• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

PA Voter ID Law halted per CNN

good move PA!

proud of my state today


and for the record Im totally in favor of voter ID under MY conditions.

that many forms of IDs that already exist are accepted and one can easily and readily be obtained from the state free of charge at many locations including on line and by mail.

Why I didnt want PA to do it NOW is because the time frame was unfair and thats also what PA decided.

Cant implement a law like this so close to elections, thats BS because in REALITY there are many people that would have issues getting an ID and that simply in not right.

Agreed to those conditions, and really, you're right, these changes should be made with plenty of lead time. However, I can't envision the state of PA ever offerring anything for free.
 
Agreed to those conditions, and really, you're right, these changes should be made with plenty of lead time. However, I can't envision the state of PA ever offering anything for free.

LOL well maybe not but thats how it should be, one shouldn't definitely not have to pay to vote.
 
Agreed to those conditions, and really, you're right, these changes should be made with plenty of lead time. However, I can't envision the state of PA ever offerring anything for free.

How much lead time is reasonable? There were elections in the spring. A dry run was held. People were asked for photo ID and informed that they could vote without it this time but would need it for all elections beginning in November. All PennDOT offices offered FREE ID cards to all who needed them.
 
Protecting the rights of the people is exactly what the courts are for. :)

Too bad the US Supreme Court already ruled that requiring photo id's to vote does not violate anyones rights.
 
Protecting the rights of the people is exactly what the courts are for. :)

...unless it's the right to representative government and fair elections/
 
Too bad the US Supreme Court already ruled that requiring photo id's to vote does not violate anyones rights.

I don't think they do either, and neither did the PA judge.
 
The law was popular with everybody including a majority of democrats.
**************************************************************************************************************
Meanwhile, as the state’s new Voter ID law works its way through the courts, the requirement remains popular.

“While judges and politicians debate Pennsylvania’s voter ID measure, voters are solidly in support of the measure, 62 – 35 percent,” said Peter A. Brown, assistant director of the Quinnipiac University Polling Institute. “And 99 percent of voters say they believe they have the necessary documents to cast a ballot.”

F&M found similar support: 59 percent of respondents said they favor the law, while 39 percent said they opposed it.

However, critics who oppose the Voter ID requirement do room to win the public opinion battle. Of those who said initially that they favor the law, 21 percent changed their minds when asked, “Would you still favor this law if you knew that many eligible voters will be prevented from voting because they will not have a proper ID?”

That’s the crux of legal and political arguments against the law.

51 percent of respondents oppose the law when that 21 percent are figured in, while 47 percent remain opposed
Polls: Corbett Not Popular, But Voter ID Is | PoliticsPA

...all moot. One of the primary roles of the court is to protect the minority from the tyranny of the majority.
 
Surely you mean an unbiased judge disallowing an obvious politically motivated law designed to solve a problem that does not exist?

I think it is wonderful to have a law that will allow a republican to win. But I know that democrats will complain that they need cheating in order to ensure their victories.
 
How much lead time is reasonable? There were elections in the spring. A dry run was held. People were asked for photo ID and informed that they could vote without it this time but would need it for all elections beginning in November. All PennDOT offices offered FREE ID cards to all who needed them.
This isn't about that. It is about democrat cheating. If elections are fair they have a very difficult time winning.
 
Back
Top Bottom