• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Strain..

jamesrage

DP Veteran
Joined
Jul 31, 2005
Messages
36,705
Reaction score
17,867
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Conservative
This world does not need a deadlier strain of the bird flu. These scientists should be criminally charged and thrown into prison.

U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Strain of Bird Flu | Fox News

[h=1]U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Strain of Bird Flu[/h]

The U.S. government is sounding the alarm after reports that Dutch scientists have created a highly-contagious and deadly airborne strain of bird flu that is potentially capable of killing millions, The Independent reported Tuesday.
The U.S. National Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity is currently analyzing how much of the scientists' information should be allowed to be published—given the inherent risks of having the information fall into the hands of terrorists or rogue states.
"The fear is that if you create something this deadly and it goes into a global pandemic, the mortality and cost to the world could be massive," a senior US government adviser told The Independent.
Scientists, too, are questioning whether the science should ever have been performed in the first place.
"There are people who say that the work should never have been done, or if it was done it should have been done in a setting where the information could be better controlled," a source close to the US biosecurity board told the newspaper.

 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

If I remember correctly this happened a year or so ago.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

What is interesting is nothing in the article states "why" it was created. The paper should not be published.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

If I remember correctly this happened a year or so ago.

Did this story only receive a token mention last year?I do not remember hearing about it.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

jamesrage said:
Did this story only receive a token mention last year?I do not remember hearing about it.

No, I believe it's getting mention now because the paper is being published soon. I can't find the original news story about this; it used to be linked on the avian flu Wiki page but it's not there.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

What is interesting is nothing in the article states "why" it was created. The paper should not be published.

The paper should be burned and any digital copies erased.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

I don't see the point of engineering something like this. Can someone with a bio-science background weigh in on this?

Science will continue to claim that it is not responsible for its discoveries since it is only pursuing knowledge, but some scientists will continue to push the envelope. There is something to be said for human advancement in that we must learn to live with our most dangerous knowledge, but I do think this research is irresponsible.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

No, I believe it's getting mention now because the paper is being published soon. I can't find the original news story about this; it used to be linked on the avian flu Wiki page but it's not there.

Sounds like the media is derelict in its duty to report stories.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

The reason the reason the dutch scientists are doing this is because there is a risk the virus could mutate into the deadly airborne form naturally. Being able to identify the signs in advance would prove vital to limiting the damage in an outbreak. There is no guarantee of safety no matter what we do, its simply a matter of weighing the risk of either option.

It will take in-depth research and number crunching to figure out what to do. A genetic analysis of H5N1 and the number of mutations needed will need to be done in order to obtain the odds of natural mutation. This needs to be counterbalanced against an analysis of groups capable of creating such a bioweapon and having the willingness to use it.

Most important, we need a vaccine yesterday. This is not only an issue of national security but of global security. Vaccination research and production should receive priority defense funding immediately.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

The reason the reason the dutch scientists are doing this is because there is a risk the virus could mutate into the deadly airborne form naturally. Being able to identify the signs in advance would prove vital to limiting the damage in an outbreak. There is no guarantee of safety no matter what we do, its simply a matter of weighing the risk of either option.

It will take in-depth research and number crunching to figure out what to do. A genetic analysis of H5N1 and the number of mutations needed will need to be done in order to obtain the odds of natural mutation. This needs to be counterbalanced against an analysis of groups capable of creating such a bioweapon and having the willingness to use it.

Most important, we need a vaccine yesterday. This is not only an issue of national security but of global security. Vaccination research and production should receive priority defense funding immediately.

If what you say is true, then the article did a poor job of reporting and should of reported it as a way to help in the event the virus mutates on its own.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

I don't see the point of engineering something like this. Can someone with a bio-science background weigh in on this?

Science will continue to claim that it is not responsible for its discoveries since it is only pursuing knowledge, but some scientists will continue to push the envelope. There is something to be said for human advancement in that we must learn to live with our most dangerous knowledge, but I do think this research is irresponsible.

The only validity behind publishing this would be discussing the techniques they used to mutate the viral DNA and create the virus. There would be scientific validity and value regarding the publishing of these techniques due to viral therapies (using viruses to treat diseases such as cancer) being something that several scientists are looking into. Although this is assuming that they engineered a new protocol for such procedures. I don't understand why they would have to preform their experiments in order to create a more dangerous version of the bird flu though or the exact mutations and details behind creating it.
 
Last edited:
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

The reason the reason the dutch scientists are doing this is because there is a risk the virus could mutate into the deadly airborne form naturally. Being able to identify the signs in advance would prove vital to limiting the damage in an outbreak. There is no guarantee of safety no matter what we do, its simply a matter of weighing the risk of either option.

It will take in-depth research and number crunching to figure out what to do. A genetic analysis of H5N1 and the number of mutations needed will need to be done in order to obtain the odds of natural mutation. This needs to be counterbalanced against an analysis of groups capable of creating such a bioweapon and having the willingness to use it.

Most important, we need a vaccine yesterday. This is not only an issue of national security but of global security. Vaccination research and production should receive priority defense funding immediately.
There is only one solution, drop a hydrogen bomb on the Dutch. ;)
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

What is interesting is nothing in the article states "why" it was created. The paper should not be published.

