• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

TSA Drops Plan to Allow Small Knives On Planes.....

MMC

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Feb 26, 2012
Messages
56,981
Reaction score
27,029
Location
Chicago Illinois
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Private
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Transportation Security Administration is abandoning a plan to allow passengers to carry small knives, souvenir bats, golf clubs and other sports equipment onto planes in the face of fierce congressional and industry opposition, the head of the agency said Wednesday.

e3617619d837ea12330f6a706700ed5b.jpg


By scuttling the plan to drop the knives and sports equipment from TSA's list of prohibited items, the agency can focus its attention on other priorities, including expanding its Pre-Check program to identify ahead of time travelers who don't pose a security risk, TSA Administrator John Pistole told The Associated Press.

Pistole had unveiled the proposal to loosen the rules for carry-ons in March, saying the knives and other items can't enable terrorists to cause a plane to crash. He said intercepting them takes time that would be better used searching for explosives and other more serious threats. TSA screeners confiscate over 2,000 of the small folding knives a day from passengers.

Skeptical lawmakers, airlines, labor unions and some law enforcement groups complained that the knives and other items in the hands of the wrong passengers could be used to injure or even kill passengers and crew.

Last month 145 House members signed a letter to Pistole asking him to keep in place the current policy prohibiting passengers from including the knives and other items in their carry-on bags. Flight attendant unions organized protests in Washington and at airports across the country. And Airlines for America, which represents major U.S. airlines, as well as top executives from some of the nation's largest airlines, came out against the plan.....snip~

TSA drops plan to allow small knives on planes

Course this is more than just the knives. The TSA gets it now, that all weren't on the same page. Thoughts?
 
2bump.gif
cmon now.....no one I know Likes the TSA. ;)
 
I think scrapping the plan is idiotic. They are using the same logic as those that want to ban guns.
 
I think scrapping the plan is idiotic. They are using the same logic as those that want to ban guns.

Sounds like your two sentences are in complete opposition of each other.

Specific to the OP: The whole program, all of TSA, is more to make us "feel safe" rather than to actually "be safe." If someone wants to hold someone hostage, more or less, on an airliner, they can simply grab one of the flight attendants and threaten to snap her neck like a twig.

Hopefully, with our new reinforced flight doors, a policy of never opening them no matter what the threat, and our new "Let's Roll" mentality, without a bomb on board no one is going to take out an airliner ever again. This let's them focus on more important things. Makes us safer. A little bit.
 
Sounds like your two sentences are in complete opposition of each other.

Specific to the OP: The whole program, all of TSA, is more to make us "feel safe" rather than to actually "be safe." If someone wants to hold someone hostage, more or less, on an airliner, they can simply grab one of the flight attendants and threaten to snap her neck like a twig.

Hopefully, with our new reinforced flight doors, a policy of never opening them no matter what the threat, and our new "Let's Roll" mentality, without a bomb on board no one is going to take out an airliner ever again. This let's them focus on more important things. Makes us safer. A little bit.

Not at all in contradiction. I think banning knives and other objects on flights by the TSA is idiotic and does nothing to make us safe just like banning guns doesn't make us safe. The TSA scrapping the plans to allow knives and other objects on board is idiotic IMO.
 
Sounds like your two sentences are in complete opposition of each other.

Specific to the OP: The whole program, all of TSA, is more to make us "feel safe" rather than to actually "be safe." If someone wants to hold someone hostage, more or less, on an airliner, they can simply grab one of the flight attendants and threaten to snap her neck like a twig.

Hopefully, with our new reinforced flight doors, a policy of never opening them no matter what the threat, and our new "Let's Roll" mentality, without a bomb on board no one is going to take out an airliner ever again. This let's them focus on more important things. Makes us safer. A little bit.

Security theater as some call it.

It was dumb to drop the plan. No one is going to hijack a plane with a pen knife ever again. It's simply a waste of time and money to search for these things.
 
Not at all in contradiction. I think banning knives and other objects on flights by the TSA is idiotic and does nothing to make us safe just like banning guns doesn't make us safe. The TSA scrapping the plans to allow knives and other objects on board is idiotic IMO.

I now see what you meant. But that's not what you said.

I think scrapping the plan is idiotic.

And you went and said it again:

The TSA scrapping the plans to allow knives and other objects on board is idiotic IMO.

??

And another poster in conflict:

It was dumb to drop the plan. No one is going to hijack a plane with a pen knife ever again. It's simply a waste of time and money to search for these things.

WTF? What am I not understand here?
 
I now see what you meant. But that's not what you said.



And you went and said it again:



??

As far as I know the TSA was going to allow knives on board, and then scrapped the idea later under pressure did they not? So for them to scrap the plans is idiotic. Not sure where the disconnect is here. They should have continued fighting for it.
 
As far as I know the TSA was going to allow knives on board, and then scrapped the idea later under pressure did they not? So for them to scrap the plans is idiotic. Not sure where the disconnect is here. They should have continued fighting for it.

Ohhhhh, I see. I think the OP is wrong. They DID scrap the plan. Small knives are now allowed. But it SAYS:

By scuttling the plan to drop the knives and sports equipment from TSA's list of prohibited items...

I thought I'd gone crazy. (I still may have, of course.)
 
Ohhhhh, I see. I think the OP is wrong. They DID scrap the plan. Small knives are now allowed. But it SAYS:



I thought I'd gone crazy. (I still may have, of course.)

No worries, I was questioning myself to see if I need another cup of coffee :lol:
 
I like how they threw that one Box cutter on the top of the knives there. :lol: Nice improv on the emphasis. ;)
 
And another poster in conflict:

Originally Posted by Gaius46
It was dumb to drop the plan. No one is going to hijack a plane with a pen knife ever again. It's simply a waste of time and money to search for these things.



WTF? What am I not understand here?

I'm not in conflict unless I misunderstood what you meant. The TSA plan to allow small knives was a good idea. Dropping the plan is a bad idea.
 
Back
Top Bottom