Thread: Raped 9-Year-Old Has Abortion

Originally Posted by Kat-2

Right. I know..it was a ''pre-people''. Heard it all.

That's not what I said at all.

Originally Posted by jallman

That's not what I said at all.

Honestly, I do know what you are trying to say. I think unless we are an aborted fetus, one that experienced an abortion, we can't know positively what it is like, or what is felt, no matter what we are told.

Sorry if I came across snarky.

Originally Posted by Kat-2

Honestly, I do know what you are trying to say. I think unless we are an aborted fetus, one that experienced an abortion, we can't know positively what it is like, or what is felt, no matter what we are told.

Sorry if I came across snarky.

It's okay. I do it ALL the time. Especially in abortion threads.

Welcome to DP.

Originally Posted by jallman

It's okay. I do it ALL the time. Especially in abortion threads.

Welcome to DP.

Thank you!

Originally Posted by jallman

No, you're just pathetically ignorant of history and the origins of your own religion.

"Puppet of his church". Not only does your ignorance know no bounds, but it is matched only by your penchant for being a droll little liar, too.

My education dwarfs yours by far. You are a servant of the Catholic establishment. Why do I say this? Because you don't have an opinion ... you have the opinion your church tells you to have.

This is the same fundemental issue I have with Islam and virtually every other organized religion.

When a penitent ceases thinking for himself and lets his church think for him, that man becomes a puppet.

Just because you lack the balls or the foresight or both to admit this fact, does not justify your ad hom attacks on me.

Shame on you.

Originally Posted by Felicity

The youngest mother ever ScienceRoll

Irrelevant.

The girl we're discussing was carrying twins. She would not have lived through the pregnancy.

The Catholic hypocrites responsible for excommunicating those involved in saving this child's life need to be de-frocked and excommunication for gross misconduct.

You can stop defending the stance of Adolf Poplar and his Nazi Brazilian buddy the Archbishop now.

Originally Posted by Vader

Irrelevant.

The girl we're discussing was carrying twins. She would not have lived through the pregnancy.
.

The point is not whether she would have lived, but whether the delivery of the twins could have been delayed to offer them a more likely chance at survival, or even if that was unlikely, delayed until the pregnancy was at a point where it was a threat ACTUALLY, rather than the potential threat that it was. Perhaps it never would have become an ACTUAL threat--though likely it would have. Simply wait until the course is clear, and then do what one must to protect the girl's life. As it was, the preemptive killing of the twins was not a moral imperative.

Originally Posted by Felicity

THERE IS MORE TO THE STORY....




Waiting longer could have given the babies a chance at life--even waiting 6 weeks would have dramatically improved their odds. The girl was already 15 or 16 weeks pregnant. If it became medically necessary, then it would be moral to defend the girls life against the threat of death, but at the point they aborted, that was not the case according to IMIP

With this information, the Bishop did the correct thing according to Catholic teaching. My guess is that the girl's mother wished to hide the fact that her husband is a scum-bag by aborting her grandchildren, and the pro-abortion pres/health minister/media et al are all using this tragedy to further their agenda. Sick--truly sick. That poor girl. With all these people USING her and publicising her personal tragedy, she will most definitely need the ministering of the Church in years to come.

No, Felecity, he did not.

Quit defending the idiotic, hypocritical actions of the Archbastard.

The girl was nine years old and pregnant THROUGH NO FAULT OF HER OWN. This is SUFFICIENT CAUSE for an abortion EVEN IF ADOLF POPLAR DOESN'T LIKE IT.

Second, she WOULD NOT have survived the pregnancy. Her total body weight is 80lbs. Her uterus is not developed enough to carry ONE BABY let alone TWO BABIES!

Shame on you for making excuses for your church.

Truth be told --- I don't like abortion either but I am NOT going to accept that the Catholic church is willing to sacrifice the life a 9 year-old incest victim to save the products of rape.

It's disgraceful!

The Catholic church has behaved hypocritically and shamefully and the archbishop is a hypocrite. He attacked the parent of that girl and the doctors who saved her life because they chose to save the life of an underage rape victim.

This is HYPOCRISY on the part of the church. The archbishop is a DISGRACE. Adolf Poplar is former NAZI ASSHOLE!!!! NOW HE'S JUST AN ASSHOLE!!!!

Originally Posted by Vader

Irrelevant. .

You said ...

Originally Posted by Vader

There is not a 9 year-old female in this world who is physically developed enough to carry a child to term. .

You are simply wrong. Apparently, a 5 year old can do it.

Originally Posted by Vader

No, Felecity, he did not.

Quit defending the idiotic, hypocritical actions of the Archbastard.

The girl was nine years old and pregnant THROUGH NO FAULT OF HER OWN. This is SUFFICIENT CAUSE for an abortion EVEN IF ADOLF POPLAR DOESN'T LIKE IT.

True--but the Bishop wasn't commenting on the legality--he was commenting on the Church's position on the matter--a MORAL position.

Second, she WOULD NOT have survived the pregnancy. Her total body weight is 80lbs. Her uterus is not developed enough to carry ONE BABY let alone TWO BABIES!

And again--perhaps an abortion would have become necessary to protect her life, but at the point they killed the twins, it was not a medical imperative.

Shame on you for making excuses for your church.

Quit your moralizing. You have no ethical standing with your bigoted bull**** spewed like a full bladder-ed two-year old in a warm draft.

Truth be told --- I don't like abortion either but I am NOT going to accept that the Catholic church is willing to sacrifice the life a 9 year-old incest victim to save the products of rape.

That's not what the Church is/was suggesting. You're pissing on a strawman.

It's disgraceful!

The Catholic church has behaved hypocritically and shamefully and the archbishop is a hypocrite. He attacked the parent of that girl and the doctors who saved her life because they chose to save the life of an underage rape victim.

This is HYPOCRISY on the part of the church. The archbishop is a DISGRACE. Adolf Poplar is former NAZI ASSHOLE!!!! NOW HE'S JUST AN ASSHOLE!!!!

And you're the voice of reason...