It was created to study how this virus can mutate to be more infectious. There are other lab that has done this too - it's just a matter of time, better to have the people who work in developing vaccines understand the mechanism and come up with a vaccine to make the virus less harmful.
 
Last edited:
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

The reason the reason the dutch scientists are doing this is because there is a risk the virus could mutate into the deadly airborne form naturally. Being able to identify the signs in advance would prove vital to limiting the damage in an outbreak. There is no guarantee of safety no matter what we do, its simply a matter of weighing the risk of either option.

It will take in-depth research and number crunching to figure out what to do. A genetic analysis of H5N1 and the number of mutations needed will need to be done in order to obtain the odds of natural mutation. This needs to be counterbalanced against an analysis of groups capable of creating such a bioweapon and having the willingness to use it.
.
And it would mutate naturally into the strain that the mad scientists created? Its sounds like bull **** execuse.Its like saying lets makes a dangeorus new disease just in case we run across another dangerous disease.


Most important, we need a vaccine yesterday. This is not only an issue of national security but of global security. Vaccination research and production should receive priority defense funding immediately

This should not involve making deadlier strains of whats out there.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

And it would mutate naturally into the strain that the mad scientists created? Its sounds like bull **** execuse.Its like saying lets makes a dangeorus new disease just in case we run across another dangerous disease.

This should not involve making deadlier strains of whats out there.

It's not an excuse, the aim of the paper was to study the mutation mechanism so as to develop a way to stop it. It's hard to develop flu vaccines because the virus mutate so quickly, staying one step ahead could be helpful. On the other hand, there is an arguement to be made that having created the virus, there could be a leak from the laboratory that stores it like the foot and mouth virus a while back - if this one escape, we are screwed.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

And it would mutate naturally into the strain that the mad scientists created? Its sounds like bull **** execuse.Its like saying lets makes a dangeorus new disease just in case we run across another dangerous disease.

You are using the appeal to ridicule fallacy. People made the same ignorant argument against the small pox vaccine. The concept is perfectly valid, the only question is if the actual probabilities are high enough to be worth the risk.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

If something wrong was done dont blame the scientests. Blame the bosses and $$$ behind them.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

More fear-mongering from FauxNews
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

More fear-mongering from FauxNews

Fear mongering, How? Since when is reporting that scientists making deadlier strains of diseases a from of fear mongering? Is this some boo hoo lib-tard we hate fox news rant of yours?
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

Fear mongering, How? Since when is reporting that scientists making deadlier strains of diseases a from of fear mongering? Is this some boo hoo lib-tard we hate fox news rant of yours?

Leaving out the valid reasons for doing this serves their agenda of fear-mongering.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

Leaving out the valid reasons for doing this serves their agenda of fear-mongering.

Is Miss Cleo working as a scientist for the Dutch and they know exactly what strain the disease would mutate naturally on it's own so they can 'coincidentally' have an available vaccine? They should not be making deadlier diseases on the chance that disease might evolve into a deadlier strain. It amounts to creating a new disease.


Stuff like this only makes it look like companies are deliberately making new strains in order to profit from vaccines.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

Is Miss Cleo working as a scientist for the Dutch and they know exactly what strain the disease would mutate naturally on it's own so they can 'coincidentally' have an available vaccine? They should not be making deadlier diseases on the chance that disease might evolve into a deadlier strain. It amounts to creating a new disease.


Stuff like this only makes it look like companies are deliberately making new strains in order to profit from vaccines.

More fear mongering, this time with a bunch of nutty conspiracy-mongering tossed in to boot.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

More fear mongering, this time with a bunch of nutty conspiracy-mongering tossed in to boot.

There is nothing fear mongering or conspiracy-mongering about it.They took a already dangerous disease and made it even more deadlier.They took bird flu and made it into super bird fly.They hope that they might be able to create a vaccine for it just in case coincidentally the bird flu was to naturally evolve on its own into a strain the scientists made. Can you explain why any intelligent person would not see it as a scam or think that is not it is too dangerous to make diseases more deadlier? Sitting there like a retard and saying its dat der feear mongering is not a answer.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

There is nothing fear mongering or conspiracy-mongering about it.They took a already dangerous disease and made it even more deadlier.They took bird flu and made it into super bird fly.They hope that they might be able to create a vaccine for it just in case coincidentally the bird flu was to naturally evolve on its own into a strain the scientists made. Can you explain why any intelligent person would not see it as a scam or think that is not it is too dangerous to make diseases more deadlier? Sitting there like a retard and saying its dat der feear mongering is not a answer.

WRONG!! Everyone knows mechanics evolve the problems with your car in order to learn more about possible future problems and NOT to generate a new source of income.
 
Re: U.S. Bio-Security Officials Sound Warning After Scientists Create Deadly New Stra

WRONG!! Everyone knows mechanics evolve the problems with your car in order to learn more about possible future problems

This has nothing to do with deliberately creating dangerous disease. They didn't study the bird flu they made a super bird flu. This super bird flu could get out,or some terrorists could use this research to make their own super bird flu. This is not same as studying how a car works.

and NOT to generate a new source of income.

Pharmacies are a charity organization that hand out free medicines and vaccines?
 
Back
Top Bottom