• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Flood of food imported to U.S., but only 2 percent inspected

jamesrage

DP Veteran
Joined
Jul 31, 2005
Messages
36,705
Reaction score
17,867
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Conservative
Another reason to look on food packages to see where it is from.

Flood of food imported, just 2 percent inspected - Health - Food safety - msnbc.com
EAST LOS ANGELES, Calif. — At a sprawling warehouse here, two investigators from the U. S. Food and Drug Administration watched intently as 50 boxes of preserved bean curd from China were emptied into a grinding machine.
The monstrously loud apparatus worked its way through 1,800 glass bottles, grinding the glass and spewing out a stream of chunky yellow ooze that would be collected, treated and disposed of in the sewer system.
FDA investigators had decided that the bottles of bean curds were improperly heat-sealed and, as a result, were susceptible to harmful bacteria like botulism, which can be fatal.
The case of the destroyed bean curds was relatively straightforward: They had been flagged as suspect as soon as they arrived in port due to a defective heat seal and were sent directly to an FDA warehouse for testing.
That’s not always how it happens.
The FDA’s Los Angeles district is one of the busiest in the U. S., overseeing the inspection of more than half a million food shipments arriving through 24 ports of entry in the L.A. area. Through the port stream products like Cambodian rice by the ton, tapioca pearls from the Philippines, tea biscuits from China, sugar cane and fish from around the world.
In 2010, about 3,500 shipments here were refused entry because they were contaminated with filth, pesticides, drug residue or traces of salmonella, according to a News21 analysis of the FDA's database of import refusals. Some of the imports contained unsafe color additives or were mislabeled. And some were even poisonous.
Nationwide, the FDA said that last year it rejected nearly 16,000 food-related shipments out of more than 10 million that arrived in more than 320 ports.
“If it comes in here and it’s bad,” said Denise Williams, a supervisor in the FDA’s Division of Import Operations in Southern California, “we’re gonna get ‘em.”
 
Curiosity: What's your solution?

Hire more health inspectors and charge these companies extra fees to fund the hiring of these health inspectors.
 
I think the best solution is to blame Bush.
 
Hire more health inspectors and charge these companies extra fees to fund the hiring of these health inspectors.

This - why haven't they done this yet?

But how silly is this:
PREDICT, or Predictive Risk-based Evaluation for Dynamic Import Compliance Targeting
what did they do - name it "Predict" and then they had to come up with a bunch of bigger words to say what it does? "we need a D! . . . how about 'Dynamic?'"
 
I think the best solution is to blame Bush.

No, the entire right wing. Not just bush*

Michele Bachmann: Food Industry Overregulated

Boehner’s District Suffers From E. Coli Outbreak As House Republicans Try To Gut Food Safety | ThinkProgress

As ThinkProgress reported yesterday, despite yet another outbreak of food-borne illness — this time stemming from listeria infected cantaloupes — congressional Republicans are still trying to cut back on the nation’s food safety regulations. The tainted melons have caused 16 deaths so far, making this the deadliest outbreak in more than a decade, and it comes just a month after salmonella-tainted turkey forced food-giant Cargill into the third-largest food recall on record
 

If you think we can ever spend enough money to ensure that 100% of our food supply is safe, you are naive. 70-some illnesses; 16 deaths. That's NOTHING. Inconsequential. Unless you're one of the 70-some. Our food supply is probably the safest on planet earth. But it is not and cannot be foolproof.

The FDA knows what farm these melons came from and still can't figure out what happened. Why is the answer always more money? Why not fewer paper-pushers and more people in the field?? And even at that, we're going to have food-borne illness. Life's not perfect.
 
Duplicate post deleted.
 
Last edited:
This - why haven't they done this yet?

But how silly is this: what did they do - name it "Predict" and then they had to come up with a bunch of bigger words to say what it does? "we need a D! . . . how about 'Dynamic?'"

Greed of the companies.
 
If you think we can ever spend enough money to ensure that 100% of our food supply is safe, you are naive. 70-some illnesses; 16 deaths. That's NOTHING. Inconsequential. Unless you're one of the 70-some. Our food supply is probably the safest on planet earth. But it is not and cannot be foolproof.

