It's hard to say...both did a really excellent job, AND both fell into the emotional appeal sandtrap...I think I have to vote for jallman because his summary post was more astute. Still, Billo, you did very well--I think you could have gone further concerning the issue of what ACTUALLY shows scientific promise, and you could have offered other angles concerning scientific ethics--but in such a limited time frame/# of posts, you both were pretty awesome.
However...the poll is closed and my vote has been disenfranchised!!!!!!