cheaper to do. One day we might need it though, considering how much water we use, and hopefully we will be prepared for it without major hassles, but I doubt it.
 
I've always figured that we don't use desalination as much on land because we seem to be much less willing to combine operations on land than we do on Navy vessels, besides just the cost compared to other land based water gathering methods. For instance, as a mechanic/engineer onboard the ship, I helped make the steam, electricity and water for the ship all in basically the same space or working with people in the space next to ours to do this. We used all of these things together to make the others. For civilians to do this and be as efficient as possible, they would basically have to integrate the desalination plants into close operation with an electric power plant near a large body of water, preferably the ocean. Plus there is the issue of more pollution being in the water closer to land than at sea. That means ensuring better monitoring of water than we do (we don't generally have to worry about foreign chemicals in our water, just microbes, bacteria, and maybe some algae, by the time we make the water, the chemicals have already diluted to pretty much undetectable levels). And then there is the matter of what to do with the "brine" (concentrated salt water left over with other sealife/crud within it that we simply pump back out to sea) that is left. We simply pump it back out to sea as we pass, whereas piping would be needed to this on land but it might need to be processed to meet pollution standards.

It's certainly possible to do that right now, I just think most people feel it isn't worth it when there are other sources available that are cheaper to do. One day we might need it though, considering how much water we use, and hopefully we will be prepared for it without major hassles, but I doubt it.

That's the way I have been looking at water desalination on land. You have to have electricity. Except for hydro-electrict the eviormentalist don't like nuclear, gas, JP, or coal electrical generating plants. Solar and wind electrical generation take up vast areas of land and contribute to eye pollution. They're ugly.

Then the liberals in San Fransisco and even the L.A. area want to dismantle all of the dams and restore all the rivers to their natural condition not knowing why the dams were constructed in the first place. To control the river flow preventing flooding down stream and providing a reservoir for water for drinking, manufacturing and agriculture. Hydo-elecricity was just a byproduct. I wonder if the left has noticed that most of the rivers in Southern California are concrete ? There's a reason for that.
 
I believe that's already being done. At least LV has been encouraging it for some time now. So-called Desert Landscaping is all the rage there. We've replaced toilets before, now replace them with waterless. That alone should do the trick with no need for desalinization which is just another one of those moves that solves a temporary problem only to create greater problems down the line.

The people of the world have been learning how to recycle more and more things as well as develop new technologies to replace that which is no longer practical or effective. We will almost certainly continue to do so. When we really are running out of fossil fuels, as has bee predicted for so long but is not yet a problem, I have every confidence in human ingenuity that they will have developed viable and practical replacement for them. When there is insufficient water, the people either pack up and move or figure out another way to get water. And we all learn to adapt to whatever conditions exist.

In our area, the lawn has mostly disappeared in favor of drought resistant xeriscaping which is quite lovely. Most of us do use evaporative coolers but these are super efficient and use very little water--the increase in our water bill during the hot summer months, even when we run the cooler around the clock, is negligible--certainly less than a dollar or two a month. In fact our city saved so much water in the last couple of years, that the city needs to raise its water rates to offset the revenue shortfall. And yeah, it bites when we are punished for being responsible.

So if we are in for a hundred year drought, this will be devastating for many areas, especially those desert areas that have depended so heavily on agriculture and other water intensive industries. But humankind is pretty resilient and capable of dealing with whatever the Earth throws at it. And we will get through this drought too.
 
Well thank God we are saving a Delta Smelt....

Consumers around the country may soon be facing steeper prices for fruits, vegetables and nuts thanks to an obscure three-inch-long fish, called the Delta smelt, and the Endangered Species Act (ESA).

In California’s storied Central Valley, for decades one of the world’s most productive agricultural regions, an estimated 250,000 acres of prime farm land are lying fallow or dying. The parched area bears all the signs of a prolonged drought, but the acute water shortage confronting farmers and growers is largely manmade, the result of the Interior Department’s rigorous enforcement of the ESA.

- See more at: Tiny fish threatens to turn Californiaâ
 
And then there is the matter of what to do with the "brine" (concentrated salt water left over with other sealife/crud within it that we simply pump back out to sea) that is left. We simply pump it back out to sea as we pass, whereas piping would be needed to this on land but it might need to be processed to meet pollution standards.

Is it possible/feasible to train-transport this brine to the east to be used on roads such as right now with our winter?
I'm assuming the brine is contaminated and may cause harm to the ecosystems connected to the roads .
 
Last edited:
Well thank God we are saving a Delta Smelt....

Much as the environmentalists put a number of farmers and ranchers downstream into or near bankruptcy to save a tiny silvery minnow that is found in the middle Rio Grande that has survived many droughts before people started trying to run the world better than Mother Nature did.
 
Is it possible/feasible to train-transport this brine to the east to be used on roads such as right now with our winter?
I'm assuming the brine is contaminated and may cause harm to the ecosystems connected to the roads .

Depends on what is in it. It is still water, just very salty water with pretty much anything else found in ocean water, including even some seacreatures. Close to shore, it is also going to have some chemicals and other pollutants, dependent on where exactly the plant would be located. It could be transported anywhere water can, but it might not be worth it to do it, since I really don't know the cost of such a venture.
 
Depends on what is in it. It is still water, just very salty water with pretty much anything else found in ocean water, including even some seacreatures. Close to shore, it is also going to have some chemicals and other pollutants, dependent on where exactly the plant would be located. It could be transported anywhere water can, but it might not be worth it to do it, since I really don't know the cost of such a venture.

I would suggest they find a way to purify it for human consumption, let it dry up, and let all that great sea salt become an important new American industry.
 
Back
Top Bottom