• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report say

jamesrage

DP Veteran
Joined
Jul 31, 2005
Messages
36,705
Reaction score
17,867
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Conservative
This is why I think elected officials and government agents deserve no privacy.People who authorize and or spy on people deserve no privacy.


Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report says - Open Channel

The Department of Homeland Security has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on a network of 77 so-called “fusion” intelligence centers that have collected personal information on some U.S. citizens — including detailing the “reading habits” of American Muslims — while producing “shoddy” reports and making no contribution to thwarting any terrorist plots, a new Senate report states.

The “ fusion centers,” created under President George W. Bush and expanded under President Barack Obama, consist of special teams of federal , state and local officials collecting and analyzing intelligence on suspicious activities throughout the country. They have been hailed by Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano as “one of the centerpieces” of the nation’s counterterrorism efforts.
But a bipartisan report by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations released Tuesday concludes that the centers “often produced irrelevant” and "useless” intelligence reports. “There were times when it was, ‘What a bunch of crap is coming through,’” one senior Homeland Security official is quoted as saying .
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

I read about this yesterday. My conclusion is what I have always suspected to be true--we just are woefully incapable of processing large quantities of random information in a useable way. 90% of this crap is window-dressing to create the illusion we are doing something meaningful.
 
Its justification for funding.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

This is why I think elected officials and government agents deserve no privacy.People who authorize and or spy on people deserve no privacy.


Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report says - Open Channel

The Department of Homeland Security has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on a network of 77 so-called “fusion” intelligence centers that have collected personal information on some U.S. citizens — including detailing the “reading habits” of American Muslims — while producing “shoddy” reports and making no contribution to thwarting any terrorist plots, a new Senate report states.

The “ fusion centers,” created under President George W. Bush and expanded under President Barack Obama, consist of special teams of federal , state and local officials collecting and analyzing intelligence on suspicious activities throughout the country. They have been hailed by Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano as “one of the centerpieces” of the nation’s counterterrorism efforts.
But a bipartisan report by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations released Tuesday concludes that the centers “often produced irrelevant” and "useless” intelligence reports. “There were times when it was, ‘What a bunch of crap is coming through,’” one senior Homeland Security official is quoted as saying .

THIS is a great reason to vote for Romney, if nothing else to get rid of Big Sis.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

I read about this yesterday. My conclusion is what I have always suspected to be true--we just are woefully incapable of processing large quantities of random information in a useable way. 90% of this crap is window-dressing to create the illusion we are doing something meaningful.

Very expensive window dressing, and very unconstitutional window dressing, no matter how you cut it. But then the Fourth Amendment was effectively nullified by the USA Patriot Act, so this is no surprise.

And ROMNEY will only expand the program, just as Obama expanded the Bush version.

As many folks have pointed out for the last 11 years or so, the Global War On Terror is a fraud of epic proportions, and these fusion centers are but a wee part of that hoax.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

THIS is a great reason to vote for Romney, if nothing else to get rid of Big Sis.

How do we know Romney won't just keep it around or expand it like Obama did?
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

How do we know Romney won't just keep it around or expand it like Obama did?

We don't. In fact, he probably will.
 
THIS is a great reason to vote for Romney, if nothing else to get rid of Big Sis.

And you base the idea that Romney will act differently than Bush and Obama on this issue on.........?
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

This is completely unsurprising - DHS is precisely what you would expect from a rapidly-put-together amalgamation of bureaucratic vagaries bereft of good guidance or specific mission oriented ability. The fusion centers are good ideas staffed by fools - I know a woman with over a decades' experience in the IC who went through their training program. The "analysts" she was going through the pipeline with were a bunch of retired school teachers, with zero prior military or intelligence experience. Apparently the bureaucracy over there equates "degrees" with "ability", and all the teachers had "masters degrees", so..... :roll: She quit in disgust.



Hey, you know what? Let's put these people in charge of health care!!!! That's sure to go well.... :roll:
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

How do we know Romney won't just keep it around or expand it like Obama did?

I think only Congress can get rid of a department.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

And you base the idea that Romney will act differently than Bush and Obama on this issue on.........?

I think she did the most to put that department in a bad light.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

This is why I think elected officials and government agents deserve no privacy.People who authorize and or spy on people deserve no privacy.


Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report says - Open Channel

The Department of Homeland Security has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on a network of 77 so-called “fusion” intelligence centers that have collected personal information on some U.S. citizens — including detailing the “reading habits” of American Muslims — while producing “shoddy” reports and making no contribution to thwarting any terrorist plots, a new Senate report states.

The “ fusion centers,” created under President George W. Bush and expanded under President Barack Obama, consist of special teams of federal , state and local officials collecting and analyzing intelligence on suspicious activities throughout the country. They have been hailed by Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano as “one of the centerpieces” of the nation’s counterterrorism efforts.
But a bipartisan report by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations released Tuesday concludes that the centers “often produced irrelevant” and "useless” intelligence reports. “There were times when it was, ‘What a bunch of crap is coming through,’” one senior Homeland Security official is quoted as saying .

I would rather the government not have the power to do this. If any are caught spying on us, they should be removed from office immediately.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

I would rather the government not have the power to do this. If any are caught spying on us, they should be removed from office immediately.