The FDA knows what farm these melons came from and still can't figure out what happened. Why is the answer always more money? Why not fewer paper-pushers and more people in the field?? And even at that, we're going to have food-borne illness. Life's not perfect.

Since no one is arguing for perfection (ie 100%), that is a straw man

IMO, we should and can do a lot better than 0%, which is what the rightwingers want
 
Since no one is arguing for perfection (ie 100%), that is a straw man

IMO, we should and can do a lot better than 0%, which is what the rightwingers want
Which rightwingers want 0%?
 
Take one example - the ridiculous food safety regulations. By forcing smaller, marginal family farms out of business, these regulations reduce competition, promote monoculture which increases the chance of a disease or blight decimating an entire food species, and increases contamination risk as food sources and storage is centralized. To boot, these regulations increase fuel consumption and air pollution as food is shipped across ever farther distances. Our food supply has steadily become safer over the years even as media reporting of food issues tripled in the past decade. But regulations spawned by populist politicians, supported by a unquestioning society educated by a sensationalist media, will reverse the long-term trends of the ever safer food supply.

Why the Small Business Failure Rate Is 90 Percent Smoke and Mirrors | BNET

De-regulation doesn't mean, "Katy, bar the door." It means getting rid of those archiac rules and regulations that do no good. But, hey, I guess just mentioning the word, "de-regulation," if you're a Republican, makes you a target. Get educated!!!
 
Why the Small Business Failure Rate Is 90 Percent Smoke and Mirrors | BNET

De-regulation doesn't mean, "Katy, bar the door." It means getting rid of those archiac rules and regulations that do no good. But, hey, I guess just mentioning the word, "de-regulation," if you're a Republican, makes you a target. Get educated!!!

No, de-regulation means getting rid of all the rules. You're talking about "regulation reform"

From my earlier link
As ThinkProgress reported yesterday, despite yet another outbreak of food-borne illness — this time stemming from listeria infected cantaloupes — congressional Republicans are still trying to cut back on the nation’s food safety regulations. The tainted melons have caused 16 deaths so far, making this the deadliest outbreak in more than a decade, and it comes just a month after salmonella-tainted turkey forced food-giant Cargill into the third-largest food recall on record

People are dying, and the republicans think there's TOO MUCH regulation :cuckoo:

House Republicans vote to cut funds to implement food safety law - The Washington Post
 
No, de-regulation means getting rid of all the rules. You're talking about "regulation reform."

Find me her quote. She says nothing about deregulation. Here's what an unbiased news source has to say about her comment:

Bachmann visited a family-owned meat packing plant in Des Moines, Iowa, on Tuesday to argue that Americans want safety but also common sense. She warned against regulatory "overkill" and said that regulations can be so complex that they become expensive to the point of putting companies out of business.

Here's another real news source that says:

“It is more regulation than this business has ever had before,” Bachmann said, as she pointed to a binder of papers. “Now it’s gotten to the point where one employee out of about a half-dozen has to be dedicated, full-time, just to dealing with rules and regulations. This is just one business, but it is replicates all around the United States.”

Bachmann didn’t specifically say which regulations she thought were “overkill,” but regulatory reform — be it the tax code, the Environmental Protection Agency, Department of Education, or some other federal agency — is a theme most Republicans seeking the nomination for president have hit on during their Iowa travels.

Bachmann criticizes Obama, food industry while in Des Moines | Iowa Caucus 2012

Stop reading blogs and leftie loonies. Get the facts for yourself, Sangha.

People are dying, and the republicans think there's TOO MUCH regulation :cuckoo:

House Republicans vote to cut funds to implement food safety law - The Washington Post

Sixteen people in this latest report. That is hardly an indictment of our food industry. We have the safest food supply on planet earth.
 
Find me her quote. She says nothing about deregulation. Here's what an unbiased news source has to say about her comment:



Here's another real news source that says:



Bachmann criticizes Obama, food industry while in Des Moines | Iowa Caucus 2012

Stop reading blogs and leftie loonies. Get the facts for yourself, Sangha.



Sixteen people in this latest report. That is hardly an indictment of our food industry. We have the safest food supply on planet earth.

