• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Israel Starts Rehab in Prison

Gladiator

Verifier
DP Veteran
Joined
Jun 21, 2007
Messages
4,682
Reaction score
660
Location
Suburbia
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Israel is starting to utilize Criminon and Narcanon criminal rehabilitation programs in the Israeli prisons. Arab prisoners are aparenly not being excluded from the prsion reahab programs.

http://www.criminon.org/graduation gallery1/pages/Nizan Graduation 12 2003 ISRAEL.htm

Tel Aviv to try Scientology founder's drug rehab program

http://www.allbusiness.com/middle-east/israel/858801-1.html

By utilizing effective programs to have offenders internalize the skills and values that make constructive member of society, the release of rehabilitated offenders from Isreali prisons would decrease the Arab and Islamic support for Terrorism against the West.



.
 
When I was in the IDF, I was assigned one day to visit a Palestinian girl who was in prison for conspiracy to commit terrorism. Shinbet had uncovered a Palestinian suicide-bombing plot and captured the 'active-team' members as they were on the road to their staging area. This girl was one of four persons inside the vehicle when it was stopped. At her trial, she admitted her part in the plot and was sentenced to a seven year term.

When I visited her in prison, she was 21 and had already served three years of her sentence. She was very pretty and quite intelligent. We spoke in Arabic and engaged in a bit of small talk. I inquired as to her health and the prison conditions. She replied that she was in good health and had no complaints about either the prison or its staff. She stated that she was never threatened or abused at any point after her arrest.

She then did something extraordinary. She read the prison plastic ID card that was clipped to my blouse which included my name and military rank among other things. The ID card was printed entirely in Hebrew. I was fairly amazed and asked her how she had acquired this language ability.

She told me that after about the first month of incarceration, the prison staff had informed her that she could attend class in any of a number of academic courses offered. The first course she selected was Hebrew. At the time of the interview, she was also taking three other academic courses. I complimented her on her Hebrew, and she complimented me on my Arabic. We talked for approximately four hours, alternating between the two Semitic languages.

She had volunteered for the terror mission after her favorite cousin had been killed in a shootout with IDF forces. In retrospect, she now felt that vengence was morally wrong and she deeply regretted her earlier decision to wreak havoc on Israeli civilians. Upon release, she planned to attend university and obtain a degree. At the end, we hugged and parted as friends. I resolved to keep tabs on her case.

After serving four years of her seven year sentence, she was released. She returned to the West Bank and enrolled in a university. She subsequently obtained a college degree, became duly employed, and married her childhood sweetheart.

Her professional duties require her to travel extensively, but her prison record severely curtailed her ability to traverse checkpoints in a timely manner. To help alleviate this bottleneck, I provided her with an official letter of introduction and a signed and sealed military directive. All travel headaches have ceased.

To this day we remain very close friends and frequently chat for hours in outdoor cafe's over our cups of delicious sweet tea :mrgreen:
 
Dear Tashah,

I wish there were more avenues for establishing the respect and trust that your encouragement of the Palestinian lady prisoner illustrates.

To me, rehabilitation usually requires more than academic education. Certainly academic education can be a component of rehab. But increased social skills, self-disipline, self-awareness, understaning and responding to variations in attitudes are some of the components of Criminon and Narcanon. I pesonally keep a copy of the Scientology Tone Scale of attitudes in my wallet, for a handy reference when my interpersonal relations don't seem to be going well.

So when I said Israel started Rehab, I was not referring to academic programs. I was not aware of the availablility of acadmic courses being available in Israeli prisons for Palestinians. Many Palestinian prisoners are probably not sufficiently oriented toward self-improvement to take advantage of academic courses, to the extent they might be available.

Focusing on Settlements and a Capitol for a Palestinian State seem of secondary importance, to me, as compared to finding more mutual cooperation and respect.


.
 
The majority of Palestinian prisoners are arbitrarily detained in IOF dragnet operations of military aged males. It includes one THIRD of the democratically elected Hamas government who have committed no crime beyond being legally elected. it includes several hundred Palestinian children. Israeli/Zionist Arab incarceration practices are racist and Apartheid to the core.

PeaceMaker-X.gif
 
When I was in the IDF, I was assigned one day to visit a Palestinian girl who was in prison for conspiracy to commit terrorism. Shinbet had uncovered a Palestinian suicide-bombing plot and captured the 'active-team' members as they were on the road to their staging area. This girl was one of four persons inside the vehicle when it was stopped. At her trial, she admitted her part in the plot and was sentenced to a seven year term.

When I visited her in prison, she was 21 and had already served three years of her sentence. She was very pretty and quite intelligent. We spoke in Arabic and engaged in a bit of small talk. I inquired as to her health and the prison conditions. She replied that she was in good health and had no complaints about either the prison or its staff. She stated that she was never threatened or abused at any point after her arrest.

She then did something extraordinary. She read the prison plastic ID card that was clipped to my blouse which included my name and military rank among other things. The ID card was printed entirely in Hebrew. I was fairly amazed and asked her how she had acquired this language ability.

She told me that after about the first month of incarceration, the prison staff had informed her that she could attend class in any of a number of academic courses offered. The first course she selected was Hebrew. At the time of the interview, she was also taking three other academic courses. I complimented her on her Hebrew, and she complimented me on my Arabic. We talked for approximately four hours, alternating between the two Semitic languages.

She had volunteered for the terror mission after her favorite cousin had been killed in a shootout with IDF forces. In retrospect, she now felt that vengence was morally wrong and she deeply regretted her earlier decision to wreak havoc on Israeli civilians. Upon release, she planned to attend university and obtain a degree. At the end, we hugged and parted as friends. I resolved to keep tabs on her case.

After serving four years of her seven year sentence, she was released. She returned to the West Bank and enrolled in a university. She subsequently obtained a college degree, became duly employed, and married her childhood sweetheart.

Her professional duties require her to travel extensively, but her prison record severely curtailed her ability to traverse checkpoints in a timely manner. To help alleviate this bottleneck, I provided her with an official letter of introduction and a signed and sealed military directive. All travel headaches have ceased.

To this day we remain very close friends and frequently chat for hours in outdoor cafe's over our cups of delicious sweet tea :mrgreen:

Amazing story.
 
It includes one THIRD of the democratically elected Hamas government who have committed no crime beyond being legally elected.

Go read the Hamas Charter and then try to repeat that with a straight face.
 
Dear Joe,

If prisoners are given the motivational incentives to overcome normal human resistance to self-improvement, then imprisonment can be a positive, motivating factor for increasing moral influence

If self-improvement is offered as an alternative, then the reason for arrest or detention is less important. The Western legal system devotes much resoures to determining innocense or guilt, and fashioning "fair" laws. The failure to offer constructive alternatives is the crime.





..
 
Back
Top Bottom