• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

The Gunslinger: Ruined Before it's Started

I liked the ending to The Mist. It hit me pretty hard.

I liked it too, it wasn't your typical Hollywood ending (Im so sick of those) and it was a lot better than King's written ending (his story ends when they leave the grocery store) imo.
 
Yes. It ruins it for me. Not specifically because Alba is black, but because to my mind, Roland is who King says he was, who I pictured, and who the illustrated books pictured. It's not necessarily a race thing, it's a decisional thing in that there were plenty of actors who would have fit the role better.

:lol:

Now it's not about race? You just said it's because he's black. That Roland's ethnicity wasn't up for interpretation. The piercing blue eyes. And that Elba's race would spoil the racial dynamic between Roland and Detta. :confused:

And I also happen to think highly of Tom Hanks as an actor. He's shown the ability to pull off everything from comedy to serious drama and won Oscars for it and I think that were he a little younger he could have played the role of Roland quite well.

Tom Hanks is the best actor of his generation. But that doesn't amount to unlimited versatility; doesn't mean he's suitable for any role. Tom Hanks has a friendly, homey kind of presence. A good dad type. He's almost completely unintimidating. He wouldn't fit as a sociopathic villian or a sexy action hero, as examples. Nor a gunslinger IMHO.

I don't see why sticking to key character traits is so difficult. What's going to happen with Detta Walker/Susannah? The racial dynamics of the story are key. Did you read the same books I did?

We're talking eight books here. Into a movie that's what, two and half maybe three hours? There's depth in the novels that just isn't going to make it onto the screen. I think you're overstating the importance of race to the story. There can still be tension between roland and detta. Sure maybe the context of the tension is massaged a bit to make more sense. There's so much to love about the series I can't see how that ruins everything else. And Mr. King himself agrees.
 
I'm a fan of Stephen King's Gunslinger series. There are many of us. For years and years we've waited for the movie industry to begin putting this franchise onto the silver screen. And now they're finally doing it.

And they're totally going to screw it up.

Now stick with me here; this isn't a racist rant. I'm quite the lefty, but what's happening here really bothers me.

Roland Deschain is the main character of the series. King describes Roland several times as looking something similar to Clint Eastwood with "blue bombardier's eyes."

So who's going to play Roland?

DeCaprio might have been able to pull it off.
If Tom Hanks were younger, he could have done it. Same with Jeff Bridges (and Clint Eastwood obviously)
If only Heath Ledger was still alive.
Joseph Gordon Levitt? A little out there, but the guy is talented.
Matt Damon? Hmm. He could probably pull it off. Definitely.
Ben Affleck? It's a risk, but with the right direction and cast around him, he would have been a possibility.
Jude Law? Definitely, because Roland's background is similar to the Arthurian legend and so a Roland with a British accent is well within the boundaries of the role.
Christian Bale? Yes! M'f'ing Christian Bale would have killed in the role of Roland.

But who did the studio choose instead of all the above to make what could have been a franchise of 3+ movies (at least 3 movies)?

Idris Alba.

Yes, that Idris Alba; the black, kinda chubby actor from The Wire.

If you've read The Gunslinger series, in whole or in part, you understand how untenable this is. Roland Deschain is not a black guy. His ethnicity was never up for interpretation and you never wondered, "Is Roland a black guy?" That's because King describes him as a white guy, and in the illustrated books, Roland is always a white guy. And a big part of the series is the tension between a black female character, her alter ego, and the other members of Roland's ka-tet.

This is such a monumentally bad idea, that it's hard to believe it's happened. I refuse to go see these movies and I'm in the midst of a nerd meltdown about it. I don't pay the whole "politically correct" stuff much mind for various reasons, but this is just that, run totally amok. Some Hollywood tools came up with the idea that they'd put their own spin on this epic series: "Hey, let's turn this thing on its head and make Roland a black guy!"

No, you dummies.

Peter Jackson didn't do that with the LOTR. Fans would have crapped cats if Jackson would have had Kevin Hart in the role of Frodo Baggins and Morgan Freeman as Gandalf. Sorry, it just doesn't work because Tolkien didn't write those characters as having those characteristics.

And King, being a what even I will say is a d-bag liberal, didn't have the nads to stand up and say, "You're not doing that to my greatest work!!!" Instead he thinks it's great (he's either lying or has his head stuck so far up his own backside that he doesn't realize what a gigantic middle finger this is to the fans of the series).

This just blows. Sorry for the rant.

This chubby black guy?

Idris elba.jpg

That's the only Idris Elba I know, and he's a badass. His name as been bandied around for several years to replace Daniel Craig as James Bond.
 
That's the only Idris Elba I know, and he's a badass. His name as been bandied around for several years to replace Daniel Craig as James Bond.

Shhhhh, James bond is going to be ruined for OP if he finds out. :lol:
 
I would LOVE Elba as Bond. Especially since I adhere to the Bond = Call sign as opposed to Bond = Bond theory. The only thing I'd be disappointed with in terms of superficial casting things with regards to Bond would be if they cast someone who couldn't pull off a British accent. I don't even really care which dialect, though I'm sure proper Brits might, but I'd want it to be at least something within that gamut.
 
Back
Top Bottom