De-regulation means eliminating regulation, not reforming it.

3000 people die every year and millions get sick. It costs the nation billions of dollars. Ignoring the problem won't make it go away. Whining about regulations wont work either
 
De-regulation means eliminating regulation, not reforming it.

3000 people die every year and millions get sick. It costs the nation billions of dollars. Ignoring the problem won't make it go away. Whining about regulations wont work either

Show me where she said deregulation. Anywhere. You know, with quotes around it. From a reliable source. Stop pickin' up with loonie lefties are puttin' down....unless you are one of them, of course.
 
Show me where she said deregulation. Anywhere. You know, with quotes around it. From a reliable source. Stop pickin' up with loonie lefties are puttin' down....unless you are one of them, of course.

Funny how you want to focus on one link and ignore the ones where the republicans passed laws making it impossible for the FDA to enforce the food safety laws.

Actually, it's not funny; it's sad. 3000 people die every year from unsafe food, mostly young children and seniors, and you want to focus on ONE republican. Meanwhile, the GOP is making it impossible for the FDA to inspect imported food.
 
Funny how you want to focus on one link and ignore the ones where the republicans passed laws making it impossible for the FDA to enforce the food safety laws.

Actually, it's not funny; it's sad. 3000 people die every year from unsafe food, mostly young children and seniors, and you want to focus on ONE republican. Meanwhile, the GOP is making it impossible for the FDA to inspect imported food.


On the plus side, imported foods tend towards the expensive, over their domestic counterparts, and usually, it's the wealthier folks that buy them. Now THAT'S class biological warfare, lol.
 
On the plus side, imported foods tend towards the expensive, over their domestic counterparts, and usually, it's the wealthier folks that buy them. Now THAT'S class biological warfare, lol.

Much of the food we import has no counterpart in our domestic supplies (the article mentions fermented tofu), and in the case of staples (ex rice), the imports are often cheaper
 
I'm guessing several posting here don't do much grocery shopping because when you are looking at fresh produce in grocers everything from onions to spinach to green beans to cantaloupe to bananas are imported. I buy American whenever possible, but is often difficult to find fresh food grown in America.
 
Funny how you want to focus on one link and ignore the ones where the republicans passed laws making it impossible for the FDA to enforce the food safety laws.

Actually, it's not funny; it's sad. 3000 people die every year from unsafe food, mostly young children and seniors, and you want to focus on ONE republican. Meanwhile, the GOP is making it impossible for the FDA to inspect imported food.

Show me a quote where any Republican said he/she wanted to deregulate the food industry. You can't because it's all baloney.

Is this what is going to happen every single time Republicans try to rein in spending?? On everything?? It's 2-cents away from "Ohhhhh, the chilllllldren!!!!" What a joke.

BTW, most of those deaths, it's 3,000 actually, are from home-prepared and restaurant food. Not from our food chain. The people who die have weakened immune systems, for the most part, are sick from other things, or are old. 3,000 is nothing in the scheme of things.
 
I'm guessing several posting here don't do much grocery shopping because when you are looking at fresh produce in grocers everything from onions to spinach to green beans to cantaloupe to bananas are imported. I buy American whenever possible, but is often difficult to find fresh food grown in America.

Right you are. Fresh food year-round from all over the globe. We are blessed. If we were left with what was "in season" from our country, our dinner tables would look much different.
 
Show me a quote where any Republican said he/she wanted to deregulate the food industry. You can't because it's all baloney.

Is this what is going to happen every single time Republicans try to rein in spending?? On everything?? It's 2-cents away from "Ohhhhh, the chilllllldren!!!!" What a joke.

BTW, most of those deaths, it's 3,000 actually, are from home-prepared and restaurant food. Not from our food chain. The people who die have weakened immune systems, for the most part, are sick from other things, or are old. 3,000 is nothing in the scheme of things.

Actually, most of those deaths are from comtaminated produce or meat. That's why we need more inspectors, not less. And many of those with weak immune systems are young children

Your arguments sound like your getting desperate. Your disregard for 3000 deaths is a troll-like argument.
 
Back
Top Bottom