We have a way of removing unsatisfactory politicians from office. It is called "elections". Unfortunately, we seldom exercise our right to get rid of the rascals.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

We have a way of removing unsatisfactory politicians from office. It is called "elections". Unfortunately, we seldom exercise our right to get rid of the rascals.

Senators and congressmen resign after scandals all the time. There are recall votes as well. It is not too far fetched to remove politicians from office when they abuse their power. Waiting for an election takes too long.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

Senators and congressmen resign after scandals all the time. There are recall votes as well. It is not too far fetched to remove politicians from office when they abuse their power. Waiting for an election takes too long.

Umm, sure. How many congresscritters can you think of who have resigned due to scandals? How many have been recalled? You would think that, given the single digits approval rating of Congress, most of them would be replaced in the upcoming election, but that never seems to happen either, does it?
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

Umm, sure. How many congresscritters can you think of who have resigned due to scandals? How many have been recalled? You would think that, given the single digits approval rating of Congress, most of them would be replaced in the upcoming election, but that never seems to happen either, does it?

Recall election - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Recall of State Officials

Recalls do not occur often, but they do happen. There is a list of recalled politicians in both links.

Most politicians resign over sex scandals. But some resigned over a threat of a recall election.

List of federal political sex scandals in the United States - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

Recall election - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Recall of State Officials

Recalls do not occur often, but they do happen. There is a list of recalled politicians in both links.

Most politicians resign over sex scandals. But some resigned over a threat of a recall election.

List of federal political sex scandals in the United States - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

From the Wiki article:

In 2011, there were at least 150 recall elections in the United States. Of these, 75 officials were recalled, and nine officials resigned under threat of recall. Recalls were held in 17 states in 73 different jurisdictions. Michigan had the most recalls (at least 30). The year set a record for number of state legislator recall elections (11 elections) beating with previous one-year high (three elections). Three jurisdictions adopted the recall in 2011.[8]

So, it does work at the state level.

It wasn't so long ago, in fact, that California recalled its governor.

So, it might work at the federal level as well.

Maybe we could hire some hookers and get those sex scandals going... no, I suppose that plot would be uncovered.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

This is why I think elected officials and government agents deserve no privacy.People who authorize and or spy on people deserve no privacy.

Yeah, but this is just another day in Big Brother paradise. Thanks Republocrats, really wanted to live in 1984.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

We have a way of removing unsatisfactory politicians from office. It is called "elections". Unfortunately, we seldom exercise our right to get rid of the rascals.

In a country with 9%-to-18% approval rating for congress and a 90% reelection rate for incumbents?

Stop Repeat Offenders. Don't Re-Elect Them!
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

This is why I think elected officials and government agents deserve no privacy.People who authorize and or spy on people deserve no privacy.


Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report says - Open Channel

The Department of Homeland Security has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on a network of 77 so-called “fusion” intelligence centers that have collected personal information on some U.S. citizens — including detailing the “reading habits” of American Muslims — while producing “shoddy” reports and making no contribution to thwarting any terrorist plots, a new Senate report states.

The “ fusion centers,” created under President George W. Bush and expanded under President Barack Obama, consist of special teams of federal , state and local officials collecting and analyzing intelligence on suspicious activities throughout the country. They have been hailed by Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano as “one of the centerpieces” of the nation’s counterterrorism efforts.
But a bipartisan report by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations released Tuesday concludes that the centers “often produced irrelevant” and "useless” intelligence reports. “There were times when it was, ‘What a bunch of crap is coming through,’” one senior Homeland Security official is quoted as saying .

9/11. Never forget.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

This is why I think elected officials and government agents deserve no privacy.People who authorize and or spy on people deserve no privacy.


Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report says - Open Channel

The Department of Homeland Security has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on a network of 77 so-called “fusion” intelligence centers that have collected personal information on some U.S. citizens — including detailing the “reading habits” of American Muslims — while producing “shoddy” reports and making no contribution to thwarting any terrorist plots, a new Senate report states.

The “ fusion centers,” created under President George W. Bush and expanded under President Barack Obama, consist of special teams of federal , state and local officials collecting and analyzing intelligence on suspicious activities throughout the country. They have been hailed by Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano as “one of the centerpieces” of the nation’s counterterrorism efforts.
But a bipartisan report by the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations released Tuesday concludes that the centers “often produced irrelevant” and "useless” intelligence reports. “There were times when it was, ‘What a bunch of crap is coming through,’” one senior Homeland Security official is quoted as saying .

It will take some time for DHS intelligence to find it's flow. The same is true for all the Intelligence organizations that currently exist. There's quite a bit of trial and error involved with formulation of an effective mission oriented intelligence program.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

It will take some time for DHS intelligence to find it's flow. The same is true for all the Intelligence organizations that currently exist. There's quite a bit of trial and error involved with formulation of an effective mission oriented intelligence program.

the first being deciding just what the mission really is.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

Exactly.

Now, how do we get that message to the average voter?

The average voter doesn't give enough of a rats ass to pay attention.
 
Re: Homeland Security 'fusion' centers spy on citizens, produce 'shoddy' work, report

Exactly.

Now, how do we get that message to the average voter?

Blunt force trauma.
 
Back
Top Bottom